305
the Reports given by
the Commissioners
on which
The Government Scheme is based were not in accordance with the Evidence given
and that the measure itself is contrary to the general feelings and wishes of the principal
Inhabitants.
Upon the second point I would submit to you that the Holders of the Marine Lots purchased them for the benefit of the Marine frontage and have held them ever since the year 1841. During that interval they have reclaimed Land and erected wharfs and Buildings upon them with the knowledge, and implied sanction of two succeeding Governors Sir John Davis and Sir George Bonham. If these authorities had entertained any idea of the necessity or importance of the Work now proposed they would undoubtedly have given some intimation on the subject.
It could not now be attempted without great loss to the Owners of the land and a strong case of necessity therefore ought to be shown to justify it. I submit confidently that not only does not any necessity exist but that the policy is not in favor of the measure. There are places of loading and unloading for the public along the Praya front and cargo cannot be carried uninterruptedly along the Sea front by reason of the Barracks and the measure could only therefore be partial and as I conceive unattended by any considerable benefit.
On the other hand the cost of the works must be very large. It seems to me that under no circumstances could it be undertaken without indemnity to the existing holders whose collective outlay is very large and this together with the expense of the Work would make it a costly undertaking. In the meantime there are works of real importance, which are delayed for want of funds and which should be undertaken with the first available means.
On all these grounds I humbly submit that the proposed measure should not be undertaken at all events without much more enquiry. The result of which I am convinced, will be to satisfy you of the impolicy of entering upon it.
In Labouchere,
I have been,
My faithful Servant,
Since I mentioned this subject to you I have more fully examined the rather voluminous documents Connected with it. I have quite satisfied myself that the objectors have no sufficient ground to rely upon and also that it is desirable to stop the agitation which they are endeavouring to get up in the Colony by sending out your decision at once. I therefore submit