L
FOR SALE.
ADIES' SWIMMING COSTUMRS.
LADIES SWIMMING SUITS. GENTLEMEN'S SWIMMING
DRESSES.
GENTLEMEN'S
DRAWERS."
SWIMMING
BATHING SHOES. WATERPROOF, BATUING CAPS, LIFE SAVING DULTS and DRESSES BATHING TOWELS and BLANKE 13. BATH SPONGES
WIRD SPRING MATTE€38, for Bemmbr.
SUN UMBRELLAS. CHOLERA SELVS.
WHITE CRAPE TENNIS SAfRTS.
LANH, CỦAWFORD & Co.
Hongkong, Wth Hop, 1993.
1632
NOTICE
A.
8. WATSON AND
FAMILY AND Disponatko
CHEMISIS.
PERFUMERS,
PATENT MEDICIYS VENDORS,
Dawanlata' SAXARTMAN,
And
ABRATED WATER MAKERS.
JAIPS' LABDICINE CHESTS REFITTEE,
PASSENGER SRIPS SUPPLIED
NOTIUE--To avoid delay in the execution of Orders it is particularly requested that all business communications he addressed to the Pim, A. 8. WATSON and Got, or
HONGKONG DISPENSARY, 723
NOTICES TO ÇORRESPONDENTS..
countermandad.
Ordera for extra copies of the Daily Press-should- be seat befgro 1 m. on the day of publication.
Alter that hour the supply is limited.
-BIRTH.
the wife of Mr. WILLIAM WHERTS, of a
MARRIAGE..
The Daily
Press
HONGKONG, JUNE 26TH, 188).
We fear
་།
11
The British steaner Veeracion and the British
·
Monday
Tuesday
Wednesday
Friday
Thursday
Saturday Sunday
...
您
950
.87....... 300
353
305
24
510
Bang
2,292
*242
THE DAILY PANK TOEJJAT, JUNE 28cm -1771.
the pislatiff now complaiqad was Mr. Flag Smith's combent on that ortioise
mist painsin fo Nagamki longer than was notarVATE
..
member of the reporting staff
Telegrame for Bangkok can go forward by the Hongking Telegraph. The Tearood counsel
Our authority for the police court reporting on the wor to questions of Me. Franels the plaintiff times mare powerful than any suit for damagor, Jarbenwall Hetes was a good one--no faen a perian, satd-Winn ay angagament with the China It was thing noknown in the history of a mait olasing at Bingapore at 10 am, to-day, the then read the petition. In which the plaintif
fres proes, for abs editor to sua sofher 28sh jest,
claimed $1,000 for libet, and the unsyor (both of In day yesterday's fans we reproduced & patep than Mr Bulgin hiusoil-but we uliositatgly Mail was copoladed, Mr. Murray. Bain was su
➢-
xious to renew the engagement, and when Mr. for durangen for publishing an independent which have already bars pabituled), and went sa from the Rising Bra and Nagasaki Szprast, which withdraw the allegation if it is questioned- The British steamer Chinbiang, which arrived to say that the plaintif both with steraneo to criticised méher roughly the notion taken by Admiral he said Mr. Balgin would tell them he never hull Balu had formed the intention of going home, statement upon him, bags, as he (the de here yesterday from Shanghai, brought of This abilities can editor and what he wrote in Wittes in ordering that Her Majesty'e ships should say comprasication bat onda in his life with Mr. he ssut for mas to take the position of vilter and fordant) would show, upon a good founde Frase-Smith and then no reference was made as manager of the China Mail. I bara sever inn. He did not argun that the whole of the 17,500 in treasure.
the China Mud was open-to anything and every for sealing, du The reason which fol to the Come to the Clerkenwell News, and that as a matter of stated to Mr. Smith that I have been engaged pamerapli was true, bat be seared the jary pa Port Darwin must be progressing new thing in the shape of legitimsta áriticism; ba put mander in ablating this order are parfootly wallsfot be ueror had any "couuestion" with the as Police Court reporter to the Clerkoniveli News, kin honour; and, he would swear it ‘on his cattı. daily paper called the North Austention has been himself up, as to say, he did every public writer, known; Marled to be perfous hot bed of
and the Admiral boing the respassibly gone. Derkantwell News With refereñoa jo the I shozid like to make a statement with regard when he got into the box, that from w Mr. As a target to be shot at wherever he laid himself
to that,
Bolgin and his own frisade had told hima; le bo- started to compata with the Northern Territory
very properly, in our opinion, weta Nagienki e pes Times. The first number appessed on bus lat apan to altask, and of any fair and logitimate dan of the hesiths of the men under His command following statement
Onraathority for theramark that Mr. Baigin proved Mr Francis-There is not the lost ouasion, loved it was true. As he was only an apaÁsur oriticism on himself in his editorial-ospacity, or icad pork for Britiste men of war antil effoolire an attor fallera on the China Mail is also good one Jane, and is oreditably got up,
Cross-examined by the defendant-I am 32 lawyer na wall us an amateur journalist, hs on his wrillaga, as to their styleand composition measures were taken to orellaste the contagious als. Mr. George Murray Bain--but 'as that gootiem C
years of age, sad I left school at eighteen. I was thought it would make the dass more clear to We clip the following telegram, dated London, or as to the opinions expressed in them, be dides which had made the place notorions. Howeger
may possibly hare bien mistakes we also apologies four and a half yours on Mr. Baxter's newspaper, the jars if he stated what the law applying to for what after all in a more expression of opinion- the 31st May, from the North Australian :-"The not some there to somplain. What he comprejediced our scatompomey may be rainst Admiral London Standard states that the British Goplained of was that the remarks of the defendant, the oborations as lost offer's suitabl. The learns anusal said that unfortunately, or two years on the Daily Chronicle, and I came to the sasa was. The losened barrister bad mad?
lty for the important command be at present holds Pornment has onbeanted to permit the establish exceeded the limits of legitimais criliciam, they are not in gend farts, nor can they bo jattiied. The parhaps fortunately for Dr, Fraber-Shaith, Mr. the China Mail in 1876, arriving in March. out a good ex garie cast as that would be a Tha defendant pointed out that these periods, good one anopposed. He believed · Fils Lord. « ment of several English stations on the coast of went beyond lassubject matteras towhich he was gallani Admiral na ecu good marving turing a long Geotso Murray Baio was not here, bat of the New Guinest facing Torres Straits,"
opon to be eltanked they want from the man and homonesble garoor, and although the fact of his probability of Mr. Baia ever having made each added to the time which has etapsed sines the ship would tell them that the statement being. sanoditor to the man himself apart from his bolag a rather alelos diestpifuncion is utters a statomout as that the jury would be able to plaintiff name to the China Mail, would mako incorruet in sovral partionlara did not "non- The Milsu Biabi steamer Nagoya Hors, which pos tion san editor; and they attacked and oritering the service has perhaps made him low popa judge by the fact that Mr. Baigin was hard again Mr. Bulgin oat to be a year and half older than stitate it's libel, but that it would be suficient a.ahaw that he honestly believed what he statel arrived at Shanghai on the 21st inst., reports that cised his position as editor act upon thots, tratar than a of his pradosessors, it, has over even stor of the same paper. He did not think the age he had given.
binta that he was not a thorough meator of the jury and consider it probable, eran if Me.
The plaintiff I may have made soms mistake to be tras. That was the law nocording to many she passed tho Sumida Murat &a.m. on the agon falibcods. They frat stated what wa|profession-su officer and a goatlossa in avery cos- 17tb and that she was still fast on a rook 12 false with rezard to him in point of fact, and post
Frador-Baith wees to state it, that Mr. Bainas to the age at which I loft schoo! Ianid I was recent decisions. The defendant proceeded to then about eighteen years of age. It is a long taler to tho paragraph in the Nagasaki Express of miles from Shimonesoki, but there is good pres-thon band as athok npn those falsehoods. Naw undoubtedly the orter and by Adolral would oncoge a man who had bolore proved au poot of the vessel being saved,
The defencesst up was that the statements were Will was a matter which an editor was utter istlase. Instead of being a suitable apology time ago, and I may have made a mistake with the 20th May, on which Mr. Belgin had written
and led to the paragraph which formed the bat
In writing the pangraph tha The defendant-You say Me Miray Bain of this action. not false, I was not distinctly elated in the entitled to disons, and the editor of the such a statement na bat simply made things regard to that.
Having aritiaised defecco that the allegations made were true, Naganaki paper was justiled in-expressing ten thousand tirans worse. steamer Albay loft the Aberdeen tack, and the nevertheless it was statcé indirectly that they his opinion, whatever it might be, ne to the the remainder of the atticts the leacond counselored to renew your angagaosat with him when editor of the Nagasaki Express was perfectly justified; tho matter was one of great literart Spanish steamer Pasig war andooked at Kow. were not falee, that they were not easiliciously pa-polley or impotior of the Admirst's action, said he intended to put in in evidenes, with it had expired. loon yesterday. The German back Gerd Hege liahol, thatike defendant & and fide balieved them and he was perfectly datitist to say if he liked, view to show that these attacks on Mr. Bulgin
Plaintif-Hoored to ronow it terminable to the welfare of the port of Nagamki, whom was dooked at Aberdeen yesterday and the the true, that they were not directed against As his (the learned counsel) beifeved be Ti bay, had not bean baad file: A littlo paragraph pab with a six months notios on either side; and the prisones of a British woan-of-war was net British atester Naples will bo doskod then the plainti ar sept in his public capacity, and that it was time the Admiral was put upon the shed in the Telegraph of the 7th May-
whom I came through here on my way home, he very unlikely to be required by an outbreak in the sonatry. Trino affected the port as w 00, to-day.
that they mure Igitimate odtisien. Ho (the shelf. That might be a very wide and sweeping - What may happen to a man in storia. Ho we wanted me to break my journey off here,
Defendant-Was the offer of the renewal of matter connected with its trade, and it was The gambest Cuskohufer merived here from learned counsel) thought he would satisfy the conclusion to drove from the single not of thea Moibourne daily newspaper, and coconlly ho ob the agreement on the same terms as the former matter which the oditor of the Nagsacki England yesterday morning. Mae is a vessel of jury by the most completo evidense that the Admiral's which was criticised. The article in tairol the thres were holiday granted to each of one? Oh, mera than that, on the ime term a Express was fully jathibod in dealing with. the same clots as the Earow, which arrived a short statements were false, and i ha did who the Nagasaki Express was fairly open to criticism, the fellows in turn throughout the font. He set the last year of my agreement. After losting This criticism was dealt with by the China By Appointment to His Ezeliny the Gods use, and like it, otrries four guns. Her thought his Lordship would tell them no sues. To deal with the subject matter of that article up the country by rai., and near him in the carriage the Ching Hail I went on to the Japan Mail. Mail an foliowa(bors extract read). He
reavon'sad bin Royal Highness the
ofasers are:-Licut. and Commander, Henry Wsion wbataver, no power, privilege, or duty Mr. was legitimate criticism, and Mr. Fraser Smith's at a most attractive example of a lovely wron
Why did you leave that paper PI analled (defendant) contended that in writing such a Hill; Sub-Licula, Heart W. Sharp and Godfrey Fraser-Baith gut have as aditor to attack or artiels as it began, wase fair and reasonable one, subject to the dacciption of fat, Fair, and forty *DUKE OF EDINBURGH,
H. R. Maudy; Burgeon, Samael C. Bronze; As priticise another editor could possibly oxanse or he gave his russons for his outains, but be made ur friend of the press, it must ho ceased, in rory may agreement for a number of reasons which I amunt on what was stated in the Nagasaki
mauly address. Lady happens to drop har handker
I got there, and I. left at the end of the month: journalistic etiquette and custom whisk the
· WHOLESALE AND RETÁIU' 1) RUGÓISTH, start Paye tetor.in-Charge, George A. Hakyn:justify the publication of a faluobood is point use of the occasion, as he might lawfally de, to booking, aganhat 20, and of excanding y gesto do not care to make public. I ascelled it after Express the plaintiff showed an ignorance of
chiof; roportar pioksit np, and, bauda i over with Engine, John E. Chang Garner, George S. of fact. That the publication was malicious was criticise Sha Chins Mail, He said-
What was your agreement for To be editor | lowest on boy whoever swept out a news. more a dtter for the jury to inter from the Der eroning soatonomy the Chijini in the most killing bow. Courerosion scen, Rage- Janninge.
fari thanasian than one which could be abso-hing the Nagasaki Ebyross over the goals says: ter talls who he is, and states that he is going over of bue paper; it was an agreement terminalin by paper aftes i mld not have been guilty at The three months' notice an ofther aide, After this £}acfendant went on to argue that the expressida. Return of visitors to the City Hall Museum for utely proved. They could not open ant to the Iti a man and comtedly proceeding, of which to Tasmania to complete las baidage. Inly enga
tho is travelling for microstion, and happens to be joined the Shanghai. Ubarier as pasditor with amateur journalist was want to refer to this work ending 24th June:-
...jury Mr. Smith's besit and mind and show thomur journalista ara fraquently guilty, to make
and saampions zomarks concerning per also on the way to the same place. Both loucuor to Mr. Prastan, I did not join a reportar, but I himself, and he thought tho jury, or may mae of Egorman. ODINSON. the motives by which he was actuated when he right to and not cruntly in kocordance with their rether. The lady is the widow of a cocamial quarts did reporting, the same as when I was on osamos sruse, would come to that oclusion.
wrote the artials, but they could the jury webus."
zoofor, and has an income of $1,000 a year. She hat
the China May, and as I do now. I was Howse the only amateur journalist in the Far from the nature of the article, from its exess Now he did not hold that up as the very best proprietor of the paper with whom our raportorial thers a your, my engagement being tor-
also a mansion at Tovenk, and one morning when the
East-amatent ag-called, and this was a bank- if they found it to be in excess, from Mr. Smith's previous conduct in annecessarily attasking style of oriticism. The editor of the China Mail friend had boea eagared, was standing near the man, minable by month's naine. I laft beesuse bandel attack at the editor of the Hongkang was perfectly at liberly to express that opinion elox in question debesing whether he would invoat a I winted to go home to England. It is not Telegraph. Mr. Bulgin teid it was not, bat Mr Balgin: to infor that the article war not pubished bend ide in the sole ria of the publin with referance to the marks of the Nagaruhi shilling in a asb, or wait for the three penny boa, true that I was discharged, I sut in my the jury had seen that he did not know who the resignation. On the contrary it was made editor of the Nagasaki Wapraar was; he said he interests mobcarted, but was published for the pra; he would have done ten thousand times there wasps past buna atrlab carriage with coach-
within the narriaga a lady and gentleman. They cra Lown to me that Mr. Preston was leaving the had simply written from impressions, and wast purpose of anaogance and for the purpose of better if he bad pointed as that when the amid footrace all in the first rank of fashion, and A correspondant of the du Pas writes from An.doing Mr. Bulgin an ignty. The publication Nagasaki Exproes gave its opinion that the the widow and the suportor, married. Adrance Aus-paper, and that if I wished I could have the those impressions were he had forgottes. The aconer the Admiral was abolred the better tho tralia 1 From the above it will be sasa tass there aditorship. I bave never hear I that Mr. Drum Hongkong Telegraph had been plain spoken ching that the people in the province of Au-hui of the false statements contained in the ariole aditae of the Express would have noted more fairly are still prises in the nagget" Hue to be picked up mond stated that I did not do for the Courier, against all abruses, and against the China Heit are intensely axasperated at the Frauoh para- could bass lat ons effcot, and that was to defama
and I rbould be very mash surprised if he has occasionally; these linos could not possibly retr The remark A very pretty little story and very prettily told, said six. I can produce a letter I received from to the citat of the Nagarali Express, but minst tons in Andale. The Catholic priests and the the plaintif and injure him in the estimation of if he had meatiound the acts that rendered the in Australe. English missionaries are in great trepidation lost any one who without knowlod o of him or his posi, Admiral unfit for his position. the inhabitants should rise against them, and tion read them. It was stated as a matter of partook a little el sbaan.' it was not the-vory but why except for personal apite and malice, that gantioman accepting my resignation. I have been meant for tas editor of the Hongkong never told you I was Police Court raportar for Telegraph. If the jury believed that this was have communicated their fears to their reapan foot that before he came to Uhina he had had highest style of criticism, and if Me. Fraser should this be added on to it
The talented author of “notes on Mauritius, Ane the Clericsmosil News, neither by eonversation, the foundation was completely taken away. Advartaments and Subscriptions which are not tive Console, asking than to natify the outboas experiege in soy aditorial capacity-Smith in his commanto on that articians
from the plaintiff's case. A man publicly at- of the hunt while compiling those marvels of literature ordared for a fixed period will be continuad nutilities to give fordiguera protection in vase of not in these words oxsetly, but in words and confined himself to pointing out that the tralia, &o, &c. was evidently in the cast and out nor by lattene
The defendant-I hold a letter from you, you tacked had a right to defend himself in the same emergency-Dully News.
which are equally effective. It was stated dite of the China Mat was guilty of some.
are on your gatha, and I advise you to take care. mancor in a newspaper, and if he wont beyond own imagination. No, no, Mr. J. B., journalists of Thia extire journalistic experiance is confined thior of the ass Burt, that he displayed want which bare not made him famous oxcopking in hie
your type de not, anale up say of the "unggeta" Did you ever give me any of your experieness what we actually trus, be was exonerated if he An increasing trade has aprang up between to Policy Court reporting for a low class and taste and gave u justification for
in Police Coart reporting in London P
believed it to have been true when he wrote it, Kinngebow and Hoogkung in pigs, which were sper. If say proprietor of a newspaper in the his remark with reference to the Nagasaki Es in say country; your dart in about a thirty has a
PlaintifTo the best of my knowledge I "The defendant went ca to deal with the plead- ipped from Kiangohor in 1883, the Commis- clones or, anywhere is the Best was looking press, he would have boon within the bounds of wook.thitt for enramming"nde" and taking a tarn
naver did; I will swear I nevar kald you that Iings, and be polite i out that in them a sentence. sioner of Caston's days, to the number of 20,000 round Fors capable man to take the editorship of legitimate eritioista. But he was not atentat the hand crank of the printing machine; your ɔnght to be colland te akrostoling the "wose of a
wes Police Court reporter of the Clerkenwell in the paragraph compliced of had been picked They are carefully fonded, he writes, and fed his paper end had is his mind'a oyo the paragraph to deal with the enbject matter of Mr. Balin's forbs an alendar of the public minil in a newapanar
News.
...: out as having a doublomning, and the ground Or the 19th May, at Kikoara, Burwand, NRW almost entirely on tweet potatons, which abound in question would he thinks Mr. Baigia a itzelartiole and tas parsyesph is the Nagasaki Es. wasp" But the repairing of the local water cast.
at the port and are sold at incredibly low prices. person to mast, his requirements! Would not an, inde an attack on Mr. Bagin self.doubt when he read that paragraph that it was my recollection, I do not think it is possible
press as a public question, but he trial round No man in the colony could have the least
Nor any other papers Not to the best of was stated on which the plaintiff relied for verdiot. He believed is Lordship would This having somewhat raised taj prion of firing, - the astaral result of that paragraph be to defamo On Saturday, the 23rd is, at Sh. Perl's College
The defendant here produced a letter which be him out in saying that if the plaintiff Exiled intended for and referred to Mr. Balgia. It the loer glasses were beginning to complain, Mr. Bulgie, to deprive him of his proper prodit. The article, went on Chapel, by the Bishop of Victoria, HENDY HOGIES,
This Is ervointingly funny. The idos of the of the S. P. GF Missien, Japan, 13 MARS LOJ and have suggested limiting the Bamber of pigs and ropalation as a journalist, and to prevent bien China Mail kaight of the moisture and pasta pot styl.
WAS AS Benedik as anything the sear the plaintiff said was his handwriting. It was to satisfy the jury that the antenos in question which may be exported. HOPKINION.
written it was simply abusive and was worthy of dated the 19th May, 1878, and alluded to come that alleging Mr. Balgia's journalistic ex- Shtalaing saployment in that capacity olsarbera?ing the editor of the Rising Sun su taur journa The words themselves, withant any addition or ins is either the sans iguant or most impudent the lowest class rowspaper that was ever publish. costribution the defendant had seal to the China parienass at home were confined to Polins Court H. Visnot, the editor of the Indépendant de explanation, were defamatory and injurious. But pisce et touloufors we are ever seen even in the ed in Eugland. It was booked on to the end of Mail, as well as other matter dealt with in reporting for the Cerkmall News could be Saigon, fooling himself, aggrieved by pertain the plaintiff, by his petition, asked thein to 0.
organ of missionarics.
paragraph that had nothing todo with Mr. Balgin to previous correspondense, informing the fairly made to bear the interpretation out upos stufements in the” Saiyonnais, dépôted twe friends to wait upon M. Card, the editor of the sider setting further. Beyond the simple On that point Mr. Fraser-Smith was entitled or his journalistio experiences or writings. It defendant that a certain lady who had been it in the plandings, he would not be entitled to a was simply a piece of malicious, impudent, per-named was celebrated in London Palias Courts vardin. When he wrote the paragraph he did latter journal. The friends execute their inc. of the words as they stood was there to his opinion sad to express it,
not great deal mors to be inferred from them.? The Rising Sun and Nagasaki Express Ean been in Bonai abuse, mud that Mr. Fraser-Smith should when the writer was in Landon, either proses so in the firm belief that Mr. Bulgin bad, been sopoission, asking M. Cardí either to with. It was sot merely stated the plaintiff had had existence for years under the prosent management; have been guilty of such senseless attack on tions against a cabman, or in connention with a Polica Court reporter to the Clerkenwall Neto, draw what he had written or to name two of his no previous experience in any siftorial capacity,it in anty a small sheet, hat so far as literary morit is Mr. Bulgin catsids of say critisiem of bloquantity of oats abe, parsisted in keeping to the nod that that was the extent of his journalistia After this it experiance. There was nothdug injurious to Mr. frisada to make arrangements for a dus. M.
bat it went further and made the assertion that concerned it en certainly slain to take a far higher his writings would give to the jury the elus not annoyaãce of har neighbours. We had been hoping that the Government Cardi replied that he had nothing to retract and any experience he might bare hau was coined to place than the China Maif conducting a public
only to the meaning of the article of which they went on to allude to Mr. Smith costeibation Fulgia in saying it, as such thing would not no reparation to offer, and, like a sensible man,
newspaper for festa dous not constituto a man apro would razenäider their intention of placing referred VI Vienot to the sanrts it as soosidered particulareiass of journalistio work in connection faasional journalist we should really like to know complained but also of the ball own temptuous and again, atsting that the contributie was not disqualify him from taking the charge of
with a low-class paper. Did not thosewords olearly what is the test of professionalism.
half insolent apology. Again, in a letter sigasd published because they did not wish to tajarea nowepapon It was not necessary for Captain Dearest in at the head of the Police | himself defamed.
bear the massing put upon them, "that before com- So far legitimata veltisiem on the artiols written
Corostal" pablished on the 3rd April, in- the entertainment company to which the contri- on to have previou experience in editorial. Force. "Banian," when referring to the News, says the Marcary, besa received in ingtCoins se editor of the Chind Mail aferesold by the editor of the China Mail, who is found mediately after Mr. Bulgin's arrival, that gentle.bution had reference by publishing auch dama work to make a capital editor. The Jury wore asked to ocnsider that because it was ging erit olems in the China Mail. proposed appointment on Saturday, rightly Shanghai of the arrival s home of the Starting the said James Knight had had no experience the editor of the Cats Aftat asarining bermax was ettsakad....
The defendant objected to the latter being put Defendant-Now, Mr. Bario, don't you think i said that Mt. Balgin's journalistic experience at remarked that it smacked strongly of a job. Castle. The clipper left the Lightship at 0.10 in any editorial capacity and was not qualified to editor ny an amateur boas portarly satittad take "kie efllorship of a respectable newspaper to point out tost there was a mistake sonja.
in on the ground that while admitting that any after reading that letter, that it is lively you home was confined to the work stated, that it on the 24th May, and she arrived home on the joh will be perpetrated the 21st.. but the home has not transpired. .and was a man of low character and vulgar asso- But immediately afterwards into fell him. thing which appeared in the paper ander editoriai gave me some information nor erning you orpe was musnt to insinuate that he was a person of low character and valgar associations. Thá bryond, redemption. Today, we under-cording to her time of arrival at Enez (on on oiations. Would they think very bighly of self foto the same fault which ho was action-anspices might be used to show matice a letter inoc in Police Court reparting in London
from a correspondeat could hardly bo tend in Plaintiff No, exaspting that letter. I recol-inainaution was not meant, and was not convey. the 12th June) she was 424 hours going through the editor of a newspaper who hat simply been aing in another. Ha bad pointed out, in not
leet the airpumstance now it was on ons sosed by the words. In apeating of the Clerkenwoll stand Mr. Deavy leaves here" for bome the Caual, at the loft Port Sail at 6.30am.gulics court reporter and in connection with very petite tare certainly, that Abuse had a way,
Nec as a low class paper, he was speaking of ilie Lordship said it was often a very hollow slon ohen you wat in a criticism on by the Pacific Mad steamer, and Cap-on the 14th, so that she must have made a very low alsas London rapor? To any one who know been subtilated in the China Mait for argn-
Defendant-That is not the question. Doyonize mats, of its ranks with reference to other Tain Demperen is to take up the Acting rapid run through the Mediterranean and sorese anything about Louden and the papers publishment, hat he himself did tou trasand tima desis of navar stolendauit was the publisher unt remember that yon antamally had soms oon paper. The Times, Standard, Daily News, Teis
the Bay of Biscay-New has been received od there" low class paper" must moon some worse; he snbelitated personal abuse for form of a letter. The defendant was Superintendener of the Palico. No doubt that the Cleangle passed Matte so the 19th inst thing very low indeed. The artiste, not con-oril fois and argonit and based that personal of the imper in which the letter appeared, and versation with me on this subjek I do not, I graph, & wore high class papers, while "loyd's,
Reynolds were low class, Nevarthals kliena: the giant officer is an exemplary gentleman making her time from the Lightship up to her tent with stating falsely that the plaintiff abaco on what was untras in abstapes and tast: Mr. Frannia was at liberty to rosd it to show only rather I gave you some information from Clerkenwell Neins, the Weekly Despach and
war on inexperienced mas sad therefore anfitted he did not know whether it was matras or not, mallon. That was the only object for which it that lotter,
The defondeat than wad a part of the para. latter papers had such won se lassbard Termal. and an excellent military ofcor. He may ressing Mills acurly 90 days."
for bis position, went on to state that whan he as would be abown from bit own letters, but be als be a thorough dissiplarian, and possess The N. 0. Deźly News of the 22nd inst, says: was bare before as aditor of the China Mail for published it purfactly turbines whether it was
We. Francis said the letter professed to he a graph in the China Mil daling with the par George Augustina Balajand Mr. Ashton Dilke,late oriticism of something pablished in the China graph in the Nagasaki Express un Admiral member for Nowcastic writing to them, men -the art of direction so necessary in a Police"We hear from well-informed Chinese sources three yours was an atter failure. The defendea or falsa
that a terram has been reseirad from the out was entitled, of ecuras, to his own opinion on Who, y be sated, is the mighty professional Veil entitled "A few neton of my voyage from Willes, and asked to whom the passageon amatone in the very front rank of joursalists whe eartsin Is gould not be anniderad in consequence men of Force. We say he may, but we have no Taung li Yawes of a distinctly pacifle nature; that point, bat he must not base nou it a crit, sathority of the China Hatif We ansvar a person
Melbourne to Hongkong." He would ball attan-journaliste was intended to apply. tion to this para raph.
Plaintiff-The editor of the Bising Sun and low ohdraster and valgur assouiations. It wär proof of it. He was for a few months, on and the generally received inferene is that the cism of Mr. Balgin'e prosant performances. If named Bulgin, whose journalistic experiences prior to
.?
in that sense that he referred 'to. Mr. Balgin ax The funny part of this particular literary globe. Nagasaki Express, one occasion, Acting Suparintendent of Marquie Tsang has nedod in arriving at the statement was untrue, and the most convincing to bias were confined to police court report
trotiera efforia in, that the" Natos" ars the prodro
Is the editor of the Nagasaki Eising San an having been connected with a low alais paper Victoria Gaol, but we are not aware that Paris.
some madus vivendi with the French Cabinet in ing proof they could possibly have of the fasting for a low clues paner called the Clerkenweli News,
Our informant being a man of soare that Mr. Balgin was not sa otter Iailowe at the This genius after proving an uber failure oathe Chination of a supposed thoroughly sessons journalist, amateur journalist P--I believe ao; the probabiliaalted the Olerkenteell Nous, a paper which had
Mai, Buccessively trind Yokohama and Shanghai with
ohanged its name since he (defendant) laft Lon he proved a very signal sizes in that position and responsibility, we give the state time of bie former connection with the Ching
differ at results. He was thez erofibed with man of large and varied experience-h she asked ty is
Nater mind what the probabilities are; on to Mr. Baigin now wenta for the Chua Mail, position. History is silent as to his merita or
ment for what it may be worth, without in the Mait was the fact that Mr. Bain was as well venting a lot of twandle about China, which no boty potato hires jouzuslist whose ablo sompilation of the vegetable market report and graphic description beant de rep vonching for its aboarsey. Farthesatisfied with his performances that he was will. would publish; afterwards contributed a parael of of the big "tarunt" Krown in farmer Brown what do you bass this libellous, slanderous, and denidadly a low class paper-but that did not demerity. At all events he comes to us with. colour is given to the ramour from the fact that ing to re-engage him for another terar, und when shildish staff to a neal avering print ander the bago-gardou would command a Iterativa appointment inaniting atterance -I believe the editor of the make him a low clase individas!. The defend- ant red another extract from the paragraph a private talegram has been received from Tien- Mr. Bain wanted to go to England and had to get hacing "Not a Murtin, South Africa, anda paxisual i canrasser or trotter round Nagasaks Hiring Sun in an amateur journalist.
Apocalip." and final y distinguishyl himself by got with "copy?” on a high stars Sydney or Melbourne What are your reasons What is his name? complained us to the alleged failure of the plain- in the absence, of another more experienced in stating that a large detachment of Chinesen man to take. bis place ho scat for Mr. Balgin¦ ting a rabbishy description of "A Ginesu Fanoral paper. Can it be skat the talented" J. B." has been 'Fbelieve his name is Gribble; flat is the name tiff on the China Mail, and in Yokohama and soldiers at that port has been disbauded and agaio. The article said "This genius, after in Hongkong" pubifahsi in a third rats Landonating out the China Mail was for a walk, or is it of the aliter when I was in Japan, AGA Shanghel. This only alluded to Mr. Bulgin's
proving an atter fallarse was not ontent magazins. Mr. Bulgin is at present wielding the posible that the cue is shallow as the other and man, he might suitably largap, there is ordered back to their homes."
with "simpla fallara,” bat "alter failure "--" on scissors and paste brush for the Fish Wrapper during
Talns on what grounds you styletdim sau literaryincapacity which Mr. Franole bud himself engines that no casy going body of subsariosra will no imaginable excuse for placing him over The German steamer Marie, Captain Hohlman, the China Afail saucessively tried Shaghad and the temporary absence of Mr. Murray Bain, and be be amnsed with ench rabbish ss the production which teur journalist I know, something about him, wald he was justifled in dealing with. The to - an officer of tried and peoved ability, and one high arrive here fron Hamburg on Satur- Tokohana with equally indifferent results would be wine to confae himself as much as possible apponced in Saineday evening iume of what you to from what I heard in Japan I believe him to be the use of the scissors and paste brash, it showed
to the use of them wecessary adjtacta to journalistic Factionaly call the "Organ of the Yiazintarien”t an amstsar journalist. N
an absolute ignorance of the working of a news- suocess. We consider that our Nagasaki sortaspa who bas of several previous occasions day, is a new boat, this being her first massage that was, he was an attor failure there as well
From the referenss to the advertisement sanvas. Now tall me this, when you wrote this dis paper and of the literal meaning of the varb" to She is a vessel of 740 tons, and of a useful stas, as, here. Then the paragraph went où-” Jir rary romske su Admirat Willee an ill advised,
edit" to complain of this a libellous. All worthily actel Captain Dease's boum built te stem nide knots; The Hamburg-sor Balgia is at prosent-wielding the scissors and anfair, and eached in anything but tast impartial ser one would almost think this was from the you not mean it to apply to me-o
same hand as the paragraph ho bad road. This On your path P-No, but- cannot say at this papers, not in Hongkong only but everywhere, tolena. As we have said: befors, there is no respondent of the Londes and China Lopressposta rask for the Fish. Wrappor, during the spirit of independenes which la expeted at all times
hensible the conduct of the Editor of the Rising Sun had arrivo 1 in the solong. The terrasd manga! possibio excuse for the injustico about to bolurring to her, said she was zobu fast vessel. temporary absence of M. Marray Bala, and he bootstrap to boot, however opto-was published a couple of stage after Mr. Bolgitdate what was passing through my mind at the wars principally filled by the aid of the emissore
time I wrote the paragraph. Dy and paste brush. In the China Mail'in sine. and it would take hor a kong while to make the wont be wise to confine himself to the was of
may be, there certainly cannot be the luant Justifios
then briefly recapitulated what he considered Answer the question-I don't think you were out of ten "copier, nine tenths of the contents perpetrated. Chief Inspector HoRaroon has soye The Marie has, bowster, made fair thess necessary adjuncta of journalistic success" on for the nearing importinence of a shallow pated
were the points the jury had to consider. in my mind when I wrote that paragraph, I did were tiros contributed, and such was likewise the several times bera deemed fit to hold the ad. passage for a boat of her class, socsidering stop. (meaning thoroby that he the said James Bulgin poppy whose "sek in his strongest point.
paes, hav ny accomplished the run-in l days was unable to perform bis duties as altor of the it did asem a pity a gentleman se opmpetent to
The plaintiff was then called and said-I am ant intend it to apply to you that I am aware of with the Hongkong Telegraph or any other The defendant said the editor of the Nagasaki paper. The proper, duties of an editor wers to Sha taft. Hamburg on the 3rd May, an called at sail namepaper the China Mail, and to write lay down the rulas of trus and just esition the marees of the China Mail in Mr. Bain's Gibraltar. Fuat Said, Adsu, and Biz zapore, and feading or other articles for the plans thereof and to pensare others should himself fall into absence and the editor of that paper and of the Rising Sus was an elderly man who had been colinat news from all quarters of the world, pra during part of the voyage experienced stormy and was entirely dependant upon extracts from far worse mistakes. It Mr. Bulgin had had no Overland China Mail and the China Review. I long sonnested with journalism, and he asked sout it is a readable form, and to revise and cor weather and strong contrary winde. This per other papers to fill up the columns of the Chine oditorial experience Hr. Fraser-Smith might arrived in the colony about the end of March, the plaintiff for some reasonable ground for rest. Not an elitor of a single tendon paper of standing wrote his dwa articles, though a limit. fermanos compares very well with that of many Hail). It would be for the jury to asy whether her been justified in referring to that Pact in About two months prarions to my arrival and sling him an amateur journalist.
Plinti-It was from my impressions; Iostafrendered that nocasary here. It had not. lager steamys that have recently arrived. ---- or not the words complained of would be fairly riticising Mr. Bulgin's ratersuce to maturat tims ap to my arrival actos written by me
been the onstar on the Chiwawit until recently. understood, by say ons who rasd the jangnabats, but he had no right to base his grpeared in the China Mait. I road the latter have no great information about him.
Defendant-So in reality you know nothing to it was well known that Mr. Murray Bain diâ The fire alarm bells waru set pealing yesterday to impate that ignorance and ineficiency whiobariticism on faisahood. But whotbor the state in the Hongkong Telegraph of the 2nd or Sel by all classes of the public. Indeed, it foreseen, immediately after the Tower dook the plaintiff said they did. And then name & gate were true on false, was there any insti- April sigoed. Oorastalk. I bara co doubt about him-do you know that his name is Nor not write his own articles, but had thom entri in not too much way that for official track eleva, intimating a conflagration in the bit of pure personality, which could not be justi- cation for the coneindian words, which were whatever it refers to me. I have read the para- many impression was that it was the same batet outside the oflox There was nothing wrong
Eastern district, a fire having rokas uut la house
pass the editorial functions, as Mr. Francia appointments in Hongkong bare excited" No. 61, Wanelli Road. It appeared, on suguiry, fed in any repost. "There cannot be the simply personal abuse? To some extent the graph of the 7th May which you have roed. It gentleman who was editing the pager when I was in that, for leader writing did not solely com
alightest justification for the sneering im roraarke coumised in the paragraph might be fair afzo refers to me, identifying me by its ro. in Jan.
foreung to the author of the notas. J.ħam mad Delendast-He is thesame gentleman, and his sosmed to think. Tanagh he (defendant) con- more indignation than the placing of Captain that the ground for of the promises, which was
an old and frail Chinese tenement, was occupied by pertinence of a shallow pated puppy (meaning and legitimate ordlism if true, but he asked the DEMPETER Over Mr. HUBSPOOL's head. It is a retailer of keraine oil, and through an soilent borohy the plaintiff James Bulgin) whose jury to fled that they were far is erase the artiste of the 6th June. I am the Jane sme la Nortean; were you not wideg on some siderad he bad acted perfectly within his rights cheek is his strongest point." Was or was of say legitimata artician and were not pub. Bulgin referred to there.. I was never employed thing you knew nothing about wrote from in the way he bad criticised the scandalous, slanderous, and insulting aspersions in the China gratuitous insult to an old and tied official, the oil onaght fire, which almost directly assumed
portor for that journal. I first commenced You used the scissors, and paste in taking Mail, he admitted he might bare done it with for which it puzzles any one to find a slia-such conddarable proportions that the flames that not bulling a man up to ridienie and listed bond fide for the purpose of enlightsmier on the Clerkenwell News, nor Police Court re-impressions
barst through the roof within a few minutes, soutempt? If it was, it was defamatory the public wind, but as a matter of sbase of Mfr.
this extract from the Nagasaki, Rising Sun Pas mach effoot with less strong Janguage, and certainly with bester taste. He was realy, na dow of justification. If Mr. Hongroo had body of men from the finite stationed as Won and Litolious, Was there any inati alias Bulgin To show they were published mali- work in Doanaction with
Don't you think it is an offenes for you as never held the position before, he would, obal ware soon on the spot, and worked hard to for it whatever ? Did it enlighten the public cioarly he proposed to put in other articles prior left school, at abant 18 years of age. I left a Yee, I ent is from the Nagsenki Express.
in any way as to Mr. Bulin's ability to in date to this, in which Mr. Frase-Smith had boarding school at Cheltenham and joined the now that the post of Deputy Superintendent save the adjoining proraines, in which attempt sonduct a public paper or as to the opinions and tsokod and abused Mr. Bulsin poravnally staff of the Cheltenham Times to learn jouroa journalist to publish a garbled artesat
they succeeded, the fire bring omfland to the views to expressed in bis paper? It was sim without any such justification even as he prolist. I remained there about a year, engaged not aware. hine been abolished, have a right to expect house where it originated whilst the police of ly ous of those expedients hasty writers resort fossed to have here, and they would also have in in reportingus particular class of reporting.
You are the author of these moles on it how much more has be this right after. 2 Statins with the aid of the mannst engine to when they have not time, or, possibly, ability evidenes hofors them an article published the simply what I was capable of at the age of 18. tratasia, Africa, and Mauritius by James Bulgin,
Hikely be hurt his feelings or anything he con there, gut a complete mastery of the iss hasing proved himself ahla in sustain the before the Central Fire Station pagines arrived.
to work ap legitimate criticism and dessoud to following day which the defendant had girou On leaving that I joined Mr. W. G. Baxter's reprinted from the China MailP-Yes..
Are you acquainted with the editor of the sidered likely to injure him in his profession. partenal souse to support their position. The notine be intended to make use of as sa apology, oath of England newspapers. dignity, and discharge of the duties of the The next two houses on eithor side were, how ofculant danied that tis statements made.i] It was a very lengthy one. The Issraad oonasel gumber of these papers. The principal print. Shanghai Mercury?—I know ́s person named The reply to this offer was-/! No, blood and offica? In any case the selection of Captain vor, some hat damaged by water and the pall the paragraph were either written, printed, or then read the arst portion of the article in gasang establishment is at Lewis, I was there Mantarlane, who was, I believe, connected with thunder rar to the knifo." Mr. Baigie would not accept this apology though he had written about ing down of the woodwork. Both the Super- DEXTER is to be deprecated He came intendent of the Fire Brigade, Mr. Wadahvase, pablished falesty or maliciously, but if he tion, which quoted the passage from the Chinz for four and half years and for two years that peper.
Do yen know Mr. Rivinghia, of Bhanghai amateur journalists as being insan,contemptible, nit to fill a lucrate post on the garrison and his sistant, Mr. Carvallio, were suon on the stated what was as a matter of fast fales Mail and the caramente en it in the Telegraph that timo was anboditor of the Cong Merciery; do you think be le a person who and cowardis, hocates the paragraph, was too:
the following eraning, and went on to say that Chrouide and Mark Lane Esprom. Tast paper taff, and had neither claim nor right to spot. One man what injured by jumpy privileges he might have were gone.
As we therefore had at the Ioast Intention or ds. has less in all the county towns of eight likely to have any fealing against you I don't grossly personal, Mr. Fraser-Smith read his ing from the fint floor windes into the street, The defendant said, farthermora, that they
were legitimusta oriticisms and commenteiro to unfairly seail the professional reputation of counties. During the remainder of that time think be is likely to have any very friendly letter tendering the apology, the reply Lo Mr. employment in the Civil Serries so long his retroat by the staircase having been at ones
something Mr. Bulgin had eaid or Mr. Balgia, or to leave an erroneous impression on I was engaged in reporting-attending county feelings towards me, as I don't think I over Fraasis, and his own subsequent letter. Perhaps as there were competent officers in that cut off by the flames. He is being attended a dog. Me. Halgia had writton su article in the the mind of the public in regard to his journalistic meetings, and desriptive reporting. There was spoke to hira in my life. I don't think he knows it was true, in strict justice, that he ought to have sscertained whether, bis statements were true be the Tug Wah Horpital
vors lille Police Court reporting among it. I anything about raad en article which to fore he made them, and not trusted to his memory. Dervice to till the vacancies. I the
China Mail which was a logitimate subject of are, we at pude on zuesiring an intimation that wo had heen guilty of pubishing what was ansarted to
loft there to take the editorship and manage. Defendiat-I oriticism. The plaintiff admitted that as a bas libel, expressed our resinoes to wake all tha Government had any reason to doubt
public writer be was open in respect of his atonement in sur power by correcting in our fat is ment of the Fossendale Neuss, published in Labas written concorsing you in the Shanghai Still he wrote without no lots of malies, for le the ability or suspect the integrity of
writings to any fair and legitimate oriolara, sou our uzstate monta and errare, and in foot, sin. nashire. I remained there for a year and Mercury. The defendant then read an article never had anything to do with Mr. Bulgin Mr. HOBSPOOL, which they certainly had
that he was open to ridicule if he exposed him. ply offered, as the gentleman aridently considerad he left to Sain the staff of the Daily Chreticle headed Balgin himself again" which reoeuty beyond exchanging a few of the owlinary cour
had been injured, to make the amande honorable. self to ridioul, that he was open to be held up
ab-editor and descriptive raporter. At the appeared in that paper, dealing with Mr. Bul-tasies of life with him, and when it was lo not, then in Mr. J P. McEuns they
pablu centempt it he did in his editorial on Now he would read the lottare. Mr. Fraser-present time the Clerkenwell News has bomo agia's congestion with the Courier, his notestimated that he had gone further than the ot had a man who has not only acquired ox-
pacity anything worthy of public contempt, and Smith, ou receiving the sammans, wrote to him London daily paper equal to any in London in oa Austraissis, Afrias, and Mauritius, & in oumstances demanded, be cured to be published. perience as Deputy Superintendent of the
eiroulation with the exception of the Times. It very uncomplimentary manner. He then asked in a prominant part of the papera leading article when a man bad so exposed himself either (Mr. Francis)- court bors jury would be sakod to dew any My dear Mr. Francés, have inet received has changed its name, but I cannot say whether the plaintiff whether he couddered that was containing one of the simplest apologias it wa
A
possible to give for having been Int inte stru Hongkong Police Force, but bas, after Mr.
very fue ao as to whether there might or summons with year aame attached, for a libel on it was under Dow maasgement. All I can say is fair report on his work
Mr. James Dulgin, which appeared in last nighte
memoria. His would have withdrawn anything Plaintiff It is a malicious description. that it ln as respectable a paper on I was evər HORAPOOL, a good claim to receive the ap
might not be in the criticism seznothing of er- Telegraph. The following is the paragraph com.
connected with,
Defendant-It mean that a good many people which might have been considered injurious had the apology been socpled, and he pablished the pointment. The principle of giving Acting M. de Lesseps bat made speech to the effect dos. Bet the orifioista to which a man was plained of
exposed zanet bo what was called legitimsta
have been malicious to you. EL MARA
Thie concluded the cross-examination, and apology is a duty to himself, kis clients and the appointments to outsiders de cauentially that a complete andersandfug exists between theoriticism, and the only gnostion in this base was On perusing fun above I must admit that it is into speak of its contemporaries in an abasiyo
Mr. Francis intimated that that was his case public. With regard to the status of nawspapers, Ticides one is petice, as it naturally dis-English Cabinet and the Sces Canal Company, whether the defendant had or bat pot exceeded very questionable taste and ought not to bare basn
The defendant than addressed the court in a Me. Bulgin had thewa strange ignorance in courages the subordinate oficials. This was which he said, was motivaty progressing in the the oude of ordinars, cossumble, legitimate published. lese express y regret to Mr. Balgia that anything so persually offensive shogid kärs driticism, or whether he had not taken cocasion appeared in my paper; and if you will be good mark
speech of sonsiderable length. At the outset ha stating that the eirculation of the Daily Chro expressed regret that the time of the jury should mile was now equal to way in Londen but the be taken up with frivolous and paltry a casa;Times, for it was well known that the Standari, ho did not think in the whole course of his life Telegraph, and Dady Nows had six times the he had seen such a case brought into court. eircolation of that paper. He was, willing to His LordshipAre you going te giedsvidence? Believe Mr. Balgia when he said he had not been The defendent said, he was going to give ori a failure at Shanghai and in Japan, though he akang bad certainly good reason for beliering other denes on several points
Addressing the jury, the defendant went on wins, and the editor of the Shanghai. Mercury to say that there were some peculiarities in this believed so too. These reasons were stronger. Als.Lordship thought it was not necessary to ones." It was one of the very low cases which had than Mr. Balgin's unsupported orth. He re- evor appeared in court in which one editor had collected that in si setion at Shanghai Mr. go into that matter.
Mr. Francis said his ollent was in this post-come into court to sue for damages against the Preston downribad Mr. Enigla as a reporter.. tion; be wanted some of this to go before the editor of another paper for libel The editor of though he was tie the less a resposta lo public to ande some of the harm that this sense a newspaper had a far better respon for his own journalist for that, and police scurt reporting ass article of the defendant's was Hikely to do protection in his paper than any damages a dourt was a perfectly honenrable and legitianfs brunch He should like to put Mr. Bulgin in a strong a could give him area under the Libel Act. If of journalism. It was nothing menisk or low se position as posible in the opinion of the public, thers was anything in the paragraph which Mr. Fransis had endeavoured to load them to His Lordship thought that had been done als formed the Losis of this-sation, or anything suppos. Nothing could have been fairer than which pressed hardly on Mr. Bulgin in the way his offer to give the truth wide publicity if he The examination was continued, and in an of sitiolaty, de had in this paper an organ Bilby Iwan mulakukan, "but the plaintiff declined to
out experience of Police datis, and though,
ting appointment when there was no extra emolument to be reapod, and he most fully justided the confidence show in him by the efficient and entisfactory manner in. which be cufed the Police. He is respect od, alike by the members of the Force and
one of the many bad features of Sir Jos POPE HENNESSY's régime, and we bad fre quent occasion te donounce it. We had fond." ly hoped the days of jobbery in connection with official appointments were over in this Colony, that deserving-oficers would to fu- ture be allowed to enter into what they may legitimately consider the heritage of their labours. Is it too late to rectify the mis.. take in the Police Department ? It would be a graceful act of defersnes to public opinion if His Excellency were to amend bis velection at the last moment and do an act of simple justice to an pld servant of the Colony,
LATEST TELEGRAMS.
REUTER'S TELEGRAMS. SUPPLIED TO THE " DAILY PREEK." FPIR BASTERN RITEFUOR, AUSTRALASIA, AND CRIVA TELEHKAH CO.'S LINE,]
Losnow, 23rd June, 1863, THE NEW SUEZ CANAL.
preparatory work of making a sosend Canal.
SUPREME COURT.
25th June, SUMMARY JURISDICTION. BEFORE ME. Josrtos RomELL, AND ́A SPECIAL JURE.
on
+
could be neod.
papers
when I
There are
Mr. Francis-Was it the habit of that paper
mauner.
Witness No. :"
Did it pander to the lowest passions of the people in its writings I never saw sa article of personal abans in the paper of any kind. I was on the paper for two years within a month, and I left to go-to the China Mail, When I left I received a testimonial and a pre- sentation N
Nor were its Polias Court reports published in of the writing of an article professing to criticise to point och eko iovevdrugies and offensive porhens of the phraseologs of the ring or the gambling an article written by Mr. Bulgin to make a pri- the paragraph I shall be gind to make the aerie Laisons No. vate, parsons), and utterly useless and unnecessary norable in our next issue. Yours very troly
E. FREE-SMITH, Editor. attack upon Mr. Balgio's «barnater? That was what they charged him with that was the gist The answer that was sent to that was- of his ollazos. The only way to deal with that your Mr. Freser-Smith,-I have shown your question was to go through the whole of the a letter to Mr. Daigin. Ha declinus to scorpi any tole from which the extracts complained of were apology. The attack is no grare too personal
nus oh You must remember, too, that taken. It was not a long article and he would it is only the last of 189. MẸ Ban bảo v reak it, pousing here and there to point out whet | interestin to give you. It was for you to havs esatuado kim to be legitimate orificium and adorning the vorreolness of your statements tofore what not. It would seen that Admiral Willas, published them-Very faithfully you,
INO, L. FRITOIN, for reasons best known to himself and into T.hich they need not inquire, had not taken the That was the pith of their complaint that Mr. fret to Nagasaki this year, and that the editor Fraser-Smith published statements not knowing Mr. Franels said this was an sotion brought ofthe Biring Sun and Nagasalet Express criticised whether they were ten or falsosisply reck. by Mr. James Butulo, the editor sad mareger, to rather roughly the aption of the Admital. The Isssly and his offer to publish ocrrections was Mr. George Murray Boln's abanon, of the China Chand Mail, in a paragraph for which Hr. no umede. The learned counsel ountized to Mail, and the defendant was Mr. Robert Fraser Bulgi was responsible, orificed the oritiniam road the article in the Talsgraph, and with re- | ready, Smith, the proprietor, editor, and publisher of of the Nagasaki Express, and thoarticle of which faroon to the following pasenjem
BULGIN Y FRAUER-SMITE, $1,000. He. Francis appeared for the plaintif Tho defendant conducted his own case...
The forors were Messy G. E. Lammert, Arnold, and 0, J. Hirst
soon as his sttention was called to the article, to
a
admit that some parts wers in very bad taste.
and that it would have been better to have left
us
out other parts altogethme. Ha toadured his
Irant apology to Mr. Balgia for anything