TNAG-1553-FCO40-2117-Hong-Kong-Control-of-Publications-Consolidation-Ordinance-19-1986 — Page 265

GRS 650

CONFIDENTIAL

CONFIDENTIAL

FM HONG KONG

TO PRIORITY FCO

TELNO 313

OF 300635Z JANUARY 86

INFO PRIORITY PEKING

nie need fei.

vain

THIS TI

RECEIVED IN REGISTRY

ADV

12 FEE 1986

MKK 30

M Shall need to submi

DESK OFFICE.

HIY

PA

bition lakan

INDEX

HONG KONG : CONTROL OF PUBLICATIONS CONSOLIDATION ORDINANCE (CAP 269)

1. THIS ORDINANCE PROVIDES THE GOVERNMENT WITH SWEEPING POWERS TO

SUPPRESS JOURNALS FOR PUBLISHING MATERIAL PREJUDICIAL TO THE SECURINTY OF HONG KONG. IT WASAZED ENACTED IN 1951 FBGUWPYB QOTOT AND WAS DESIGNED TO MEET THE THREAT OF A FLOOD OF SEDITIOUS PROPAGANDA FROM CHINA, FOLLOWING THE COMMUNIST TAKE-OVER. WE HAVE RECENTLY BEEN CONSIDERING WHETHER TO REPEAL IT.

2. THE ARUGMENTS FOR REPEAL MAY BE SUMMARISED AS FOLLOWS:

(A) THE POWER TO SUPPRESS PUBLICATIONS PROVIDED BY THIS ORDINANCE

IS UNACCEPTABLE IN A FREE SOCIETY.

(8) THE ATTORNEY GENERAL CAN CONCEIVE OF NO CIRCUMSTANCES IN WHICH

HE WOULD BE PREPARED TO USE THE POWERS.

(C) THE POWERS WERE TAKEN AT A TIME WHEN IT WAS UNCERTAIN WHETHER THE NEW CHINESE GOVERNMENT WOULD BE WILLING TO TOLERATE

HONG KONG'S CONTINUED EXISTENCE AS A SEPARATE ENTITY. THEY HAVE

ONLY EVER BEEN USED TO SUPPRESS 3 PAPERS DURING THE 1967 DISTURBANCES WHEN AN EMERGENCY HAD BEEN DECLARED. THE POLITICAL

POSITION HAS CHANGED: HT WOULD NOW BE UNTHINKABLE FOR THESE POWERS

TO BE USED AGAINST THE COMMUNIST PRESS IN HONG KONG.

(D) WITH THE APPROACH OF 1997, IT IS NOT DESIRABLE TO LEAVE SUCH AN ORDINANCE, HOWEVER REDUNDANT, ON THE STATUTE BOOK, SINCE THERE

IS A REISK THAT THE CHINESE GOVERNMENT MIGHT PRESSURE THE SAR

GOVERNMENT INTO INVOKING SUCH POWERS.

сод

correction

CG6/2

(D) THE PRESS AND PUBLIC OPINION IN HONG KONG HAVE BEGUN TO FOCUS ON THE EXISTENCE OF LEGISLATION OF THIS KIND, AND TO EXPRESS ANXIETY ABOUT THE RISK OF ABUSE, ONCE THE RESTRAINING EFFECT

OF THE LINK OF AUTHORITY WITH BRITAIN DISAPPEARS (SEE FOR EXAMPLE

THE POINTS MADE BY MR WONG KWOK-WAH, VICE-CHAIRMAN OF THE HK

JOURNALISTS ASSOCIATION IN HIS CALL ON MR LUCE ON 5 JUNE 1985)

(F) ALL NECESSARY POWERS TO DEAL WITH PUBLICATIONS WHICH INCITE

CRIMINAL ACTIVITIES ARE COVERED BY OTHER LEGISLATION: IN A REAL

CRISIS EMERGENCY POWERS COULD BE TAKEN.

3. ARGUMENTS AGAINST ARE AS FOLLOWS:

CONFIDENTIAL

\(A)