TNAG-1243-FCO40-1557-Future-of-Hong-Kong-1983 — Page 5

RESTRICTED

yes

Reference

НКК 040/1

Mr Homme very useful. A bit dated now that of Donald non

Morris

Mr Ham

아

Com

Mr Cli

wish to see and wemmipht (op

на

good to the t усов

Thank you

011 2/12 Mr. Donate Thank

WM 21.12.

Bering. Not has bad,

Aktuald Blant - Rekking without

SIR ROBIN DAY'S 'QUESTION TIME: 17 NOVEMBER 1983: OF HONG KONG

1

•

Copies sent to

FUTURE

-

Margotis - HK

I was given the attached transcript on Tuesday. Although it is now rather old hat, you may be interested in the following observations:

(mp)

22/12

minute

(a) Mr George Waldèn's remarks were generally helpful. I think

can gloss over minor matters such as his mathematical inaccuracies (97% of Hong Kong is held on lease ...) and commend him for his emphasis on:

(i) the need for realism;

+KK 040/1

RECEIVED IN REGISTRY

DESK

29 DEC 1983

REGISTRY

(ii) the need for sensitivity in the Sino-British talkak

(iii)

INDEX

PA

Action Taken

our basic aims in the talks;

Ати

(iv)

the need to bear in mind the interests hot only of the people of Hong Kong, but also those of the people of this country;

copied to оборь R

(v) the reasons why democratic processes in Hong Kong are

not as well developed as some evidently would wish.

(b) Mr Bernard Levin's remarks, cast in the Sir P Goodhart mould. were hardly of the type to boost confidence in Hong Kong. Mr. Levin's arguments reflected those in his 'Times' article of 30 September viz:

(i) It is more or less inevitable that Hong Kong will revert

to China in 1997;

(ii)

(iii)

(iv)

when that happens, the basic freedoms of the Hong Kong people will be extirpated;

?

with this in mind, we should launch as soon as possible an international rescue operation' to make adequate provision elsewhere for Hong Kong people who want to leave;

it would be futile to negotiate any deal by which the Chinese 'promise' to leave Hong Kong free; it would not last.

Mr Levin clearly has difficulty with nationality questions (people of Hong Kong described as British Brotected Bersons) and with choice of language acceptable to the BBC. (See page 8 of transcript).

(MP) üb

(c) Mr Paddy Ashdown's remarks seemed to reflect basic ignorance of the facts. Another poacher of Lord Carrington's term

megaphone diplomacy', he accused the Prime Minister unjustly of:

1

jingoism;

(i)

(ii)

Union Jack waving;

CODE 18-77

RESTRICTED

/'dangerous'