518
Jak
asked for it and would never have accepted it. But Sir C.Clementi's arguments which were sound enough in theory would apply a fortiori to proposals for national recognition now that the military and political success of the Cantonese has carried them
so near to establishing their claims. It is not unlikely also that these views would have the support of Mr.Brenan the Acting Consul General at Canton who stated some time ago that the situation required handling on large lines as recommened by the Governor of Hong Kong.
In short, it would appear that the policy now proposed by the Foreign Office would isolate us from other Powers, would fail to conciliate the Cantonese
and would even encourage them in their general attack, would not remove the danger threatening the Custome or the restrictions hampering British trade, and would be viewed with strong disapproval even by the
Inspector General of Customs himself. On the other
hand, the only policy which offers any prospect of saving situation is the policy of recognising the Canton Government as the national Government of China
at the earliest possible moment consistent with our obligations. In the meantime, it would be futile
by taking independent action, which could produce no substantial result in our favour, to sacrifice the
united front hitherto maintained by the Fowers. (In
hit the niggustion quation)
this connection it would appear of vital importance to ascertain the precise nature of the conversations held by the Japanese and American representatives with the
Canton Goverment.)
Tallukasuck
29/11