DRAFT.
194
W-Mcade.
W. Meade
I don't see why the service
"Therton" on board the
should not
4
5413/74
count, except for the reason mentioned in your minute and
the rates of salary allowances were originally fixed & subsequently
this understanding, viz. that
Lee
your
minute 12 5413/74-
in the diff
As for
I know there has been no decision of
that
antrepoint date affecting the claim to pension
for similar service on the W. Const Steamer, nor has
W-Lewes any farther notes on
As far as
otwith the decision Waspects Can
the pointi Jean judy
judge you gave excellent the m
reasons at that time for not regarding the claim service as pensionable; but at the same time appeared disposed to admit the claim
Eventually.
Should not M. Havelock be consulted before you decide on such a general question?
In Hemming
JRK
16/10/83
my.
See the latter parts
5413/14. I still think
Junite
the service should be admitted to
if to do gene think are
weed consult dettenbeth. Gringt
зна адна а
ague
A
would to the time and
have to comml
we should telepas which
am 17/0
would give sire Bt inconscineme
"revised an
the service was not pensionable. This however to my mind seems an very strong argument and the negative side of the question.
of Capt. Miluen gets the benefit
m.
""service we shall
of his "Sherbes" service also have to reckon with her Carter
Lewes in his minute on
attempts to draw a
between the two cases
on 8878
-179 Glash
destination
but
D
Sconfess
I am unable to appreciate it.
W. Canter I was refused ground that the rules of the Colonial service did not admit
his "Sherbes" service.
counted for pension. If differently
being
we decide Capt Milen affle für
in the cave of
causse
to Carter will of cas
recouton
& I don't see the
could refuse it.
on the whole I think I should be disposed not to allow the service to count as pensionable I think the weight of the argument
is against me, the the team your letter.
in 19t Mother unfly that we should give mag on the point. Telegraph this
Selegraph this 5. Bowen "Warn
"BM atoue Shan lim service not pensionable
19/10