1911-02-25 — Page 5

PERJURY CASE AT ·

SHANGHAI.

defence.

Feb. 14.

THE HONGKONG TELEGRAPH SATURDAY FEBRUARY 25 1911

-.

Mila 1 4 ford foad the Julge a *155

|

Mr. Opyl-4 hormat id the water,

Ma Dramas let from the a candy of the "Stede Bachange in wh Mahad was abode et

Shta on, Re Neil and

Witness was suspended December 9, and he then took legal advice. Ele identifies the correspondende between himself, and Mr. Hurratt and between his lawyer and Messi. Drantmond White-Cooper and Phillips. The result of the arrangement was that witoos was made legally liable for four Inkle and as to a slave for life. Witness bad evan transnetious with Mr. Carmichael, With regard to the 200 Ayer Tawahs sold to Carmichael on March 30, these were bought by witness from Mr. Sopekh. (Two contracts mande with witness handed confirmed by Carmielivel and Shekh as, bayar and seller respectively The 200 Ayor Hente en qoke to witness to the Taxals.soki to Carmichael on April b, ate effect a Me. Hunter. In the witnes purchased from Mr. Kadoorie afteronop Mr.. Pirie was talking to at 114 27. Witness bought the 200 Batu Andaina, sold to Carmichael on Mr. Neilen in the middle of the ram,

April 7, from Mr. Someth. The con- Miclad will agree I will Mr. Piri tract notes for all these transactions werd to wides quad sil "Well, laak word producat in the Supreme Court. kong Miolet, they are all'aggraed except | Witness produced the contract notes you. You say Yes Witness said for all the other sharos that word the tid in the cirémmpstanis ķe end posaljest of the actions of Mielmol `v. Haurtgage his life for the sake of the Carmichael.

morrow." After wine was taki torget his schedal, and they worth arrive at his defiiey. All the bro kers rushed to ir joneza to make up their schedules and then re- turned to the Exchange an1 from five to right be the ders neralinising

Mr. Doughs-You bought the second lot of Ayer Tawals from Mr. Kadoorie, and I presume the charge is that they were your own shares. There is correction in file porail in your account with Mr. Kadoorie. Can you explain st? The Ayer Tawals are allorel Trom Tis. 26 to Tha, 27,

Witness-There wasgraat excitement in the shares on that day. I unor Mr. Katooris to say Fis. 26 and

Mr. Oppo called for all the contract notos of witness's transactions with Mr. Somekh.

Witness went on to day in farther cross-examination thast Somekh was AR

outside broker. Haproduced a copy of his account for rowipt and delivery delivered by witness to Mr. Somekl for the Jans Settlement. Mr. Somakh had not paid witness. Witness might havo bogun the sooond (missing) book in Fobfiiry. Both books were being run at the same time. There must have been at least 15 names in the second book. Witness land n ofork who was now to the businow and both lo and witness mide amass of things. It was not a fact that tha secon I book was

only started when the first was finishod. I could not help his jurk keeping two accounts on shu ganfe page. It was not afrot that all the accounts in the second book hul merely boon carried forward from the feat. Wilnass could

explain why his clork Ind put Sonckh's name in the second book. At

Tue June Settlamont witness had to reocite Tls. 250 from Mr. Kadoorie., The correction in Kadoorib's account.

I telephone Tis: 20 to my clerk. Mr.in wittess's book was made on the day Kadario handel and a contract, for of the settlement, and was in witness's I had a dispute with his own handwriting. Why was he bound about the price. We asked me to cancel take the correction two contarios the extract. I did tot agree base "go? 1 witness's credit was good onough for Tls. 173,000, Kadoorio the market was, very strong, So I would trust him for Tis. 200. Witness left in a gover position, I had to mal understood from Kadoerie that he was a contract with Mr. Michaol for The buying the shares at Tle. 20. It was 27. Kadorie next day and every day citing day. In the Exchange they wae nagging at me, and saying he bad roll them at T14 27. I caid "No, were drinking champagne and eating. evviare Carmichael had given witness 28." When the Settlement caus. Icaris blanche to buy those shares and as Kadoorio Fout him a contract note at | Tls. 27, witnom gold them to Carmichael at Tis. 27. There was great excitement in the Exchango.

contracts of Cannichel. Counsel matter of fact ho had call the othat he had 19 deliver tà kim at prices settlement day. Beforasites went to owing, the Trust would not press for over bought or over-sold any. Anglo- would submit on that that there was a hana for us and test, therefore iler Tis, in March md he said the Exchange in esllot and saw Mr. pyment, but would, on the contrary, dayas or Java Consolidated. After the complets answer to the first change he would not want the antil that timt he had to deliver the shares in Sainters and asked him wist was to be give thou reasonably time to clear our Juno settlement witness was ill and The second charge was a very differnt thing and he would sell then back to June to a Mr. Davidoon. Hamgge 4- Jonc. Hø rôplied that he did not know „hway and make good our debt, to the|| went away to Japan. matter invloed. Counsel did not "wich Mr. Michael. Mr. Michal realizat | of fatither should give witnes fleese what was going to happen. Witness Toast. The letter to band foregs mo Uro-oxonimod by Mr.. Oppo Mr, H. 8. Oppo appeared to protetorny hand nonls about the prosecution 136,000 on the Sqawang that he eighty Seamanga and that what ver went to the Exchange from the Bank into a position which is quite different Witness sont out settlement necotints, in this case unless ho was cropelled to had for tus March settlement; but of | mange leg d'olerių redusa his Halility, mud bọ saw only Mr. Davidson there to the verbal understanding_come to of which he kept no copies, to his cato and Mr. J.U. E. Douglas for the 'do so, hat, if he might say so, the course he had to buy them for June. The shares were sold to him at a frac-and he said "Well, aby don't you between the spokesman of the Trust and clients. I had had considerable ox- . Douglas said that at the last adding of the seromal citgo exemplified Counsel priseraded to devribs the state tion under T17 Witus as under ke your settlement Witness said the Brokers sul 1.fail to see how the perience in stock-broking, bat he was hearing his Worship framed certain that the rather canning nature of the market dating the rubber boom extract to deliver 89 Seangs at • With whom, Wong ?" There was na- Trust bun assume the attitude it now not a steak-broker in London. Witness. charges against Mr: Sichael, and un-1 of this prosesation. To ded with the ant pointed out that with orders rash-piega aout Tls 400, which meat that Fly there. A broker arrived after ten takes in the matter. It may be im-kept n book-keeper for three months tol intimated that he would open, the secont dange he had to tell the Cut |ing in from til parts of the suttlements by soull have to pay him a clique of minutes and he lift, so witness-went to possible for me to clear everything by from April onward, last year. Some- defence in this Court His Word the there was is intention to commit bager and seller for et otsisparately at in respect of that

nao nywhat long stiny. He can was it was imposibl's for a broker to fipul salon. The $2,000. Instead of doing 100 once brotus and ark this what the end of September unless rates times witness filled in counterfoils to tin aethai | was going to leap, n. "At øløven o'chek materially, improve." In a postscript his contracts, but when he ran ellort bo framed charged on the find two charges à

him mide in the information and omitrary or mislead the Cuit ant that as the orders come in. He describe the gedleman gars

the thero was a coling awl in the after- alded 1 venture to suggest that ural loose ontracts. During the boom in Tae! there was no perjury comitted. | what took place imben quently ani said Sewinnuga saying "Make wo of the ason they came to the conclusión that the Committee of the Stock Exchange he had not time to enter up counter- the third. The charge of perity was There was no quativa Mr. Allebac) that Mr. Miod crude out for a hug Serang ad feturn them to me in there were seven of them who escilla meeting of all brokers concerned fails to the contracts. He und filled up very serious ono un I he asked his Wor-

liip to follow carefully the fact that he wished the Court in that manter, and time agunt Siguier the promissary Jung and whatever der you have not meet the settlement. Mr. Hunter, to discuss the above..

the counter-foils of one book of 100 contracts. The contracts were made would lay bafure hinrand enter then Michael world be band in givier note for the ausou he cold at fuel, puttan over to me in respect of Mr. Phie and Me Ollonlesen "estum his evidence tu trayer u the whold stay caying that he did not want to mortgage | flym." "Ha labi, chat they would na 1 worked the seven," one at a tinge

in duplicato; one copy being given to carefully before he decided shether this for his Worship to see whether there the rest of his life by rigning a promise pay him back the many which he had Hunter said" Don't make trouble. Let

the buyer or to the seller, as the cos was case for the higher Court, ean- siduring, as counsel had said before, leat as a jaw and potpet tuntive in the cory note payable on donant for The Turned over to him when he delivered

ne pass the settlement. I can assure

might be and one copy being retained however intime it is kan sight be hie pria in linging this eve. Arno, Argh, however, he was the shue Wins pat 1 hin your thu tary will negross you, that

by witnos after coffirmation by the having to go before a jury was a very head of the meaning of the its e in the called in signing the unter On July 31. 1. The Senawangs were tho they have no intention to you, they

buyer or seller. Witness's records 7 Mr. Michael rooived a letter saying I only pelir that he had. He sold them pays if interion to do anything but

were his book and his duplicate copios considerable durat to any ofta prom Cott le plaintif was foll

· Counsel proposed to recapitulate dhority

Fed and asked certain" "quoting by that inhen be d'ested lås Thermit boy | at exh ad Th. 1200 a share and be help you." Wingas mulondoaid that

of the contracts. He then gave details The ous me the cost of all had r. Car the Judge he was wied these ques September the Siak xhung, Combo ght than from the same man, Mr. there was a propaal for rome ona to

of his account with Mr. Somekh. tions at a time when Leʻʼbud in igsikind | mitte, word i deci gith kita modeling to | X3 ong, su Th, 1255 a share for June, lend the amount of the deficiency, to michael and he did so beans theine, was on the jeart of plays very is esepte chanteres in his de. He the ads of the Shel Exchange. In what that he had to pay himnable the rettlement to pass. When lawyers a misunderstanding of the way as a food by his Looplatip: you the autuma Mr. Mihad brought suit The 55 a share for three months. witness said then he meant the in which broker, basin

de transmed as on pour own accounting & Carriefeed, but boy hid very "AKU Bhat, he did with the Els. people who wore going to the He believed that brokersani ualet e danas ! Bad se negli at No" file invest in the proslings and he 30,000 situs said that is money my. - Witness replied to Mr. Hunter Be was then a kod » Pe you mom tagit mit my them, t of thivio provede, weit,ints the pockets of the that this was to big a matter to decide the sitaatii heci w of when they had

say that you never,ward may bus la 115 wo It Raportant in the poplt was earnered hay in Sumatrana minuto and asked why he was not been told by their le pulsa lyj-dra and of

Pile, an] Benjaminfrared sous fon days previously judgments in Court. A broker wag of the expaue, in white ga ideration of the dive of Mr. le an agent and as an agent due was cotic. { Jungle "Games Celine dentur 2 G

Medan 1. if hey had pure in misterling When dags eams by had to deliver led to nu indemnity from his pincipal is awer was "Aben The C to her M. Mi had the fan Somawangs The man who po ni thoa tgk ng han fat the guri nparted from the $ Melut Tartibus bad w very for any liability. he might hures, Or- dinary agents did na uz fint, but moding to co di Bug Bagel talar had emig areon with him in rabber share bat a bunker, who was a spent kind of two be wide to show (basiprodida ngofse with the Stork Ex-in dayan the halo give witness, head with as heard Mr. Neilsen say agent, night by the rules of his eiting (that bagab olurely tune in dan

donge lede af de vía el is sign a believed. Th 211,000 Winos ap- and the castom of the plice, stick hidegt stilomak på de sened in etish ha..kompts toties that w Greed on printed this man before florsettlement been given jordi 57 sondi on, give a board pernig was allegit: “llad “pacar bed

and said that there was a cangur manong Jisbility to other person, and in - Easy time com cay ni than nolgien

ile be duets that there would bena» set- plea it was to other hookers, Where and his antyer was "Da"

ilona at... Tine mui replied that if there lisoker did incur that leg lidty, he dought that his Worship nga i domjese

wa asetilment ha mild not help it. was entitled to in lemnity fest hisprin the pendu bon fled there wat al pittily

With eat, this man's elegie witness in eitband at his age Witnes intention der, part cipal. Hega-entitled to that in lar

mid not are the element. I told him that he had lost alat u had March the cabber band had just started and Dust Be conklu mike the settle nity who lead acted within fi. liability and within the requ of hout The ind worth der Faaland er yde atea in canine anel bistars in shares, pas protest met. Jie then hagan a threaten authority, Where, a broker hul not jokkie darligi, after he had ea floret th

dion with the ja ligumarțin the eveld carek We end wou eat, we could him saying "We will expd on Mitud acted within the seaps of his mathouity videung, dei fod to farms Bones uf

g. Carmiliek. Mr. Nielen sloop nothing bat or fers; we did we shall sue you; we will bankrept you" he was denivel al hi denisky. NA; and that was done on Metoder 13

wid dof his know how to fail them. There Witness said that he didnt care. and the du 'ge i coat di là de ke ta| am who was instruited to get to

apen in dean the. Es drouge wa wat as time for difaking: they were Thom Piric softened his vien curl said The inter briker and who Bugatan of this dear father with men .

witekaan. A reply was genciv:1 that imgbling over, each other.” Ak tha that they did not wish to ste kim, and shins did not net within the age of epoke on the 17th and Begin Toorollis su pension from the end lane wils had to gira mem-asked him to go in sud make the his authority, but a pan who bought judderd was d'fhard in the had fagtede with the one of the Stock Exchange The settlement and afterwards collie; what and roll somebody dad's shares and Averille lado and after he mug of the jalpant in this case 901, ahogether. He had to revive held and that they would give him kan ilgisi id a dou- hai bora la mad and lafame then and the Comet a refu alta - Fromborking me sabers of the Exchange, a life. Pirio mid that ther was mu

The banca ho bad to itna leit. Witness wat overwhelmed † TR 27. within Liv prope of his unihority, and rest benia; deals 17th when myn

offer the quedi on of his enspor-ion | Ths._70400, of exire, if what he did came withinsel was invitadoedt tech vitor until the wiis of his de rettent pay brakers over dud abure abat he got by all that het sceneret and he said the seaps of the Cormpt Pmetices Act, 1 & r. - Ni^nel in turaing the muster

aamd bad boy gminta. My.rom them was flc, 8.1,000, at thisWe will make the stita ut to which had never been eaf reed her, hover in limit and on reading the Midied on dawniej 15`r plied dad tebe hack to get ipuna the public. Alout would be liabl».

reports in the new papers come to ale would take tépori vini ny the Fix-the middle of May the market collapsed. This Worship sail that the Act formele in that there might posibly change Company, shafter that he Theme was nothing doing ia dung; very ged to was in the law of England and have been anne ingat nabing be charged with pony, Mr. Darghe Hule bines. Bem were afraid to if it heevme necessary it would be en-

tween him and the sludge arrow what

said that if there was any folity in the meet their oralis 1. they were had passed. On the Saturday how rate,wers given to the Halgeit was, na forced here..

Making die for Sor $10. Witness was Mr. Opps said that ho did not think a better to his cod. M. Dages, la atende, as www evident from the baking his with that; he was ofidil that Mr. 1.aughs hail gives emplate which lus stated that in locking the such a wore tunely, it was not tande to go and mat his clients. The The schelles in the Explungs. The, forced him to reilla at Tls, 26, statement of the law. If a keretetreats he was reported to have realy or intended a pervert the Stock Exchange was like a geog-shop next morning the brakers assembled in Witnes said that Carmichael had an andisek el profit the whole thing de to the Jul;, he made a

Toni judice. Caturel thenge bar, Witness's clients said that the Exabango ran to woke the settle not paid him anything Kadoorio Blandli bo get aside.

nextter of fad ke kontol on the unstion of what was they would not be able to meetment, but no hvker was willing to begin was paid at the rate of Tis. 20 on Mr. Dongin said that it was quite 40 Angli daris an Talat perjury to be said that he would do the retent males the Exchange; they were waiting for the Co-Settland Day. Who Judge and not Mr. Oppe-Is your explanation that parable that the whole transter in cold and Kummings. Mr. dones wouldle with this fully der in the cr The pot sp the prizes as the lifte mitter: When the Committes suived ask my explanations about this tera betet asi to if there was anything yigions, callad to, give evidends that be bend for dat questions are led by the was to mus. Wie pined Mr. Pire, olm was . of the tion though Kadvaris had been bugyou had drink too much?

Witross-No, no. In the afternoon in law, but in considering rau tim rerrived the letter from Monul Julge dil at nete parily dea that 901 to Mr. Back that the Junt Fettle Committee, but acted at aukesi,med to give evidends, should lie wher the wine had evaporated he told where there was gling of that sort Mihat said that if he were called they were relevant to the is-ste. Ament emb! not go through. He is made a speecir to the effort that he had required. As regards the 200 Batu

-mọ Tha. 27. I said it whe Th. 20. Fish the briter was entittel to his at The further bguing be well elog Judga akel que tu to find and spoke to Mr. Pat and Mr. Ollendes- made the rangement for the settle Annams sold on April 7 it was not trad indemnity, two he fet charge that the matter up. Com al wonki sabimit thiago and when he ran to think out sen anl sail "Dan't delay afters for ment with the Cathay. Trast and ex- that witness obtained these shares from was brought against his client was that i d'of this kind she hi hi jalga ut le sight is that are from what 1 see of the public there willphined about guante, ce. Mr. A. Mr. P. C. White, Wo did buy 400 Batu tun feral parcels of 200 Ayer Tawal Wordip hal în de îdá a ca r of perjury, tain things werd to: relevan Console chant of a dane lettlement". Anderson anggested that three Anams from White on April 7 at Tls. abies, and on pred of 200 Bata which was in king a wilful sa teoriji would be able to show if the state- He suggested that thing shotild sit down cheers skoni be given for Mr. Piric, 21, but sold them back to him in two Agotta stires were sold by him as talent with the oljer of examining ments were not reticent to the sand work on a system of earring hot the latter said that he did not want lots of 200 each, nt Tls. 18, on April feber to W. V. Carmichael and were l'indie,'ad where a man saw his

As a matter of fag, the quition whethe poldie an I said “We live on them them. They then rest to the Hong-12 and 13. White was one of witness's ught by him as baker, whetess is and ad iniel him in calling ther Mr. Michalded or did it jade and tast at all the They said kong and Shanghai Baak for the exile-defaulters and owed him Ta. 1,000, tanth sal in fact in making that wate-freshi opilen a ba call himet », plear this ford maquia of fies on which tho || © Oh, it will pas," or something like neat. Witness aw them there like regard to witness's raplins to the int on giving that evidere Mr.matter up, that the requtrikdity was dulge wanted mors evidence on the thit They dit want to face it. be as. Soms were signing and, he Judgo witness thought that the Judge Michaei cauitted wilful and estraga. re Loved Inam bin.

deans be-fraud, and as a tatter of Wits quid. We shall see what we pushed his way to the counter. Mr. in his first question was asking him porjury. Phintiff in that ease brought His Wordp-Was en el invited test it was hit retria, the julge see ant was will be right. You may Loftus Jones was behind the counter whether any of these shares were owned auit in emnexion with seven different. | tocall further evidence?

came to your genges at the last minute," and he said “riga this." Waneas said by him and registered in his own name. -prva metiofs 'against Mr. Carmichael Mr. Donghat--Yes, I understan 1 on Pelea laat was then sworn. He said There was a weting of the Stock What is it and he said Red In his real answer witnesa mirant And he alleged that in re-pest of all from the rejout and from the stateneath he was 56 rears of age and Exchange of Vans 25 sul schemas for Witness explained that he cjub not that by taking from one and paying thoss transactions ho did act as broker of the Judge that cret did na illa maler in Shin hai inee. 1448. puiting through the ethanent were real at the time and that even now it austher, about Tls. 2,00,000 had passed for Mr. Carmichael and as the latterfredi evidens... Mr. danes objected 12 waxon of the original anbers of disease. The tokers had enno 1 took him about a misale" to read a through his hauls, and he received declined to fulfil his contracts he was the case being re-mel. Thit was on the Shanglin Stocks ning the edasion that there wild ba na lowyer's letter. I asked there who nothing for his own pocket. That entitial to resiver an indemnity. Now the 11th at the framing of the in-us,

was born in Bag last and is mother settlement and they were troubling and signal fefore him what it was and they intement, therefore, was perfectly true. in the upper Court in prewing his cre

His Wor-hip-He had not the stor bugange

Arabia. Here anxi and hello a general aid "Oh, nothing in it, sign it. In regard this statement that he had Mr. Michael rested his race upon † then fasun Mr. Michael

Shanghai in 1932 He was

me ting of brakers for the Saturday. When witness bul-sigaad he asked for ever owned any of these shares who proving these coidracks which were Mr. Douglas--No.

elgestel la D. Sas-min's Bene-Various vugge-time and speeches were copy and Mr. Jones said "If you pay witness read that answer after the pro-Yes. prodiced and the evi 'enco

Mr. Douglas then read the report of volat Jasinin at Bombay formule which rand like Greek to wit- for it" Witness a copy Interceelings, he handel a lottor to Mr. put in that these shares were the dudes stement on the 11th year sal in the Settia Highss, na in the crow I they triked five at indirectly, through member of the ones in Court on October 17, think- bought fem certain people. Tho Cona el abd that Mr. Jones tok the School for six months. That was the time. They suggested that they Exohauga Witness was then askel ing that he would then be razilled and Tla. 8 par'sliare-Yes, extracts were submitted, of course in original objection to the ease being re-whole of bis Englih eluetion before all engage Mr. Dennys and Mr. to sign a cheque for Tls, 201,000. On explain himself. He refused to bring you lost TIs. 1 por share on these the usual care to the inpetion in Chambers, he referred to it unhe cheets Shanghai. He wrote Grayrigg at the Hongkong and Shang- of the other side, and un doubt if there the 11th and he repeated it on the 18th. English very badly, and ho always phai Bauk for the pooling arrangement. had bron grižene: available at that time | When a sitne fan it notessary to one assistent ta trindate it fir Thy taveling was adj aired witil the Sunday morning when it was continued

On rasmning, witness said that six the people whom it was allegal they be, might possibly have misled flui Meisrs, D. Sassoan. In March 1899 ware bought from, cound for the dugi stating retain faels te sind as a proto's ekor. In they were di-ensing the settlement an American, refused to sign. Ou Jansda mike his report. This book was defence would have fastened an it very kim ml bis eansed did we find it

1801 in tak to share broking, Me they wanted sons to eme forward 2 witness draw a cheque for Tls. handed in to the Supreme Court, and guts ly. Later, however, after the case hoge eary to call him, the repon-

Badam triding him de basin whh twa lakas of twels. On the Monday 831,000 and tried to put through after the are was orer it was given hd boon decal, this prosecution was

ibility was certainly shifted fer-hi Hosh ndalfen 1808 to 1903, there was no metting The brokers his settinnent, Mr. Grayrigge would to Mr. Jones. Witness called upon Institutel and the charge was framed There was grave respi-ibility on eau-

during which tien he was very ill word supposed to be helped by somebody and him certain shares to deliver and him ono day-ho, did not remember apon the transactions. The pm-

vel in a matter of that sort, jint is wa soution was based on the fact that the certainly lifted from the withealed had been share with two ladi O Manly all the any he had not delivered he wall hand which-21 neked for the ratura of bioger, und bis equal was due to lookershulte vrite indirilul cheques back to Mr. Graynigge in the evening. his looks. Mr. Jonos gave him back seller of those slires, Mr Sonjek, hand to say how a man inta edhe Mr. Ges. MoBain, who are his to the other look ors and wither that day. The same thing surred on Jane 29 one bo it and the Carmichael contracts, whose contract was produced in the up-aided the Court when bi drew his grant support. Piór to March 1910or the next, they weza fold that these and 30 an1 Jaly. All cheques but retains the other book in connexion am buying on my own account. per Co tri, did not exist at all in these onacel's siteation to it. Now with bed about T 450 wel an indivil cheques were not neath but received from the puble would be p the bask he was given, home, and back at Tls, 18 -No, it saited him to

with.romeotherdefaultors. Witness took transactions or that his contract was regard to this statement of Mr. Mid Atle time he was with a great deal ons cheque, On Mowly, Mr. Oller abraintely a bogus one or that the nett million tuls puset, throngifire but he bust some money, with dessen, the Chain, told witness to examine every day by the Committes when he was suspended on December sorat did not acist at all, and the pro- bis hands and asthing for hinf.elf, the word Chiness. He is 12 14 Mr. Saunders, who wanted the Sloot Extangs and the perinne he went to Mr. McKean with the Bention all that, kynning that, they evidence of Mr. Malihow. was enlobod

see him with regard to his who loaned the money. There was n basks mul the contracts. Tho lost had not got the second book which had throught by farge unuate Mr. Hang or Wharf shares an owing to neunt. Witngs won't and he was at defeit on the choque with a had given book wits among there witness handed boca referred to in the oviden of Mr. Michael had made wat of the settlement: this ran it being able to see the the bank for two hour. Me. Saunders of about Tl. 470.000. On July Mr. McKein. Some days afterwards Matthews. To the prontion alleged The actud prosecutor, Mr., Red, Inhares he had to pay Thu 35,000 and looked through his messunts and he about 8.10 p. Mr. Tsoal came and Mr. Mokem asko for the first book. that in the second cake this was a mis hot seen fit to give evidenos in this ense,

it lat nat ham sehid. Tha Mary's all "Go Bid tell them that you have asked witness to sign a promissory note

Witness then went to Mr. Jones and statement. They had it before them but counsel andertal that the real etfernent was very best. Owing to to draw only 60 per cant." That was to for Tls, 173,000, Witness sad that asked for this book, which was given to that, in that book The. 20 was aliorul to procesalats were the Stost Exhange the inbms of sms friends be say that 40 per cent of witness to sign for that amount on demand was him on his signing a receipt for it. Tli, 27 by a blue pencil mark through

induaad to sell short wima Ling's clients were bad. Witnes was nat The the Arabisa Might, ani objected, Wilnoss look it straight to Mr. Mc. the 6 swl the waiting of a 7 avorit. Mr. Dawpriceded to saline then Samurai. Afar ta hel sol Me quite serpin if this was what was said saying that it bokal bettor to sign for Kaan. Mr. Moon then discover- On the same date you sold 200 Batu The book was in exactly the same en videos that he would call,

In the Piris and Mens Bmjenia and Patta

or ricz eds. Witnes esported to Mr. half-a-million. Mr. Tweed atturated that he could not find the second Annams at a different price to Mr. dition when it was produce in the upper Marsell-meat the defendunt temeral the market and Langkat Ollerdessen that he had shown his him that he would not 14 d and the one that witness had pre-Carmichsel, and to Mr. Morphine. Court an1 the explanation of that was very heavily deed in anoxia with itros went up from The 800 outs Mr. Saunders and he told him witness signed it. On July 7 witness viously landul to him, Witness and Now were the alisres you sold to Mr. given to the Court, and they had it that Souterra and Langkata, and be wouble. 1,400 and Sumatras from what he had said Mr. Ollerdassen anil received a communication from the Stot searched again and again for this book Carmiabaol and to Mr. Murphine the the contract with Mr. Kadoorie was far have been able to have sua le his 115 to Tla. 300. I was not ablo. Wat pitill to-morrow." Witness ask-Exchange informing him that his oldiga but had an found it. He could not samo se those you, bought from Mr. Tls. 27. Coun et would produer al Mare settlement except for the nasista meat his Marala cettlement. Heed how he was to make his settisment tions must be completed by September ever given this book back to him.

remanbor whether Mr. McKean had white-No. the contracts for all these seven transag- anea of a friend, one of hit constituents had to appoxi to some friends to help chequer if he did to know where he 30, or action would be taken in neenri-

Then what did you do with the sions and put them before his Worship with whom he had done linge business and he promisel them that they stand and Mr. Oller lessen said "Wait."ance with the rules of the Stock Ex-If witness hot overbought or over shares you bought from White I as the contracts showed the people from Helind to deliver this client eighty should not to mary by him. II. Witnow tall his olerk to write the in-change. Witness replied on July and sold shares for the Juas settlement vol no shares from him. whom the o shares were bought, and he Senawangs in Maret and when he asked then if they cald holp big at dividual cheques to all brokers and that in the course of his letterand: The subho was unable to tries them house hu What did you do with the contmat-7 would be able to see that the contracts, put his affairs before this gentlemint they did it would asta about ten if they were not wantòl they could bears of the Catiny Trust were distinelly had handed all the shares to the Cathay. The contract is with Mr. White the rates, the dates and the numbos of he said that his eld ust halp. Siivo Oro said that he enld not give henixt day was supposed to be the iga pmmissory notes for the amounts bought 26 Kroowooks. Yo hnd not White on your own socount ?—I m

expeeled and one, cheque written out, given to understand that if we would rast. Witness believed he find over-

Did you make that contract with theres all correnquled with the soiling by giving him cash but that na alish, but he had 80: Somwang

that

|«tatement far as

tent

WILA

that morning witness had wout Tis 9,000 to his cralit in his account.

The Court then adjourned.

this suit against Carmichael, but eventually did so at the request of the Cathay Trust. Mr. Matthews' report Mr. MatthewA was tory inaccurate,

to show that they were not banght from dress his couage to the feet that tile'cum 1 Shanghai, to until after won, All that morning poraone signol the demigal; one, an ought to have had witness's sozonil book

Committee.

un laws Ex ons Oline in 1908

into nitness's recount, which

WHI

I suggest you contracted with Mr.

Kadorio of Tis. 20, that ho gave you n contract at Tls. 26 ; that you entered thist contract in your book at Ths. 28; and that you sold the same shares to Carmichael at T1. I profit on thit trous action if it had gone through That is not so. I cannot understand this algebra,⚫

Mr. Douglas said that

MI. Kadoarie's contract was in Court. If forgory wore suggested, he would have

to adopt a different line.

Mr. Oppo-Did you "job". any shares in the June Settlement?

Witness Everyone lost his head. I.

did not "job" intentionally. Clroom-

stanco: drow me,

You say you bought White's shares the Batu Anname at Tle. 21 and sold them back to him at The. 187

That would mean a loss to you of

Do you ask the Court to believe that shares ?--If you take 8 from 21 is it

not 18?

Do you say you lost Tis. 8 per share? -Who lost it?

Do you say you lost Tla, 3 porèharë ? -Bo has not paid me.

Mr. Douglas Mr. White owes him Tl. 61,000 which he has never paid.

Mr. Oppe-When you bought these shares from Mr. White what were you

Witness-You may consider that I

If you bought thom on any person's necoynt you could not have sold them

doing?

If you had bo

If you find bought 400 Bata 'Anname for another person's account and sold 400 Datú Annims to another person on a different date at Tir. 18, that second 100 must be diferent!-He sold mo 100 and re-bought them, I must go through the book.

On April 7 you bought 400 Batu Anuamos from White ?--Yos.

Page 5Page 6