10
THE SOTTO CASE,
(Continued from page 3), they reside. They have Filipino citizenship, bat they have no American citizenship. May I refer you to the Slaughter-house care, 16 Wallace, 48, on citizen- ship of the United States. It is primary citizenship.
Mr Hodgson--How does the question arise with the Philip pines?
because I know what these cases werd.
His Worship:-Where do you get Wong Kim Ark?
Mr. Bratton :---In Randolph again. My friend says it is not law and it is referred to in Kopp per versus the United States and the Ark case and is equivalent to the words "within the limite and under the jurisdiction of the Unit-
THE HONGKONG TELEGRAPH, TUESDAY, JULY 1918,
Shanghel
POST OFFICE.
MAILS VIA SIBERIA. London June 19
June 28 July '14
July 30 MAILS DUB... English, Obine, 2nd inst. Siberian, Linan. 2nd inat. The China with the English words "out of the limits, and with the 28th inst at 8 a.m. and is ex- ed States," and conversely, the mail left Bingapore on Saturday, in the limits, of the United States" pected to arrive here to-morrow are habitually used in the Natur- at 2 p.m. This packet brings the Mr Brutton: No, no, the ques-aliention Acts. No one within paroel malls closed in London for tion raised is citizenship. It has the limits and out of the Juris despatch by the all saa routs on. nothing to do with the Philip diction asn be naturalised and the 88th May, and for despatch pines. The question is now now we see there is no law pro- overland on the 4th June. settled by the 14th amendment,viding naturalisation
The Linan with the mail from It is
to the London (via Siberia) of Friday, stated that that Philippine Islands. I asked if the 13th instant, is expected to oitizenship is derivitory. We the Naturalisation Acts apply, arrive here to-morrow. have seen from the Treaty of and I was told 'no', and if on Hawali that a citizen of Hawaii is this authority they did apply, a citizen of the United States and they would apply in this esse, but a citizen of Alaska is a oitizen of if they are within the limits, Holhow, Haiphong Fakhoi and the United States, and you now but out of the jurisdiction, see the question is settled by the they do not.. If they were in 14th Amendment. State citizen-force the Philippine Islands would ship is secondary, derivators be considered to be within the Samarang depending on citizenship of the jurisdiction, not within the limits, United States. You see, the but within the jurisdiction. Philippine citizen *Las not
His Worship Have you the anything whatever to do with the Naturalisation Act of America?. United States. If he is an American citizen he is ipso facto Scrutiny of the Naturalisation Mr. Brutton:It must be here. Philippine citizen. Assuming Acta beginning with 1895 will this is a state or territory then show that within the United all he is, 18 Filipino States an applicant for citizenship Philippine of a prescribed territory must Islands, nothing more, so be does not come under the 14th apply within the territory. As Azraiment of the Constitution, regarde territories, if I refer There is the well-known case of you to Alaska and Hawaii you The Act of Congress in respect will see exactly what is meant.
citizen
of
the
the Exchange, and the U.S.A. versus Wong Kim Ark,160 Unit-1
ed States, 649-687, wherein you
to
Hawaii provided for. the
MAILS CLOSE.
Kaifong
2nd
Saigon-Per 2nd July, 9 a Bwatow Por Haimun,
July, 10 a.m.
Sourabaya-Per Childar, 2nd July, 10 a.m Philippine Islands, Aus- trailia, Tasmania and New Zealand Thursday day Island-Per Kum- ano-maru, 2nd July 10
Canadian,
Ameri-
Australian
Mail.
Matis.
a.m
Shanghai, North China' Japan via Nagasaki' United States, South America and Canada via Vancouver (Europe via Siberia)-Per Empress of Japan 2nd July, 11 am.
overnment of Hawaii, If you Swatow. Amoy and Foochow
Per Kaljo-maru, 2nd July, 1 p.m.
find the words "United States, are citizens of the United States
subject to the jurisdiction thereof"
1.15 p.m.
Shanghai, & North China (Europe via Biberia) Per China, 2nd July, 5 pan
Shanghai and North China
Hanggang 2nd July 5 p.m. Macao-Per Sui Tai, 3rd July
1.15 p.m. Shanghai and North China-Per Luchow, 3rd July, 3
SHIPPING NEWS.
ABRIVED."
Chow Tal. Ger... 1,115,
WEATHER REPORT.
On the 30th at 11.20-The nother depression is passing in- to the Pacifio.
Gathemann. 30th June- The depression over Tongking Bangkok 2nd June, Rbas deepened and now extende & WM: & Co.
to the Yangtze Valley. Mausang, British 1,64 Pressure has decreased mode- Corneck, 30th June-rately to slightly in central and Sandakan 23rd June southem districts. It is highest in Loongwang, Br. 6.8. 1.093 W. G. G.
Tunher.-J. M, & Co. the neighbourhood of the Bonins
Loask, 1st July-Manila 28th June Gen.-J. M. & Co. SI-Kiang. Fr. a.. 6 5 J. Fannier,
Soth June-Haihong Kwangles, Chi. s., 1,468, MoA 21th June Gen-M, M,
Fukui
thur, 80th June-Shang- hai lat July, Gen.-,} M. 8. N. Co.
Maru. Jap. 88,317, K. Tominata, 1st July- Moji 95th June, Coal,
M. B. K."
Hangsang, Br... 1,336, 8. Wilde,
Lilly
Dagay,
Mail Steamers
THE PENINSULAR AND ORIENTAL S. N.CO.
Moderate B. winds are indiost- WILL despatch VESSELS to the Undermentioned PORTS on or
ed the east coast of China and over the N. China Sea. hours ending at 10 am-to-day, Hongkong Rainfall for the 24
0.19 inches.
HOURS ENDING AT NOON FORECAST FOR THE 24
TO-MORROW.
District.
about the DATES named as For
Stearders
SHANGHAL
MOJI, KOBE NAMUR AND YOKO (Capt. A. Collger HAMA .......... in, SHANGHAI... LONDON, vis
1 CHINA
To Sail On Remarks
about 19th July & Psage
Freight:
7.R.}
daylight
Freight
Capt. C.H.S. Tooque, R.N.R./ 3rd July | &P'sago
1 Hongkong -
and
Neighbourhood
Forecast,
8. winds, moderate squally' fair to showery.
Usual Ports
DEVANHA
of Call
Capt. W. B. Hickey,
Noon Freight ́3th July / &F'sagė
TONDON & ANT-]
WERP v. Singa-
B. winds,
pore,
Penang,SUNDA
about 1 Freight
fresh, squally.
The same an No. 1.
P. & O. B. N. Co.'s office,
E. A Hewett,
Superintendent.
Hongkong, 24th June, 1913..
1st July-Shanghai and 2 Formėsa Channel Swatow 30th June, Gen., J. M, & Co 9 South coast of) Rickmers, Ger. ss., 00, China between H.K
W. Hulrabuth 'st July-. and Lamooka Hamburg and Sabang 28th April and 22nd June, Geo, M. B. K Nor... 815 P. Dolvesen Nathon 19th June Gen., -A. T. & Co.
CLEARANCES AT THE
HARBOUR OFFICE.
June, 30. Mishima Maru for London. Guthrie for Nagasaki- Gisela for Trieste. Ernest Simons for Yokohama. Sado Maru for Beattle. Pareia for Ban Francisco.
July, 1.
2.
Inaba Maru for Yokohama. Lilly Rickmera for Koohinotzu.. Branilla for Saigon. Chinhua for Manila. Jelunga for Kobe. Iohang for Canton, Tientsin for Newchwang, Hangsang for Canton Kalfong for Haiphong..
PASSENGERS ARRIVED.
June, from Manila
Per se. Longsang, arrived 98th
must be presumed to be under you are citizens of the territory Macao-Por Sul Tai, 2nd July, Tjilatjap for Yokohama. Blood by, and intended by Con-
ia which you reside. Every gress, which proposed the Amend-on the day of the annexation
person who was living in Hawaii ment, and by the legislators that was 12th. August 1898-bo- who adopted it, to be in the came a citizen whether he wanted same sense as the words used by to or not, absolutely. And, it Chief Justice Marshall in the case continues, the Constitution, ar- of the Exchange. Just the same cept where the laws of the Unit- words "under the jurisdictioned States are not applicable, will of the United States," and have the same effect in state or converse, by the words "out of the territory as in the United States. United States and within the That, your Worship, will show limits of the Jurisdiction of the what the citizens in Hawaii are. United states, must be a citizen Having referred you to these Straite and India via Calcutta- of the United States." It means Treaties I would like to refer you within the limits of the United to Article 9 of the Treaty of States and under the jurisdiction Paris. of the United States. If they are within the jurisdiction they are citizena.
His Worship-And if they are not within the jurisdic tion?
"Mr. Brutton-Well they are not within the limits of the United States,
Mr. Hodgson :-Your Worship has not got the case ao I do not know anything about.
•
Without hearing any more, his Worship adjourned the case until Monday next,
BUNKERS
can be supplied at cheap rates.
a
Mr. Brutton-There is no SANDAKAN & SEBATTIK reason why I should be handi- capped because you have not got| it. My friend can get it, your} Worship, and prove that I am
Wrong.
Mr. Hodgson:-There is no ovidence of this and unless my! friend proves it to me-
Mr. Brutton:-I have asked the question about citizenship
(British North Borneo),
At these ports steamers oall- ing for bunker coal exclusively are exempt from all shipping dues and chargos,,
A. BUNE
To Truth Lles-Somewhere,
BUCHANAN'S
WHISKY
SCOTCH
BLACK WHITE
GARNER QUELCH &
SOLE AGENTS.
Co.
p.m.
Swatow, Amoy and Foochow
Dilwara 3rd July 2 pm.
Par Haiching, 4th July.
Am,
F.
4 South coast of)
China between H.K.The same and Halnan.
as No. 1. China Coast Meteorological.
Register.
Station,
$0th June, am.
Wind.
Bour.
Barometer.
Temperature
Humidity.
Weather.
D'tion.
Force.
Wostook 7a29.7240 100 650 0.0 Nemuro 6a29.20 Hakodate 29.48
Tokio Kochi
C'mbo, Port Said, | Capt. O.E. Irving, R.N.R.] 9th July } &P'sage
& Marseilles ...
All the above steamers are fitted with Wireless Telegraphy.
For Freight, or Passage apply to
NORDDEUTSCHER LLOYD.
BREMEN.
IMPERIAL GERMAN MAIL LINES
For
ફ્
W
1
29.69
15
29.84
sw 1
K'shima to 29.90
Nagasaki 29.88
+1
F
29.87
15
29.84
BW 1- -nne 1-day, Oshima 29.85-66 1 Naha Ishi'jima
8" 1-
B 5-
Bonin Is."
30.01
+4
WBW I
A'WERP & BREMEN.,
Chefoo
SHANGHAI, NAGAS-1
19
Whaiwol 29.7370 77 W
4 ob
AKJ,
Hankow
YOKOHAMA....
11
Iohang
"
MANILA,
Kiukiang
Changshis
Shanghai 29.8169 Gutzlaff
17
806 3 ov 0 20 1.0
29.7570 Sharp F. 7a29.7382 Amoy 6 a 29.7780 87 wow 2 o Swatow
Manila
Legaspi
H
29.8*
2
"
29.83- 29.85. 80
88
В
t
it
6a29.6481 -- saw 3 o
11
29.7584
00 sw 4 b 29.8879 se 1 o
» 29.8677
Bevan, Lt. Wm. Burton. Bevan, Mrs. Wm. Rev.
F
Whitcomb
An tolm Talhoku 5a29.80- Marco.
Talchu 30th June, from Nagasaki.
Fer es Kumano Maru arrived Tainan
Koshun Amans, Mrs. E. MoMaster, Mr. P'dores 10a.m.
Carpenter, Mr. L
" 29.80 Canton a 29,7685 76 se Japan vis Yokohama-Fooabing
Moody Mr.C.A. Hong 5 29.7880 88 - 5th July, 10a.m.
Chapman, Mr. P. Moody, Mr.C.A, Gap Rook. 29.75-→ B8W Straits and India via Bombay--
Foster, Mr. 6. Moody, Miss K. Macao 29.7581-ase 2 c Per Ischia, 4th July, 10 Foster, Miss.
Toda, Mr. T.:
Wushow 9a Peacock, Mrs. J. Pakhoi 11 Macao-Per Sui Tai; 4th July,
Foster Mr. W. Shing, Mr. H. N. Hofhow 1,15 p.m..
C.
Suto, Mr. Y.
Phulien Sandakan-Per Mausang,
Banlow, Mrs. N. Tachibana, Mrs. Tourane 4th
Hashimoto, Mr. T July, 5 pm.
C. St. J. "Yo
Tachibana, Aparri Straits, Burmah, Ceylon, Law, Miss P. A. Master É. Adelaide, Western Aus-Tashima, Mr. Y. Wilkinson, Mr. tralia, India,
Tashima, Mr. Y, Ward, Mr. H. n.Iloilo Adon, Egypt, and Europe via Yamashita, Mr. Wright, Mr. Brindisi (Late Letters
Yi, Mr. W..8.. 11 am to noon, Extra PASSENGERS DEPARTED, Postage 10 centa.) (Bup- plementary mail on board San Francisco, and Way Ports:
Per 6.8. departed July 1 for up to the time fixed for departure of the mail
Anderson, Mr. MacKintosh,
A. H, (Extra Postage 10 cents) Broderson, Mr. (Lettere posted in all the Pillar Boxes in time for Brown, Mrs J.
F. M the first clearance will Cox, Mr. R. be included in this con- Darraoh, Mr. M. tract mail.) The Parcel Mall will be closed on
Grossmann, & Friday, the 4th July, at 5 Holstein, Miss
Wife Mr. P.. p.m.-Por Devanha,
R. 8th July, 11 a.m.
Bubrecht, Mr.
F. F. Hunter, Major Young, Mr.
English
Mall.
Philippine Islands-Per Loong-
sang 5th July, 1 p.m. Macao-Fer Sui Tui, 5th July
1,15 p.m. Philippine Islands-Per Rubi,
5th July, 3 p..
Siberian
Mall,
Shanghai and North China (Europe via Si- beria)-Per Linan, 5th July, 5 p.. Swatow-Per Haimun, 6th July,
9 a.m. Japan via Yokohama-Per Va
dala, 7th July, '1 am. Swatow, Amoy and Focohow-
M.
TJ.
MacKintosh, Mins 0, E.
Maxstod, Capt.
Mrs. A.
J
Price. Mr and
H,
Mre H, E N. Rabinowitz, Mr.
Rock, Mr. A. L Young, Mrs, O.
M.
A
29.8875- # 10 29.8979 -- 05 9.29.9184 nw 2b Bacolod
1b Cebu
29.9085-- H
16 Labuan 29.9184" mas ma
1 Barometer, reduced to 32 Hongkong, Observatory, June, 39,
T. F. Claxton, Director.
degrees Fahrenheit on the level of the sea in inches, tenths and hundredths.
degrees Fahrenheit.
2 Temperature, in the shade, in
Steamers.
To sail on
NAPLES, GENOA, AL-)
GIERS, GIBRALTAR, DERFFLINGER SOUTHAMPTON, (Capt. F: Prosch 17,000
KOBE AND YORCK
ANGAUR,}
Caps. H. Formes 17,000
YAP, NEWGUINEA, / COBLENZE
BRISBANE, SYDNEY › Capt. L. Klugkist 6,750 & MELBOURNE
W'NESDAY, -9th July,
.10 ..
about WINESDAY. 9th July.
(SATURDAY,
KOBE.
12th July
9 d.m.
P. SIGISMUND
Capt. D. Lenz
6,000
}
about TUESDAY, 22nd July.
about
Capt. J. Koehler
End of July.
KUDAT & SANDAKAN BORNEO
All the steamers of the European Line are fitted with Wireleme Telegraphy. Now System of Telefunken.
For further Particulars, apply to
NORDDEUTSCHER LLOYD.
MELCHERS & CO.,
GENERAL AGENTS, HONGKONG and OHINA.
Hongkong, 27th June, 1913.
MESSAGERIES MARITIMES
FRENCH MAIL STEAMERS. REGULAR FORtnightly serVICE BETWEEN KUROPE AND JAPAN.
NEXT SAILINGS:- Will leave for Japan on
OUTWARD.
Steamers.
saturation, the, Humidity of air 3 Humidity, In percentage of saturated with moisture being 100,|| Amazone,
4 Direction of Wind, to two Australien, points.
Beaufort Scale:
5 Force of Wind, according to
Le detached cloud, d drizzling rain 6 State of Weather, b blue sky, f fog, g gloomy, h hail, I light- ning, o overcast, p passing showers, g squally, r rain, s-snow, t, thunder, v visibility, w dow wet), 0 Rain in inches, teaths and hundredths.
SHIPS PASSED THE CANAL.
London, 3rd June. Inverclyde, Scandia, Spezia.
Arrivals from China-Hyson, The following vessels have pas- sed the Canal-Bendoran, P. E. Friedrich, Senegambia.
METEOROLOGIL AL.
Previous
- вр
29.74
.86 69
SSW
Day On Date On Date "London, 6th June.
Barometer 29.82 29.78 Arrivals from China -Am-
Temperature 87.
83. azons, Rhesus.
Humidity 67 .88 Per Haitan, 8th July:sed the Canal:-Bulow, Ement Force
The following vessels have pas-Direction
Wind
WBW - Straits and India via Calcutta-Simons, Glenroy, Hirane Maru, Weather
Per Fooksang, 8th July: deus, Den of Glamis.
Satsuma, Teenkai, Teucer, TyRain
10 a.m
1 p.m. Straita and Burmah-Per Itola, 8th July, 5 p.m. Straits, Burmah, Ceylon, Adelaide, Western Aus tralia, India, Adon, Egypt, and Europe via Naples Fer Deriflinger, 9th July, 9 a.m.
Australian
Mail.
Mail.
Philippine Islands, An-
1 1
อ
0
0.19 Higkast open air Temperature in the spik
London, 10th June. The following vessels, have pas-H.I. Observatory, 30th June, 1913. Maru, Koerber, Nippon, Preussen, sed the Canal-Bohemia, Hilach
T. F. Claxton. Director: TIDE TABLE. London, 12th June. Arrivals from China :-Nóre.
30th June to 6th July, 1913, London, 13th June.
Low Water Arrivals from China:-Tydeus,
Hogg targ
Mean Den of Glamis, Welsh Prince
The following vessels have pas~ eed the Canal:-Calohas, Indraní,
gaur, Yap, Fred. Wil Namur, Nile, Persons, Poly- helmshafen, Rabaul
Herbertehohe, Matupi, nesien, Atrous,
Australia, Tasmania and
Now Zealand via Bris-
bane Per Coblenz, – 12th July, 8 a.m.
Opstä i, Piésh, Fried or Sföwel, Vinden Haddock, Kppade,
ALEXANDBA" QAYN.
High Water
Mo...
THAS
Wad
10
13
歌
14, 10.0 22
*!
3.4
9850 T. 18th July 10820 T. 27th do
HOMEWARD.
Steamers.
Will leave for Marseilles.
Armand Behic, 10480 T, Tat July Atlantique, 10798 T, 15th 26 Ernest Simons; 9085 T, 29th do
For Freight and Passage apply to;
M. SAINT CLAIR de BUSSIERB, „Agent
"
Queen's Buildings, No. 3.
THE EASTERN & AUSTRALIAN
STEAMSHIP CO., LIMITED,
{
Mail Service to Australia
via Manila.
MAIL SCHEDULE
(SUBJECT TO MODIFICATION),
Steamora.
EASTERN BMPIRE....
ཙྩཱ༔ ་
Arrive Hongkong Learn Hongkong
from Australia,
27th June
25th July.
for Australia.
19th July, at noon.. 16th August, Vij
The above Steamers are fitted with Refrigerating Machinery, en suring a Plentiful supply of Ice, French Provisions, etc., and aro lighted throughout with Electricity: All State-Rooms have Electrio Fans. A duly qualified Doctor and Stewardess are carried. MAG
For further particulare, apply to oldalon DESI
Gibb, Livingston & Go, Gott
Printed and Published by the Proprietor, Dr. J. W. Loe House Street, in the City of Victoria, Hongkong