TNAG-0239-FCO40-275-Entitlement-of-Hong-Kong-to-generalised-tariffs-preferences--1970 — Page 126

be doubly handicapped if excluded by

other donor countries.

3.

We have the following observations on the

reasons which have been advanced in favour of

excluding Hong Kong:-

(a) Hong Kong is a territory and therefore

the responsibility of the metropolitan

power

(i) We regard the distinction between

"territories" and "countries" as

irrelevant in the context of

economic development.

(ii) There is no practical alternative

to Hong Kong's dependent status.

Hong Kong remins a dependant "

territory for political reasons.

(iii) Hong Kong is a separate customs

area and derives no specific

advantage from the GATT as a

Hoste dependant territory. (her exist-

ing preferences in the UK will

disappear if the UK offer is

maintained.

An OECD report on preferences (the

(iv) According to an OBOD document

report of the Group of Four) which published in 1967 (broadly Ministers broadly endorsed in 1967 stated that endorsed by Ministers) "any

country, territory or area may

claim developing status"

(b) Hong Kong is not "developing"

(i) with the exception of a limited

range of manufactures, Hong Kong

is far closer to the concept of a

developing country than a

developed one.

- 2 -

CONFIDENTIA

CONFIDENTIAL

NOTHING TO BE WRITTEN IN THIS MARGIN