INTIMATION.
THE HONGKONG DAILY PRESS, WEDNESDAY, JUNE 12ra, 1907.
TELEGRAMS,
["DAILY PRESS" RXOTASIVE SERVICE.]
It was decided at a general meeting that the H. Viceroy Hsu Shih-chang, in the course marked degree denotes status: its possessor ise of the highest products of evolution: first race for the second year of The Daily of an interview, expressed his regret that the if manifested in art, his "gift" makes bira Telegraph Cup should take place in the Sorp.general state of chaos after the war should have entine on Whit Monday, over the straight 100 given rise to friction between the Chinese and a genins. It is talked of as "the gift", eyards' course. A novel prize was announced to Japanese in Manobarin. It is his intention, it ged, and none quetion its value. Carbo presented by Mr. Raphael E. Baliliosaecording to a Tokyo telegram in the N.-C. THE ORANGE RIVER COLONY. it be that the popular estimate is too sweep. namely, a trophy to be awarded to the competitor Dady Nocs, to remove all cause for ends friction A. S. WATSON & CO., fine-that there is anotlier side of the shield who competes in most races in the Serpentines by undertaking earnestly measures of reform. to betray the disadvantages of imagination including the Christmas Morning rado, irrespec. His administration will be based on a conciliator tive of where ho foistes in the races. Me. J. spirit with the object of promoting harmoniou M. Barrie will again present the Poter Pan" relations betweyn Japiusse and Chinese în oriler Cup for the winner of the Christmas Morning hat both way share the beasts of pmex. Handicap.
LIMITED.
ESTABLISHED A.D. 134).
CHEMISTS, DRUGGISTS AND
PERFUMERS.
BY APPOINTMENT TO
HIS EXCELLENCY THE GOVERNOR.
WATSON'S ORIENTAL
TURKISH BATH
SALTS
VAGRANT AND REFRESHING.
FOR
If не turn
Store
its
to the Bible, with of referents to the faculty, wo find that other side of the shield exclusively picture. It is always viu or wicked. In
Regarding the appointment of Mr. Charles 2 instance is the human imagination cited Denby, chief clerk of the State Department, therein as in anyway a good quality to be American Consul-General at Shaug SKAKESPEAKE, as he always dose, nolie-shai, recut American papers say that is many sides,
The lunatic, he lover, ad the poot Are of imagination all compact." The imaginations of the lanitic we can We call them ballad nations, but guess at. both words it. There is really, little need
Amenting of His Majesty's Justices of the Peace was held at the Magistracy yesterday afternoon. Me F. A. Hazel presided and there, were also present Messrs, G. N. Orme, II. R. Craig, S. B. C. Ress, A. Mackenzio aud selection at a salary of G89,00+ a year is ìn]}{'plaie Lyons. The business was to consider koping with the President's policy to map ont au application from Joan Becard Moller for
marketa fur Amoriéto prožnets in the future | the transfer to him from onò J. E. Birker, of tha Mr. Denby, it is romarked, is the son of former American Minister la Peking and during twenty years rellenos in Chins learned to speak
adjanot licenon to sell by rufal intozinating liquors in the promiss. No 19 and 92 Qanna's Road Wost, ander the sign of The Western
licence was granted
for the hairsplitting definitions of Chang, Chinese. A brother of the appointee is Hole!." There being no police objection the
Congress and as a member of the Foreign Affairs Committee has simwa ndecidedly friendly feeling for Chinn.
What is to be done with Chinese "slaves" who insist on remaining tu “dirvitude"? Thin the awkward question rised by a tologram
from Lord Selborne, which was rend ont in the
Band tapas that the coolies where admitted through a mistake of the Chiness Labour staff. Lord Elgin thereupon urged that the additional which "shares" must be repatriated. to Lord Selborne replied that their reputriation. Wout early £12 compensation, even if the mon could be persuaded to return. (Ironical Opposition chows). It would mean
Trexen,and other precisians of ↑ hat gender. The imaginations of the lover, also, we describe as plensing fiicies, and predict
The following charges ora mule against Sic that his anticipatory innges will breed Gorge Arbuthnot, senior partner of a late lisapintanmat. The jungination of the banking firm of Arbuthast and Co., who has
been arrealexf: That Tas Rajah Krishnt House of Commons by Mr. Winston Churchill, psst is the particular kind that has led in
in answer to a umaker of questiom pw by in. the popular and undiscriminating osterar Bahadur was induced to runow a deposit af for the faculty. It is a surge of intellectual | £29,333 on the understanding that the interdignaut. Radiests with regard to the repeat im- portation of 250 additional Chinese coolies for the would be paid imediately; wid that Sir elevation, learling to a mental Pirmosenseoge Arbuthnot had reason to believe that a Scientifically, psychologically, we know Thunt
cheque givan for that purpose on Octeber 90 the word is misleading. There is really no would be dishonoured. The olssppropriation such thing. What we call imagination. of funds of the Madras Equitable Assurance esph in its noblest forms, tomes, undor Society, for which the bank noted as sacratury mere mosaic of concaptions and treasurer, and of Arbuthnot's Industriak, Qualysis, a derived from experience, from perceptionsluitd. For which the bank acted as manag.
ing agents. of provions actualities. This Mitrox's great ingery of the unquenchable lake of fire, grand as it is from a literary point of view, is to the psychologist no more than an exaggerated concept fonu-l-d periences of litle earthly conflagrations. The pain and read that particular fancy or imagination las caused to conthes thou sands of worthy people serves to bring us back to the point that the faculty of nangin dion may not be always a source of happiness to the average buman being. Some such iden as that which caused WHITMAN W Teaiack that the beasts of the A. S. WATSON & CO., do not lie awake at night thinking of
WATSON'S LOTION
PRICKLY HEAT
A reliable and efficiens remekly.
instant relief.
uires
WATSON'S FRAGRANT
TOOTH WASH
Valuable Autisoptic and detergent.
LIMITED,
THE HONGKONG DISPENSARY.
ALEXANDRA BUILDINGS.
Hongkong. 11th June, 19G.
NOTICE TO CORRESPONDENTS.
INA
אי
their sins seems possible in the case of our illustrative coolies. Do they maintain their cheerfuluess her inse they have less imagin. ation than those who cavy them ? The suggestion is not implausible. Certainly many of us suffer from a too lively imagin- tim. If it be of the anticipatory pleasant kind, it is not worth the certainty of later Jistlusi if it be unpleasaut, we are not
April was a big mouth in Britain's tall The yardage shipments of eutton pises gouds. was enormous as compared with the correspond
wth in 1908 and 19. Egypt and
RO
Turkey look largely, sani so lid Japan. he adian Sgures were very ing indeed, notally A fature is the large Bangal and Bombay.
Clonely exparts of Heached and dyed goods.
are shipping more, cloth requiring skilt Then the oxports of cotton in printing. e. yarn wara po a most nieouraging scale. Ger winy absorbed 6 por vent, a nes than in April of last year. Russia also increased her
Balsy. Altogether taking, and so did
much larger out. than April was a anticipated.
un absolute waste of publie monný at « mement when the Transraul Gearnment was in sure straits for money." Finally, Lord Rigin decided not to press for their repatriation, so that the
slave" are not to be compelled to forfeit their
lucrative posts for starvation in Cà nas,
LONDON, June 11th. The Orange River Colony Constitu tion has been published It is similar to that of the Transvaal.
GUATEMALA'S PRESIDENT
ASSASSINATED.
Lospos, June 11th. President Cabrera of the Republic. of Guatemala has been assassinated. -FRANCO-JAPANESE TREATY,
Los Dos, June 11th. The Frauo-Japanese treaty has hern signed.
AMERICA AND JAPAN...
SUPREME COURT.
Tuesday, June th.
IN ADMIRALTY JURIDICTION,
BEFORE THE CHIEF JUSTICE (81e Francis PRIGOTT), AND THE HON. MR. E. A. HRWERT (NAUTICAL ASSESSOR).
A BALVAUM CLIM
The action for salvaga hrought by the Hamburg-Amerika Linia and the mister and praw of the six, Arugonia "a ṛainst the China Navigation Company, Id., the owners of the 8.9,** Kapak * hervarge and freight, was con- unued. Mr. M. W. Shuis (læstracted by Mr. G. Hastings of Messrs. Hastings and Hastingsi appeared for the plaintiff, while defendanta were represented by the Hon. Mr. H. E. Pollock, K.C., instructel by Masses. Johnson, Stokoe and Master).
Captain Ernst, of the “Aragonis,” having en cluded his evidence, the Chief Engineer was called, and confirmed his testimony.
His Hanour then asked Me. Slade what he
would say, in assessing a corsonable amount to be paid, was the value of the services rendered by the "Aragonin" going inside Ockson, as that was the question the Assemar and he had tom consider.
Mr. Slade, after deliberation, said he thought 10 per cent, of the value of the vessel should be paid in causidaration of the dasgor and risk
Losnos, June 11th. Officiune siness is felt at Washing on regarding the Japanese ensed by the tamer going at night iste un. Progressives' demands.
TOKYO, June 11th. Regarding Renter's message of the trh instant with reference to the formation of a Japanese political coalition for the object forting the recall of Baron Aoki, and demanding an apology from the United States, a deputation of Pacific Coast Japanese has been for sometime in Tokyo, and prompted the
recent Progressive
The report for the half-year ended December deputation to the Government. The
in 31st of the Eastern Extension, Australasia, and movement is not regarded as China Telegraph Company states that the gross
The
portant.
REUTER'S SERVICE]
PRINCE PUSHIMI'S RETURN.
Loseus, June b. Prince Fushimi las arrived at Quebec where he received a warm welcome.
FRANCE, THE UNITED STATES AND JAPAN,
ceipts amonated to £296,334, ag inst. £317,100 for the corresponding half-year of 1965, working expenses, including £12,855 for maintenane of cables, absorb £139,51 ) against £135,507, Jensing a balanes of £156,8-4. From this is dedustel £3,411 for juegas-lax payable in Euxland and donations to China roliof faude, and £15,148 for interest on mortgage debenture The Pioneer publishes an article arging stock, leaving as the a profit for the half-year
Follow that important reralts might
the 38,'. Altealing 183950 brought for- route along the ancient word, there is an available balanes of £227,84. opening of a trada and almost forgotten read from the north-east One quarterly interim dividend of it per cent corner of Assam into the rich Chinese progiace has been paid for the half-year, and it is now of Szechwan This, the Pioneer admits proposed to distribute another of like amona, would involve the crossing of a fringe of making, with the interio dividends paid for nominally Tibetau territory, but would afford the first half year, a total dividend of 5 por the statement that France had offered her good offices to the United States was in correct. Nothing indicates that the relations between the United States and Japan pressitate such good offices; but it is true
LONDON, June 9th. A semi-official note issued in Paris says
surveyed waters.
Mr. S. Silverstone, sgeit, of the ebarternes of the Agonia," deposed that the time lost to the Aragonia" by the towing of the "Hupel was two days.
Mr. Pollock--But pua was a Sunday. Don't
Sunday? you have te tako out a pocmit to work
Witness We do. Mr. Pollock Yes, and pay a fos of something like $2502
With-se--We pay a fee of $100
Mr. Pollock-Are you in the habit of paying
Witness-i am. When necessary, 1.get those fee for working on Sunday? permits for steamers to work on Sandays.
Mr. Pollock was proseeding to address the ------ Court for defonce, when
His Lordship said-What we don't under. stand is why, If tho "Hapeh" did ask to be towel to Maten, and finding the "Aragonia 'was not. heading in that direction, the people on boară- the "Inpel" did not at once protest aml ask the, "Aragonia" what she was doing?
Atr. Pollack-Well, my Lord, when spanking or signalling at 994 no doos abt stop to argue | and call each other in pes through the m-ga
phone.
His Honour-How far will. the megaphon curry!
Mr. Pollock-That clop and upon the size of the megaphone.
Mr. Pollock continued his address in which he incurred by the Aragonia and that she was contended that there was ro danger and risk
entifled only to the waft wing charges in such circumstances, plus the cost of the extra charter couey and oxtra coal,
Captain Mathins of the fuprah" said he had
a much saror route than the railways from cent. It is also proposed to pay a bonus Tongking and Rarmo. The Pioneer suggests of 44 par share, or par csal, making a total that if the Secretary of State for Ingin is distribution of 7 par cout, for the year 1908. 15. Chitous statele the news calian compensated for the preliminary dread by inclined to surrender the opium traffic, he The sum of £75,300 has ben transferred to the
the anbseruent dissipation of the bogie. should torgain for the opening of this route general reserve fund, and the balance of that the most friendly parleving had taken in command of tha" Hapeb" sinos 1903.
ale vai dar addressed in Taz Entr
Dorespondents const_formand their manys el This later kind of imagination is very
adsense?
Blekan, ad jur goalderation, but asendoare of good
And letters jouendicarei deunte de medien « « joan zide of then paguan sakņi
No Taragon any sija-l cununicationes Beat home alibaly app send ca ilhar jag is will be instated,
Moders for enten copies of Dany Press dobit tor
and kegyer 19 any and amit pollination. After that bear the supply is livedal," "Dalyanppled for Cash"
Pocogonplus Aridess: Press, Todos - 4,B,C, SF 88. Lieber, Pia, Bar, 34 Polephone dio, 12
KEETHS
On May 30th, ad Hankow, this wife of P. A. burn, Chanomissioner of Customis, of a sỰȚI
Fin Juny Isk, at sa ghu, the wife of M. ESA, of a son
DEATH.
E
da June 2nd at Shanghu, CromneS ANDERSON, Ide Master of Arnis, U. S. Navy, aged 61 years,
HENGKONGOFFICE: 101, DES VEUX ROAD C LONDON OFFICA: 131, PLOST STREET, E.C
The Daily Press.
*8
J
laying and working of a sub naring cable between
TOKYO.
LONDON, June 9th. Sir Claude Macdonald has been received in ansience by the King prior to his departure for Tokyo.
a quid pro quo, the Peking Government | £17,314 carried forward. The Company's New common, and we must add to SHAKESPEARE'S not being likely to oppose the scheme.
Zealand and China cables have been partially place with the American Government-con- list of the lunatic, lover, and poet, the
renewed during the past year, sul the cost.erning France's arrangement with Japan. Negotiations are now la progcean between mouating to £ 4,16) has bo charged against THE BRITISH AMBASSADOR TO coward.
Elsewhere, in leel, the hard has Mr. Rust. the American Secretary of State, the general reserve fund. With a view to father, noted that individual's forth of imagination and Viscount Aoki, the Japanese Ambassador improving telegraphic communication with the as when into the mouth of CAESAR he puts at Washington, with a view to concinding Far East, the directors have obtained a con- Session from the Dutch overnment for the' the worlà, “Cowards die many times before comprehensive Immigration Treaty between their deaths! The thousand little worries Japan and America. It is safil in explanation of this statement that although the American ¦ of ordinary daily life rany many of the Immigration Law was revised during the last
included in the category.
·ession of Congress, it is felt that the matter is The shadows that harbinger raming events are always one which should be settled by a Treaty. There bigger than their cause. The imagined was a desire to arrange a Treaty at the time the frouble of to-morrow is greater than the revision took place, but the negotiations were postponed iu consequence of the foeling ia We are positive discomfort of to-day
Japan. ho message adds that the negotiations perturbed over things that do not muter have made progress and it is probable that the because we imagine they may or will matter. Treaty will be signed in the early lature. The so-called "gift" of imagination ankes
"
Java and the Cocoa Islands. The com munication is expected to be opened towaris the and of the current year, and will provide au alternative route for the company's traffic.
V. R. C.
BRITISH ARMY MANCEUVRES.
LONDON, June 9th.
the heir to a legacy unhappy in showing teddee, 21, clerk, pleaded guilty to having value of $3,200 were lost in the September will culminate in an attack on the fortress,
him a dozen ways in which he may lose his inheritanen; it curses the healthy man with vivid impressions of possible infections; it. peuples the dark, the ank nown, with horrid creatures; and though we cannot deny the "pleasures of imagination," it must emphasise its sorrows also.
Arrangements for the equipment of the forces will be most complete.
N... Daily News Service:] KOREAN AFFAIRS.
boon on the China Coast sine 1895 and had been
دار
He
detailed thus rents of the 5th December last when the propeller shaft of the "Hapok" broke. On the following morning he signalled the "Aragonia "uud en she steamed abreast of the Hipsh the Captain asked witness where he wanted to be lowed. Witness, speaking through The the megaphone, answered Matsu". Captain of the Aragonia" replied--" You must come on board and talk to me". Witness responded I consider the wosther unfit for boarding." The Captain of the "Hapab" them said—' I will do my best for yon ".-Witness then noticed that the Aragooia" drew ahead and canted over towarla thé “ Hapoh”, passing elow to the latter's bows. Witness did not consider it was necessary for the Aragania"
the "Hapeb's " to go as far as she did. She could have laid off his remerka with models.
The case was adjourned.
quarter.
Witness illustrated
IN SUMMARY JURISDICTION.
BEFORE Ms. A. G. WISE (Puisse Jumanji
THE CONNAUGHT HOUSE.
In view of the necessity for a closer study The Victoria Recreation Club has its annual of siege operations, and of the experiences meeting on the 19th just. Musure. R. W. Pear. at Port Arthur, the army maneuvres will Bou, F. Lammert, and L. A. Musso, as Bost
be in the neighbourhood of Chatham, and At the Clerkenwell Sessions Josepha Ernest hoass sub-Committee, report that boats to the stoles a cheque for £28 14s, the property of typhoon The recommend that only pair-oses his masters, Tador Lucorporated, of Elyplace, be intilt for the present. Mossrs. N. H. Alves, He born, also to having stolen 15,207 articles J. W. Bains, and R. W. Pear son, as Bati-
Some time ago un action was brought by a of jewellary, brooches, pins, &c., value £324. Lonte sab-Committee, dwelt on the success of
number of Chiness against The Connaught Mr. Wing, for Geddes, sakl be was the son of the night fêter, and enggested the possibility of
House, but, as the Paine Judge pointed out, a prosperona English merchant in Shanghai, au interport swimming fixture, Mears. W.
bricks and mortar could not be sued. The writ and in 1902 be left for Russia, where he was Logan, J. A. S. Alver, and H. M. Harrop, as
was amended and the managing partner was arrested as a Japanesespy, and accused of selling gymoneiam sub-Committee, said that the
summoned but on bis declaring that he was only A casual remark sometimes made by of imagination, in abort, has its titoris; and plans of Port Arthur to the Japanese. He was jujitsu class had to be abandoned owing to
one of eight the wril was again amended. On this bystander observing a procession of Chinese there is the temptation to envy the coolie exposed to great hardships and suffering, | langu ge diffeallias. Mosers. E. M. Hazeland Korean Cabinet, which consists practically of
occasion a series of actious wore beard. Butchers, Plies leads reflections on the subjects who, if he enjoy not the fragrance and bentally Augged, and for many days lauguished | M. A. A. Souza, and M. Mclser as Bar sub-Japanese nominees, Marquis Ito has now in- imagination. These patist labourers.
colour of the flowers, at least seems able to in gaol, with the torror of death before him. Committee report that stock worth $133.78 was dead Ministers to decide not to have audiencs Lakers, compradores, and dairy men brought
of the Emperor separately, but in a body after laughing and chattering amongst them
As a consequence, his health became impaired, lost in the lyphoon. Nevertheless the balance ignore she prickles.
Thore was no truth in the accusations, and of pr ft on the auason was good, $325 38. The conference at the Residency-General. Thaparate actions against the proprietors for goods selves, frequently prompt foreigners who have some idea of their lot to wonder at Prince Arthur of Connaught bas been ordered | eventually, after many months in Siberiua accounts were audited by Mr. II. Murray Bain, step, it is explained, is intended to make for applied to the amount of $849.6). The pro- guls, he was set at liberty. Geddes was erdered as presented by Mr. S. A. Soth, boa, treasurer.
HONGKONG, JUNE 12TH, 1907.
seebis We
The rose
to join the Scots Greye at Edinburgh, on his recent promotion to captain in the regiment.
King Edward's offer to placs a man-of-war at Prince Fushimi's disposal for the voyage from Vancouver to Yokohama has been accepte. H.M.S. Moumouth proceeds for the purpose from Weihaiweŝ to Vancantar.
six months' imprisonment..
The avancil of the British Cotton-Grewing Association has asked Lord Derby, as lori lieutenant of the county of Lancashire, to howt a county movement for obtaining subscriptions from landowners, property owners, and other
THE WISDOM OF THE EAST.
A HORNE THAT KNOWS THE UNIFORM. A case which caused considerable amuse- ment to those who board it camo on for hour
TOKYO, June 5tb.
On the heels of the formation of the new
All the
prietors were Wong Fang Stek, Tsoi Sing. Ministerial harmony, and to prevoat individual Li Wai Nara, Kwar Tsui Kwan, Nam Shui Ministers from seeking for themselves Imperial Tong, Lai Hop Kee, and Kwan Fak Yuv, but their apparent happiness. Working hard
favour to the prejudice of their cellenguas and poly the second, fourib, sixth and eighth had by after day for twenty cents or less, pro-
from proving false to the guiding influence of been served. Only one man answered to big curing thereby only the meagrest portion
the Resident-General. No special acumen is name and after judgment had been given of the bareef necessitice, how can they afford
required to understand the real significance of against those who had been served it appearad that other two were in court. When questionedd to laugh? The foreigner, in comparison
this last mezrute,
why they had not answered to their names they with them surfented with luxuries. bus bis
stated that they thought it was only the other lines of care, and perhaps in the midst of
Baron Komues, the Japanese Ambassador, worrying over something or other, remarks ftaly and Switzerland, will reach Paris at the trade, se, owing to the very heavy and increas
The King of Siam, after a tour in Northern | Capitulisis interested in the welfare of the cottoning before Mr. G, N. Orme at the Police
man who was on trial. His Lordship eaid he Court yesterday, when Conetable Wingard has forwarded to Lord Rothschild, the obairman the heerinlness of the coolie. They trend of June. His Majesty will stay u fortuighting donors for cipital for the provision of summoned a Chinaman residing at. Station of the British Red Cross Society, a copy of bad a good mind to send them to gaol, but * better off" thun hé is, he concludes, and in the French capital, in order to deal with some
a letter addressed by him to Sir Edward Grey. ultimately he heard their stories. gib uing factories and other plant, and the inade Street, Yaumati, for allowing his hores to
informing him that the Japanese Red Cross defondants pleaded that their accountant had quate support received from both employers and
stray at large.
The native pleaded guilty, Society will be represented at the conference by
Hs Honour told them that was their plexities of civilization, and to advantages London to visit King Edward.
funds is absolutely necessary to enable the work loose when tethered. The constable informed adding: Iu hringing the present matter to of the Simple Life. We ory for things
The London Gazelle sunounced that Tas to be carried on efficiently. The council has also big Warship that he had seen the animal in your netice under the request of Count Matsu fault: When they asked for time be declined, we unagine we need," one such person said King line been pleased to appoint General bis decided to proved at once with a schons for quafisa wandering about for the last twe gain, the president of the Ronists. I heg to a
bat in desiding to delegate to the conference the other day, and one of his words seemed Imperial Highnes the Princs Sudanaru Fu- raising capital by means of an auxiliary weeks, but it was only a day or so ago since he
prominent a parsonage of the society had been successful in findi ag the owner. The as Barou Ozawa, the society have taker into arrestive. Was there a clue in the word shimi of Jajan to be nu Heuerary Member of Į comping which would erect ginuing factories in
the Military Division of the First Class, or West A friss to be leased and worked by the Magistrate smiled broadly when the constable their consideration that the conference is to
At a meeting of ratepayers of the French **imagination": A form of reproach not
emmen is to say of is person that he Knights Grand Cross of the Most Honourable association. It is proposed to raise a quarter of gortinued It was hard to catch this horse, take place in the country with which we are en-
joying such cordial and special relations of Concession held in the Municipal Hall, Shang- Order of the Bath." The Gazette also con. a million pounds by this means. The total
as it was a Chinese hores, and as soon as it saw friendship." The delegates from the Japanese hai, on June 14th, the resolution to raise the lasks incagination. Imagination, it is tained announcements of other distinctions capitsi of the association subscribed up to the
the uniform it Bed". A fine of $5 was imposed Government will be Surgeon Major Kasai, property tax in the settlement extension from Colonel Goru Shiba, and Surgeon Kenji 5 per cent. upon house rentals to cover the extra generally understood, is a quality of the bestowed upon the members of Prince Fushimi's present is £256,261.
on the owner.
Kawanisbi.
cost ef road maintenance, police, eto, mas tried higher civilization. Its possession in ย uite,
says something platitudinal about the "om important State affairs, and will then go toperativer, the immediate provision of additional stating in defones that the horse always broke Haron Taken Ozawa and Dr. Nagao Ariga, and left them and they knew nothing of the
accounts.
ying that if he did so they would go into bankruptcy. Judgment was entered for the seven plaintiff with cost.