j. a has more than paid for the cost of the Gap Rock Light, ~ and as the charge of one cent a ton is more than sufficient to cover the cost of the upkeep ) and maintenance of the ~ present lighthouses. They state that any charge and above that necessary to cover such cost will deter shipping from visiting this port and is an infringement of the freedom of the port, which will affect its welfare.
4. So far as light dues are concerned I agree with the petitioners that the revenue derived from them should be applied to the purpose for which it is raised, viz: - the upkeep and maintenance of the lighthouses; and it is true that the charge of one cent a ton is sufficient to cover all present expenditure incurred on that account.
5. With regard to the increased rate of 1 1⁄2 cents a ton