TNAG-1469-FCO40-1998-Visits-by-members-of-the-Office-of-the-Unofficial-Members-of-1986 — Page 56

CONFIDENTIAL

21.

The Secretary of State noted that there was an element of

paradox in the desire of Hong Kong people to be assured both about

continuity and about flexibility. Flexibility might be used

adversely by the PRC after 1997. The Governor agreed that this was

some in Hong Kong were saying in effect that the provisions they most wanted in

the Basic Law should be entrenched; the ones

they might want to change should not be.

So:

22.

Mr Oswald Cheung noted that the Joint Declaration specified

that Hong Kong should have a high degree of autonomy. This required

some "highly cantankerous chaps" in the legislature.

noted that it seemed possible to secure this element even by

indirect elections.

The Governor

23.

The Secretary of State said he had heard some useful views on

a number of issues. He would try to take his dialogue with Wu

forward in New York about what developments in the next stage would

be acceptable in Hong Kong. He hoped he would not have to hand over

too much paper. The Governor noted that at the Brussels meeting,

papers had been made ready, but it had been left to the Secretary of

State to decide in the light of his discussions whether these should

be handed over to Wu by him, to Ambassador Ke by Dr Wilson, or not

at all.

24.

It

Miss Dunn commented that she thought the handing over of

papers was a most useful means of influencing Chinese thinking.

gave them something they could study at length, after which informal

discussion could take place. This was all the more important since

they were not getting a cohesive view of the Hong Kong reality from

the BLDC discussions. The Secretary of State noted that during the

drafting of the Joint Declaration, the Chinese had shown sensitivity

about the length of the final document. Dr Wilson noted that there

had been no sign of resistance yet to papers about constitutional development. He agreed with Miss Dunn that the exchanges hitherto,

carried out at a measured pace and without publicity, had been most

helpful.

CONFIDENTIAL