Examined by you,
Comment on my that any part is perhaps but in the hope to facilitate a division uncalled for of being able to facilitate & with a view of saving some amount to the fronted of reference Correspondence I will venture to make a few remarks which have occurred to me after a perusal of it.
The There were two Enquiries into The Caldwell charges first terminating in 1859 The second in his favour resulting in his dismissal recorded fu being I say recorded because Shrew Caldwell most injudicious appointment. Refon he up his decision was arrived at.
483 The Committee in July 59 decided that notwithstanding Caldwell's connexion with the Pointe Ma Chow Wong, and the fact his having acted very injudiciously in other matters, there was not enough against him to necessitate his removal from office.
The division of the Committee of Council in 186; reversed the above finding and amounted to this that In Caldwell's long & intimate connexion with Ma Chow Wong was of such a character as to render him unfit to be continued in the public service, according and his dismissal was