TO THE COMMONWEALTH OFFICE (The Secretary of State)
FROM HONG KONG (Sir D. Trench)
D. 20 May 1967
R. 20
05552
101
IMMEDIATE
CONFIDENTIAL
No.654
Addressed to Commonwealth Office
Repeated
"Washington No.126
# Peking No.244
1/
POLAD Singapore No.112
(C.0. please pass IMMEDIATE to Washington and
ROUTINE to Peking and Singapore)
My telegram No.639.
-83,
Kowloon Disturbances.
On 16 May, U.S. Naval authorities asked for clearance for visit by
U.S.S. "PRINCETOWN" a helicopter carrier, from
27 May to 1 June. A Rear Admiral would be embarked. The carrier carries
81 officers and 1,300 men.
20 There had been no mention of this particular visit in the existing
schedule of U.S. ships and the timing of the request seems fairly
pointed.
30 There is no need to give the Americans an immediate reply, and I
shall of course discuss with Galsworthy.
But you may have views on how far the Americans would be affronted by a
negative reply at the moment.
(Passed as requested)
(Advance copy to Resident Clerk)
Distribution
-
H.K. W.I.D. I.G.D.
J.I.C. EXTERNAL DISTRIBUTION
DEPARTMENTAL DISTRIBUTION
Copies also sent to:
P.S. to Prime Minister
Cabinet Office Foreign Office
"
11
11
*
-
-
W
D.I.O., J.I.R.
Mr. de la Mare
Mr. Bolland
Mr. Wilson Mr.
Denson
Mr. Foggon
80
CONFIDENTIAL
En Clair
PRIORITY PEKING
Telno 527
CLASSIFIED
ΤΟ
20
FOREIGN OFFICE
20 May 1967
102
Addressed to Foreign Office telegram No. 527 of 20 May, Repeated for
information to Washington, Moscow, Hong Kong and POLAD Singapore.
Peoples' Daily of 20 May carries only one item on Hong Kong which is
mainly a report on recent attempts by demonstrators to protest to
Governor.
2. Same paper publishes two photographs, one showing crowd of young
demonstrators in Ilong Kong, and the other purporting to show
"embarrassment" of British Consul in Macao who has been photographed
standing among group of Chinese and looking at the ground. Another
unidentified European member of Consulate staff appears to be at his
side.
Sent 0339 20 May
Mr. Hopson
Recd 0815Z 20 May
FO/CO/WH DISTRIBUTION
Far Eastern Dept.
NINNIN
1
паро
#
1
Cypher
SECRET
INWARD TELEGRAM
TO THE COMMONWEALTH OFFICE (The Secretary of State)
FROM HONG KONG (Sir D. Trench)
D. 20th May, 1967 R. 20th
M
tr 14502
IMMEDIATE SECRET
No. 655
MAY
G
1967
103.
+
Leon in
Addressed to Commonwealth Office (D.T.D.), Repeated to Peking, No. 245,
10
tr
" POLAD Singapore, No. 113,
11
Washington, No. 127 (Secretary of
State please pass IMMEDIATE to all).
My telegram No. 650. 90
SITREP as at 20/2000 hours.
Confrontation with the Left Wing.
Much
After a quiet night without curfew or incident the pressure was once
again on Government House. the same drill was followed as yesterday but
the demon- strators were in an uglier mood. Numbers involved though
never greatly above 3,000, were on the whole larger and there were
unpleasant elements who deliberately tried to provoke the police. On two
occasions at about 1100 hours and 1500 hours the police cordons had to
be reinforced. After 1500 hours there was a new development when crowds
denied immediate access to Government House began to move back into the
area of Statue Square opposite the Bank of China and also westwards,
causing considerable traffic congestion.
2. Soon after 1600 hours Government House, the front of which was
plastered once again with posters, ceased to be the focal point which
now shifted to the Statue Square area. The crowd here was about 1,000
strong, a considerable percentage appearing to be bystanders. Except for
the occasional hooliganism, directed mainly át Europeans with cameras,
the crown remained reasonably orderly. A loud- speaker from the Bank of
China interspersing offensive propaganda with Communist music tended to
raise the general temperature. Soon after 1700 hours the crowd began to
dis-
The withdrawal of the police perse, westwards and eastwards.
to less obtrusive positions probably contributed to this dispersal
though it may have given the Left Wing the idea that they had achieved a
victory.
SECRET
/3.
40
DA
لاور
IR/CAT
PRIORITY WASHINGTON
TELEGRAM NUMBER 1697
SECRET.
SECRET
TO FOREIGN OFFICE
20 MAY 1967.
104
ADDRESSED FOREIGN OFFICE TELEGRAM NO 1697 OF 20 MAY REPEATED FOR
INFORMATION TO HONG KONG, 82 HONG KONG TELEGRAM NO. 638
PEKING AND POLAD SINGAPORE.
PARA 3. KOWLOON DISTURBANCES.
WE HAVE KEPT THE AMERICANS IN CLOSE TOUCH WITH DEVELOPMENTS AND ASS-
ESSMENTS AS REPEATED TO US IN TELEGRAMS FROM YOU, HONG KONG AND PEKING,
AND WILL CONTINUE TO DO SO. WE HAVE NOT (NOT) INFORMED THEM
67) OF INTERNAL DELIBERATIONS (E.G. HONG KONG TELEGRAMS 624 AND 635) 81
AND WILL NOT (NOT) DO SO UNLESS COMPELLED BY SOME FACTOR OF SPECIAL
URGENCY.
2. WHEN A MEMBER OF CHANCERY DISCUSSED J.I.C. SPECIAL ASSESSMENT OF 18
MAY WITH STATE DEPARTMENT DEPUTY DIRECTOR CONCERNED (DONALD) ON 19 MAY,
DONALD SAID THAT IT COINCIDED EXACTLY WITH THE STATE DEPART- MENT'S
JUDGEMENT, AND HE WAS NOT AWARE OF ANY SIGNIFICANT DIFFERENCE OF VIEW IN
ANY OTHER AMERICAN AGENCY.
3. HE ADDED, AND EMPHASISED AGAIN AT THE END OF A LENGTHY DIS- CUSSION,
THAT IN CASE IT NEEDED SAYING THE ADMINISTRATION WERE ANXIOUS TO DO
ANYTING THEY COULD TO BE HELPFUL TO THE GOVERNOR IN THE PRESENT
SITUATION.
FO PASS PRIORITY HONG KONG 70 AND ROUTINE PEKING 19 AND POLAD
SINGAPORE 21.
KS
SIR P DEAN
[REPEATED AS REQUESTED]
DEPARTMENTAL DISTRIBUTION
F.0.
F.E.D.
S.E.A.D.
C.O.
F.E. AND P.D. D.T.D.
77777
SENT 2002/20 MAY 1967
RECD 2002/20 MAY 1967
RECEIVED IN ARCHIVES No. 63-
8.2 149
HWD In
SECRET
AD
SENT TO HONG KONG AS COMMONWEALTH OFFICE (D.T.D.)
TELEGRAM NO.
987
SECRET
(105
CYPHER/CAT A
PRIORITY WASHINGTON
TELEGRAM NO 1698
SECRET.
TO FOREIGN OFFICE
20 MAY 1967
ADDRESSED FOREIGN OFFICE TELEGRAM NUMBER 1698 OF 20 MAY REPEATED FOR
INFORMATION (PRIORITY) TO HONG KONG AND ROUTINE TO PEKING
AND POLAD SINGAPORE,
MIPT: KOWLOON DISTURBANCES,
AS MINOR PERSONAL COMMENTS ON THE J.1.C. SPECIAL ASSESSMENT OF 18 MAY,
DONALD SAID THAT HE DOUBTED WHETHER THE PROSPECT OF HARDSHIP FOR, OR
ALIENATION OF, THEIR OWN SUPPORTERS IN HONG KONG WOULD DETER THE CHINESE
FROM CUTTING OFF SUPPLIES OF FOOD AND WATER, IF THE SIT- UATION
OTHERWISE DEVELOPED TO THAT DEGREE (PARA 9). HE ALSO COMM- ENTED THAT
THE ASSESSMENT NOTABLY UNDERSTATED THE DIFFERENCES IN IMPORTANCE AND
EFFICIENCY BETWEEN HONG KONG AND MACAO: NO DOUBT OUT OF MODESTY (PARA
6). HE STRONGLY ENDORSED THE ARGUMENT THAT APP EA SMENT WOULD RESULT
ONLY IN INCREASED DEMANDS. FINALLY, HE SAID THAT THE AMERICANS HAD
RECENTLY RECEIVED AN ASSESSMENT FROM THE JAPANESE CONSUL-GENERAL IN HONG
KONG WHICH, THOUGH DIFFUSE AND AM- BIGUOUS, CLEARLY ASSUME THAT CHINESE
OBJECTIVES WERE LIMITED, AND TENDED TO SEE THEM AS A COMBINATION OF
SEVERING THE AMERICAN CONN- ECTION AND CURTAILING NATIONALIST
ACTIVITIES. DONALD COMMENTED THAT HE HAD AT FIRST DISCOUNTED THE SECOND
POINT, AND STILL FOUND THE JAPANESE REASONING TO IT QUITE UNCONVINCING.
BUT HE HAD ALSO SINCE RECALLED THAT IT WAS A FEATURE OF THE MACAO CRISIS
AND HAD ENTERED INTO HSI EH'S SPEECH ON 18 MAY: AND IN THE PRESENT
CONFUSED STATE OF THE CULTURAL REVOLUTION IT MIGHT BE A MORE SENSITIVE
POINT WITH THE CHINESE THAN WE TENDED TO SUPPOSE. AT ANY RATE HE THOUGHT
WE SHOULD KNOW OF THIS JAPANESE VIEW IF WE HAD NOT RECEIVED IT DIRECT.
2. DONALD WENT ON TO WONDER (ON A PERSONAL BASIS, AND MENTIONING THAT
HIS COLLEAGUES WERE NOT INCLINED TO SET MUCH STORE BY THIS POSSIBILITY
AT PRESENT) WHETHER THE CULTURAL REVOLUTION MIGHT BE
/ENTERING ED 150 IN
ARCH 17 49.63
1
SECRET
SENT TO HONG KONG AS COMMONWEALTH OFFICE (D.T.D.}~
TELEGRAM NO.
985
119
SECRET
WASHINGTON TELEGRAM NO. 1698 TO FOREIGN OFFICE
-2-
ENTERING A NEW PHASE OF CONFUSION IN WHICH IRRATIONAL FACTORS
WERE IMPINGING ON FOREIGN POLICY, HE NOTED THREE RECENT INCIDENTS, ALL
OF WHICH SEEMED INEXPLICABLE IN TERMS OF TRADITIONAL CALCULAT- IONS OF
THE CHINESE MENTALITY, NAMELY THE GROUNDLESS CLAIMS TO HAVE SHOT DOWN
AMERICAN PLANES OVER CHINA: THE FLAT DENIAL THAT MALLEY HAD EVEN SEEN
CHOU EN-LAI: AND THE SURPRISINGLY SUDDEN AND EXTREME ''DEMANDS' NOW MADE
AGAINST HONG KONG.
3. ON THE BALANCE OF INITIATIVE BETWEEN PEKING AND LOCAL EXTREMISTS,
DONALD TOOK THE VIEW THAT, IF THE ORIGINAL DISPUTE HAD BEEN ENGEN- DERED
IN HONG KONG, THE IMPORTANT THING NOW WAS THAT PEKING HAD CHOSEN TO BACK
THE 'DEMANDS''. WE HAD THEREFORE TO RECKON WITH THEIR REASONS FOR DOING
SO. HE WAS INTERESTED IN THE TIMING OF PEKING'S DECISION, AND WONDERED
IF IT COULD BE DETECTED IN THE LATE AND CLEARLY STRENGTHENED EDITORIAL
OF WEN WEI PAO ON 11 MAY. 4. WHILE THE DANGER IN THE PRESENT SITUATION
LAY IN THE FACT (CF. PARA 3 OF PEKING TEL NT 480) THAT THE CHINESE HAD
APPARENTLY (THOUGH, IF SO, SURPRISINGLY LEFT THEMSELVES NO WAY TO BACK
DOWN FROM THEIR EXTREME AND IRRATIONAL DEMANDS. DONALD POINTED OUT THAT
THE DEMANDS HAD NOT (NOT) BEEN ACCOMPANIED BY SPECIFIC THREATS OR
TIME-LIMITS. NEVERTHELESS, ONE HAD TO TAKE SERIOUSLY THE POSSIBILITY
THAT THEIR OBJECTIVE WAS TO HUMILIATE THE BRITISH IN HONG KONG, AND THAT
THEY WOULD BE MOST LIKELY TO TRY THIS THROUGH A SUSTAINED PERIOD OF
TURMOIL. HE THOUGHT CHINESE MOTIVATION HAD TO BE SOUGHT IN CALCULATED
OBJECTIVES RATHER THAN A RESPONSE TO THE SHEER INTOLER- ABILITY OF OUR
POSITION IN HONG KONG AS AN AFFRONT TO THE CULTURAL REVOLUTION, BECAUSE
THE LATTER WAS NOT CONSISTENT WITH THE RELATIVELY MEASURED TEMPO OF THE
CAMPAIGN (CF. NOW PEKING
TEL NO 523).
5. DONALD THOUGHT THAT SOME PROCRASTINATION ON WHEAT BY THE AUST-
RALIANS AND CANADIANS COULD BE USEFUL.
6. FINALLY, DONALD MENTIONED THAT THE STATE DEPARTMENT ARE ADVISING
AMERICANS GOING TO HONG KONG ON BUSINESS TO PROCEED AS USUAL.
[? EP OMITTRI
TOURISTS WHO ASK ARE BEING, NO DIRECT ADVICE, BUT A FAIRLY GRIM PICTURE
OF THE SCANT LIKELIHOOD OF THEIR ENCOUNTERING THE USUAL TOURIST
ATTRACTIONS. THIS IS INTENDED TO DISSUADE POTENTIALLY TROUBLESOME VISITS
WITHOUT IMPLYING, EVEN OBLIQUELY, THAT THERE IS ANY DOUBT ABOUT THE
CONTINUED PRESERVATION OF LAW AND ORDER: AND THEY HOPE IT WOULD BE IN
LINE WITH THE GOVERNOR'S WISHES.
F.O. PASS PRIORITY HONG KONG 71 AND ROUTINE PEKING 20 AND POLAD
SINGAPORE 22.
SIR P. DEAN
SENT 2017 20 MAY
RECD 2017 20 MAY
[REPEATED AS REQUESTED]
DEPARTMENTAL DISTRIBUTION
F.0
F.E.D. S.E.A.D.
77777.
C.O.
F.E. AND P.D. D.T.D.
SECRET
TWO
LIL
FOCO 024/20
1
FOLLOWING IS TEXT OF WASHINGTON TELEGRAM NUMBER 1700 OF 20 MAY
TO FOREIGN OFFICE SENT TO YUU FOR ONWARD TRANSMISSION PRIORITY
TO HONG KONG
106
CONFIDENTIAL.
ADDRESSED FOREIGN OFFICE TEL NO 1700 20/5 REPEATED FOR INFORMATION
TO HONG KONG (PRIORITY) AND ROUTINE TO PEKING AND POLAD SINGAPORE.
U.S.S. PRINCETOWN.
WE HAVE MENTIONED TO THE STATE DEPT THE FIRST TWO PARAGRAPHS OF
HONG KONG TEL. UNDER REF, EXPRESSING SURPRISE AT THE INSERTION OF
NEW, MAJOR REQUESTS IN PRESENT CIRCUMSTANCES. THE DEPUTY DIRECTOR
CONCERNED (DONALD) ASKED THAT THE GOVERNOR SHOULD FEEL ENTIRELY
FREE TO REFUSE, AND WE ARE SURE THAT, IN WASHINGTON AT LEAST, REFUSAL
AT THE MOMENT WOULD CAUSE NO (NO) AFFRONT.
2. HEAD OF BRITISH DEFENCE STAFF CWASHINGTON) AGREES.
FOREIGN OFFICE PASS HONG KONG 72
SENT AT 2220 z 20 MAY RR K
RECD 2022222 HEE
пор
Cypher/Cat.A
CONFIDENTIAL
COLOMBO TO COMMONWEALTH OFFICE
elno. 283
21 May 1967
(07)
CONFIDENTIAL
Addressed Commonwealth Office telegram. No. 283 of 21 May. Repeated for
information to Hong Kong and Saving Peking.
Chinese propaganda on Hong Kong.
Official bulletin of Chinese Embassy of 18 May
(received 21 May) carries number of items on Hong Kong, including
"commentators" article in "People's Daily" of 15 May and a news item
datelined Hong Kong alleging, for example, that:
"All the arrested, including children of ten or so, were brutally beaten
up so that many vomited blood or fainted.
"Even the injured were beaten up on the way to hospital by plain
clothes men on board the ambulances."
2. Such items offend "Third country rule" (against the publications of
foreign Missions carrying objectionable or disparaging references to
countries with which Ceylon maintains friendly relations). We are
accordingly raising the subject informally with the Ministry of External
Affairs later on 21 May.
Commonwealth Office pass Hong Kong M12 and pass Saving
to Peking.
Mr. Dutton
Sent
Recd.
1128Z/21 May 1967
11302/21 May 1967
[Repeated as requested]
DEPARTMENTAL DISTRIBUTION
C.0.
S.A.D.
F.E.P.D.
J.I.R.D.
News Dept. J.R.D.
F.0.
F.E.D. S.E.A.D.
1
SSSSS
CONFIDENTIAL
RECE!, ED IN ARCHIVES No. 63
2 2 APK 1967
HWA 1/17
SENT TO HONG KONG AS COMMONWEALTH OFFICE (D.T.D.)
TELEGRAM NO.
990
SECRET
INWARD TELEGRAM
TO THE COMMONWEALTH OFFICE (The Secretary of State)
FROM HONG KONG (Sir D. Trench)
Cypher
D. 21 May 1967
11 R. 21
141 02
IMMEDIATE
SECRET No.656
Addressed to Commonwealth Office (D.T.D.) Repeated PRIORITY to Peking
No. 246
ti
14
18 POLAD Singapore No.114
11
Washington No.128
(c.o. please pass to all)
My telegram No.655.-
103
108
SITREP as at 21/2000.
Access to Government House was limited today to groups of twenty by
blocking or cordoning access roads. Demonstrations were therefore kept
in the centre of the city. The bottom of Garden Road was the main
concentration area, the
crowd building up to about 1,000 by midday. It remained fairly orderly
though the main core perhaps half, continued to bait the police and to
exhort them to turn on their English masters. At 13.30 hours the mood
became more ugly. Some windows were broken and the police moved in to
disperse the crowd, which scattered but kept reforming.
2.' By 16.00 hours the centre of the disturbances moved about a quarter
of a mile to the North West to the water front and particularly the area
of the Post Office where a European
Over a was manhandled by the mob now about 2,000 strong. period of an
hour the police three times had to use tear gas. By 17.30 hours the
crowd began rapidly to disperse and there have been no incidents since.
Kowloon has remained quiet throughout.
3. Except for the European, who was not badly hurt, no
The police casualties have been admitted to hospital. arrested 44 men
the majority of them Left-wing workers living on the island.
20
We have no information on what we can expect tomorrow.
Distribution H.K. W.I.D. 'C'
R
- I.G.D.
J.I.C. EXTERNAL DISTRIBUTION DEPARTMENTAL DISTRIBUTION
A
100
175
Mr. de la Mare
Mr. Bolland
/Copies also fent to: P.S. to Prime Minister
HWalli
Cabinet Office - D.I.O., J.I.R.
Foreign Office
Mr. Wilson
11
#t
раво
+
t!
Mr. Denson
tt
- Mr. Foggon
I
- Mr. Rodgers
ז
SECRET
CC..
INWARD TELEGRAM
TO THE COMMONWEALTH OFFICE
(The Secretary of State)
TION (109
a
G
FROM HONG KONG (British Information Services)
En clair D. 21 May, 1967.
R.
21
16322
PRESS
Situation on Hong Kong Island returned to normal this evening after
day of scattered incidents which at one time brought central district to
a standstill.
Police acting on the announced policy of preventing large unruly
groups gathering were constantly in action dispersing chanting
demonstrators and nuisance
One groups. A total of 44 people were arrested. European who was
attacked by a mob was detained in hospital. Six other prople, including
five police received hospital treatment but were not (repeat not)
detained. eleven gas cartridges were fired today. at barrier erected to
block route to Government House. Police insisted that only orderly
groups of not (repeat not) more than 20 people could proceed past the
barrier.
In all Crowds gathered
A mob outside Hilton Hotel unsuccessfully demanded
They
management remove British flags flying from hotel. broke one window and
ripped down sign board.
In a chain of events in Central District police clashed with scattered
crowds. The area was sealed and traffic diverted. Police broke up
biggest groups with
Another crowd burned Union Jack tear
gas and baton charges.
at Harcourt Road fire station.
Order was restrored by 1830 hours when normal traffic flow was
resumed. For Boxall above cable sent Chapelries.
(Copies passed to Messrs. de la Mare, Wilson
and Bolland)
Distribution H.K. WID 'C'
-
- I.G.D.
J.I.C. EXTERNAL DISTRIBUTION
DEPARTMENTAL DISTRIBUTION
Copies also sent to:-
RECHVED IN
63
вард
P.S. to Prime Minister
Cabinet Office
Foreign Office
11
D.1.0., J.I.R. Mr. de la Mare
Mr. Bolland
11
**
J
Mr. Wilson
11
曾
-
Mr. Denson
= =
IT
Mr. Foggon
11
-
· F.E.D.
ON
(110)
אס.............
En Clair
INWARD TELEGRAM
TO THE COMMONWEALTH OFFICE
(The Secretary of State)
ста
HUA 5/12
FROM HONG KONG (Information Officer)
D. 21st May, 1967
R. 20th
1940Z
PRESS
Hong Kong Government has announced that it will not, repeat not,
tolerate any more disorderly gatherings such as occurred in Statue
Square in Central District this
Saturday) afternoon.
Following events of today, Government tonight issued a statement which
stated: "During past few days Government has permitted group protests at
gates of Government House to proceed without interference, Until today,
demonstrations associated with these protests have been noisy but not,
repeat not, violent.
"Today, the demonstrations have lost their orderly and disciplined
nature. Groups of demonstrators returning from Government House have
mobbed around Statue Square and the Law Courts and have resorted to
violence and rowdiness by molesting spectators and by attempting to
block the tramlines with rubbish. These activities have been urged on by
loudspeaker exhortations to further violence and disorder.
"It has therefore been decided that in the interests of the public,
disorderly gatherings of this nature will not, repeat not, in future be
permitted. People will, however, be allowed to continue to exercise
their right to petition the Governor in small, orderly groups or by
post, but disorderly processions or unlawful gatherings will not be
allowed"." End of statement).
Noisy demonstrations took place all afternoon around Bank of China which
has been headquarters for demonstrators marching to Government House,
Following chanting of slogans and pasting of posters around Government
House marchers returned to vicinity of Bank where they interrupted the
weekend calm of central area by noisy shouting.
At times passers-by were molested by the crowd. Photographers were
approached and forced to expose their films. However, visits by police
parties to the scene
evented serious trouble.
IN
P
43
HWAYD
F
1
/ At
PARO
At a few minutes to six the crowd surged towards Hilton Hotel. A
group saw the hotel manager and demanded the flags, British, American
and the hotel flag should be lowered. Hotel manager pointed out it was
one minute to six anyway and he always had flags lowered at six. So the
flags were lowered as usual by a uniformed pageboy wearing white gloves.
In Kowloon situation is remaining normal.
Commissioner of Labour said today that a series of discus- sions between
management of Hong Kong Artificial Flower Works and representatives of
various groups of workers have been held in Labour Department during
past four days.
As a result of these discussions considerable progress has been
made towards resumption of normal work at two factories, one in Kennedy
Town and other in San Po Kong, which have been scene of recent disputes.
Spontaneous support for Government's firm maintenance of peace
swells today.
More organisations representing people from all walks of life-from small
man hawking his wares in street to business executive and professional
man have added their names to those who have already come forward
publicly to support Government.
Statements of support for the authorities' action were issued by 56,
(repeat 56), organisations today.
Contributions to the higher education fund for children of
junior members of Hong Kong Police have exceeded $7,500. Director of
Commerce and Industry, Mr. Sorby thanked the many persons, firms and
organisations who have expressed sup- port for the fund.
For Boxall.
Above cable sent Commonwealth Office (D.T.D.).
Distribution:
H.K. W.I.D. 'C' I.G.D.
J.I.C. EXTERNAL DISTRIBUTION
DEPARTMENTAL DISTRIBUTION
Copies also sent to:-
Cabinet Office
Foreign Office
11
(+
中
It