WEDNESDAY, FEBUARY 5, 1890.
"Me Frannie" ta "k" long speech referred to the excellent mark done by Dr Cantlle in the colony, and presented him with the fol- lowing addrein→→
On behalf of the Community we beg to offer to you our sincerest wishes for your speedy ristoration to health and strength, and a continuar career of public usefulness.
The Residents of the Colony of Hongkong, In acknowledgment of many valuable services rendered to the Community, And
• In recognition of bis labors in the interests
of Lealth and medical science, his energy, publia spirit, and worth, This Salver, Tos and Coffee Service are
presented.
⚫
The following is the address from the Court, Bosate, Licentiates and Students of Court, Bonate, Licentiates and Students of the College of Medicine for Chiness, and
SUPREME COURT.
THE CHINA MAIL.
IN APPELLATE JURISDICTION. (Before the Full Court) Wednesday, Feb. B.
Caso
THE CONTEMPT OF COURT APPEAL.
of fact.
did.
as
the
*
AL
wa from
Court.
at
il
Mr Francie Your Lordships can under stand how difficult is for a Chinesan. stand how difficult is for He is so thoroughly ashamed of losing face and all that, and in the heat and face and all the, and in the Beat excitement of the moment be was in a facit and all that,
temper
was
expressed
M:
the
of the Court to the Prison Ordiacuas ja order that his client might be dealt with as a first-class mademcanent,
The Court refused to go into the matter,
cut the Magistrate's decision. saying the prison authorities would carry
valet
VIBITORS AT HOTELS.
boarno
Moore
Mr
HONGKONⱭ KOTEL,
Ferry.
Me A. Marangonis Cal. and Mrs Santa
Marin
Mr L. Marte! Mr J. H. Martin Rev. and Mrs Masoo
Mr & Mrs E. McCabe
Mr J. McNair
秀
Mr D. Soutar
Mr and Mrs J, P..
Thoman
Mr R. L. Thoman
Miss Tippings and
mnid
Me H. E. Tomkins Mr W. B. Walker Capt. J. Wacrack Mr W. B. Walker
Capt. Spencer Wilde
Miss Wylay and gaver.
Oommander and Mrs
Wylay
ness
Mr T. Yatsoi
PHAK HOTEL.
Me H. Haboeck
Mr B. P. Sheldon
Mei.Miss
Mr E. V. Hampden Mr Ed. Jaulmer Me O
Langberg Mra Lehmann Mr P, W. R. Many
Mr W. Niamann
Mr B. Oblasn
Mr Stewart
Mrs J. E. Stewart Miss. Vordon Mr G. R. Wheeler
Miss Woolrich
Exchange.
Borakona, February 3, 1806.
On Laudon-
Haut, Who,
1
11 ***
On detasad, 30 days' sight,
***
F
H. + 21
you" deo octuide the Cort, you must not Mr Freudia-And should not have affact-Long for a long time, comes out with the use them inside the Court if the Magistrate ed the sentence which he got far the of-expression Godem con of a b the population is ster changing, but the
fence. in citting.
apparently intending that expression for memory of you and your good deeds in con-
The Chief Justice-The case was adjourn the witness Stanton. That la the case, no fr W. G. Allan nection with the College and Hospitals will
Mr Frausis-Certainly ust; Uut the Ms.
Me Arnold be green for many years to come, and if
gimrate in an Bugliah Court, has us inhered for two days, and the man having had doubt, because Stanton had given orid Mr H. W. Andrews
planty of time to think over the matter ence, which bad the effect of oon-Dr W. F. Arnold these institutions continue to flourish, an
snt power to punish
plant to go to the Magistrate and apo victing
Now, the Laxrne Brion C. Balbas There is
The Chief Justice-That is trup. Innd time to go to the Magistrate and apo victing his friend. TO JAMES CANTILE, R., M.A., M.B., here in every reason to saticipate they will da, it will always be remembered that In
England a Magistrato cannot sentence alugins humbly, ablaks to his own trumped counsel for the appellaut, who has urged sties J. l'albas F.B.C.B.
that he up tale about McEwan, and instructs his everything that could be urged on behalf Mir L. Barindoague. Sir,--We, the undersigned residents in no small tueasure is their success dus to
Cheung Teung Fat, Secretary to the man to impressment for contempt, hat heup tale shout McEwan, and instructs his everythi
with a man by hinding him over or solicitor to raise that detenes! Don't you of his client, is very straightforward, Mr H. Berkus Bekkey 74. You are indeed a son of whom your
Baby express, Your the Colony of Hongkong, desire to expalma mater, Aberdeen University may well Man On Insurance Co., appealed against expelling him-ordering him to be removed think, if you had been upon the Beach, and in the manner I should have expert Baron Bahns
Mr & Mrs C. Mooney apon the sre of your departure from the
can ang the sentenos of seven days impriachment to
from the Court. But we are dealing bere you would have taken that into considera-ed from him admitted that his client dide, W. Boles steps to passed upon himate, for using certain has powers here, where to discuss theea putished bim for his originst adu Colony, our deep asuse of the valuable be proud, and I trust that before lang
aid that his alisut did Mr and Mrs A. thet University will
will take steps
lut did Mr and Mrs. H. and family pure,
Mr Francis-With my Lot temper, I allege that the police trumped up the dade
my Lot temper, I use the expression and that his olleet aid Mr J, W, Bolles Is alisut did mervices which you have rendered to the t
Bottenbcion
Mr J. Murokia But to shield McEwan, and he very. Frankly Mr W. Brooker
Mr Nigg Community during a sojourn amongst us of tingly recognise your services. We wish passed upon him by Mr T. Sarcombe from the Coart. But we are dealing bere vouk, if you had been upon the Beach, and
you and Mrs Canille every prosperity. For indecent expressions, in the Magistralo's land. We are not here to diecass the canuut asy what I would have done. yoo and Mrs Camilia evory prosperity. For Bath, Police Magistrate, for using cartsin with a specilla Ordinanas., The Magistrate ion.
a can wishs nothing better than Court, in presence of the Magistrate so se policy of the Act but to administer it. I would have pubished him for his original admits that that charge was false and that Vice-Admiral and MreMr J. W. L. Oliver Dearly nine years.
During that peried your name has been your sons we can with nothing better than indecent expressions, In the Magistrato's has powers here, which he has not in Eng
Mr Francis--No; but the policy of the offence and not for what transpired after he did use the expression. Under these
A. Buller, maid and Capt. and Mrs Palmer
Me W. Partith very in the Colany wbleb the spirit to oyisiity of your disposition and varsatile Acting Attorney Grown Solicitor, appeare very prominently identitled with many under that they pries worthy sons of a worthy to constitute contempt of court.
Mr J. J. Francis, Q0., instructed by father. We envy the land which is to an
Act points at anything likely to lower the warde. What he did two days afterwards circumstances, all the learned counsel could takings in the Colony wbleb required the foy the charm of your personality and the Mr E. C. Ellie, appeared in support
joy the charm of your personality and the Mr E. C. Ellie, appeared in support of the dignity of the Court or to interfere with ought not to be considered part of ths of do was to argue that the words in the Master Edward BullerMr L. Parito
. a cost B. E. Follock, display of much any whleb regairad the father, Was worthy some of a worthy Court, in presos, In the Magistrato's has powers here. The Magistrata o would have taken that die Besch, and display of much energy and publia spirit to Leolality of your disposition, and we feel application, and the Hon. C. Foliar the administration of justice. I quite non-tence. I do not think it can be fairly said that presence of the Magistrato must mean Me and Mrs J. CairnsMr E. Pasquet
your disposition, and we feel 31. G. Act points at anything likely to lowor carry them through, and on every occasion, are that the varied abilities and versatile Acting Attorney General, instructed by Mr ends there are many things which at first the inan was guilty of insulting the Court in the houring of the Magiatesto, ale W. J. Cantor Major and Mrs Pem. you have shown yearself foremost is there
the administration of justice. I quite non-tence. I do not think it can be fairly said that pres gifts which have excited our admiration 4. B. Jolinson, Crown Solicitor, appeared sight do not appear to interfere with the or that he had suy intention of reflecting so that the Magistrate might deal Capt. and Mra H. K. bortai work of enlightenment and progress,
Mr & Mrs V. Perkom and affections here will gain for you in the on behalf of Inspector Mowan, who was adicinistration of justice but which ought upon the Magistrate or jaatize or the doci with the man from big own knowledge,
Carey Your labours, assets that which you already Your letours as a member of the Sanitary
Mr Engine Chonselor Br 2 E. Peters Board, and in the interests of health and old country a still greater reputation this made the respondent,
country a still greater reputation this on behalf of Inspector McEwan, who was right do not appear to interfere with the inan was guilty of insulting the Cronet presence of the Magistrate must mean Master Edward Bullerbr L. Past
The Court was traded to excess, chiefly to he and very properly would be punished; siva. That ho did not dream that his ro-there and then, summarily, without calling M
but in this case the expressions were not marke or anything he said about In for the production of any evidence at all. Mr F. B. Dancus but in this case the expressions were not nirke
Barg-Ool. Presion Mr A. H. Reunio zedfsal sclaves, have entitled you to the that which you already possessed there. medical
nght used with reference to the Magistrate, not spector Stanton could construed I cannot agree with that. It does not fol. Me W. A. Daff by Chinese of the wall-to-do dlan. heartfelt thanks of the Community, while the
ause a Magistrate may the bring Mr Francis paid-This appeal
Me T. F: Richardin law Odd
come to his cats, not said so far as the evid. was only expressing his towards the Magistrate, not said an as to as conterapt of Court, and that he in because a Magistrate may be somewhat Me J. B. Duncan
Mr C. Roghe College of Medicins for, Chinese, the Odd
it come to his eats, not said so far as the evid-was only expressing his own ill-will, anger, deaf persons in the Court may use all sorts Mr T. J. Eldridge
Rev. and Mrs G. T. Volitmes Soulety, and the Hongkong Public
under the provisions of the Magistrates' towards the Magistrate, not neid on as to as conteript of Court, and that he from the Clinipal Staff of the Alles Mamo-Ordinance, Seotions 90 and 110, and it ones goes except to come to the eare of the and did not intend it to be heard by of insulting expressions and turn the Court Mr G. Fanwick
14thence Library are monuments alike of your gene
come
Slado originates in this way. On the 14th ence rial and Nethersole Hospitals :-
present in two persons who were almost within touch- McEwan or anybody else in the Court. into a sort of pandemonium because the Miss Victoria Fer rosity and your energy.
ing distance of the speaker, not heard and There is no evidence that he had malice in Magistrate is not vory acute of hearing: Mr H. K. C. Fisher MiesH. P. Blads January last, the appellant was present in two persons who were almost within touch- McEwan Hongkong, 5th Feb., 1896.
Mr. J. T. Smits the Police Court during the boaring of a vidently not intended to be heard by the his mind or any intention to commit an and, therefore, I am not inclined to hold that Mr A. Fuchs To JAMES CANTLIE, Esq., M., B. Caso in which he was not directly con generality of the peopls in Court, and, offence.
in the presence of the Magsatrate means Mr Greenfield
Miss Sraith Mr Justice Wieso has been brought 20gthing other than what it is, or that it is Capt. T. Hall cerned. He had gone up there as the murality ont calcalated in the least do- ..., 4., &., 20., Dean of the d
ught Mr A. Fuchs good Oollege..
iend of a person summoned to aeswor a therefore, not calcalated in
synonymous with the words in the hearing Major & Mrs Hankamies Summers Dear Sir,-You have been connected"
regres
The Chief Justice-I suppose he has no of the blagistrale. I cannot help thinking Mr O. Harris with the Alice Memorial Hospital and with charge of keeping fales acales or measures, grea to bring into contempt the Magistrate up in Hongkong. with the Alice Memorial Hospital and with charge of a desestrate was sitting apariance of what would have happened to that the use of such expressions in such Me Max. Heymann The following Inscription will appear on the College of Medicine for Chiness during defendant
the College of Medicine for Chiness during After the case bad been concluded and then the Magistrate's decision or the Court
Me Francis, a quoted fruts Bloxatone; bim in his own country if he had made now an audible toon that it could be heard Mr. J. 3. Host the Silver plate
the whole period of your residence in Honghad, hoand his friend were leaving the submitted that no offers was amml of the same expression. the whole period of your residence in Hong defendant in the case bad been ined and which the Magistrate was sitting
oy the Ispector of Police and the con- Mr T. Howard It Huic Me Francis-Ho could not have been atale is a gross insult to the Court. Mr A. N. Huke Pada To
keng, sad with the Nutheraola Bospitspanishad, JANES CARTER, Eqre, M.A., M.B.,
since the date of the earliest proposate for Court; and while leaving it was stated that and submitted that no offenes was comml of the same expression
punished more severely in this instance is not intended to apply personably to the Mr G. L. Hummel F.L.O.S., to.
its erection. You are now about to leave they were heard to make use of certain exted unless the expressions came within the its erection. You are now about to leave creations, by two polies constables sitting The Chief Justica la recen years there than if bo had taken off his shoe and flang Magistrate; that I admit, but it is a gross Capt. and Mrs Hunt From
the Colony and settle in England, and wopressions,
personal cognisance of the Magistrate. close to the door.
insult to use Mr A. Inhoff it at the Magistrate.
Mr A. Linhoff were some judges in Eugland who were cannot permit you to go from among us The Chief Justice-They or be?
Mr Justica Wine-Oh, yes; assault; six witness, who was there in the discharge of Mr Morton Jones Mr. D. Webster derf; you do not mean to say that a man Mr Francis--The appollant; I beg your
(laughter). cone allowed t
his duly. Under all the circumstances Mr L Kaizer. using expressions months (laugh wi-Oh, yes; assault; six witness, who such an expression to a and bars Hunt without placing on record and publicly acknowledging (however reluctant you may
Mr Ferocis-I am speaking with roof the case, therefore, it seems that Mr J. Kinghorn be to receive auch acknowledgment) the reported to the Magistrate, and the appel. You want us to find that in the presence forence to the contempt.He again sub the charge was made sus hofors the Mr G. Littor bo to receive such acknowledgment) the Fardon, The expression was afterwards could be allowed to go on using expressions months (se-Oh, yes; assault; six witness, who was there in the con eminent services you have rendered to the
which keep the Court convulsed in laughter. lent brong lint bronght be. You want us Bospitals and to the College during the nt was, at a subsequent date, Section of the Magistrata must mean in the mitted no insult was intended to the Court, Magictrate fully, that the expressions were Mr H. W. Looker
fore the Court and charged noder
action fo
To call a witnose and spoke at some length of the appellant's used, and that the defence sat up wa Miss E. Loyzagara 10 of the Police Magistrate's Ordinance be such an insulting name and to vas such willingness to withdraw the charge against an aggravation of the original Mr M. Mantegata Past nine years.
An Surgeon and Clinical Teacher, as 10 of the Police Magistrate's Ordinance hearing of the Court. To call a witnose and on no incult was intended to the Court, Magictrate fully, that the expressions the Mr G. Litton Lectoree on Surgery and Abatory, as Se with having behaved in an insulting man by sach an insulting name and to vas such willingness to withdra
or au constable and doing; and although he may have been hurried into making that defence-setting Hongkong, "áth- February, 1880
erotary, and afterwards as Dean, of the Cal-ter and used insulting or threatening an insulting expression in open Court so as Inspector McEwan and the core gainet an aggravation of the original wrong. Mine . Loyzagara
Mr Justice WiseWhy has he not done soup that false charge-by s cortaia impulso
Major the Hon. and was of somebody 1
before; he does it now only when he is on to shioid himself, I cannot forget that the Mrs J. Anderson The Hon. J. H. Stewart Lockhart said—lege, you have been at all times and under language in the presence of the Court. Hot be board by an Inspector and another to apologies all round.
Mr Francis-Anything leading to insuls the verge of gaul?:
depositions disclose that some evidence in Mr and Mrs A. Chap- Mrs E. Neel Bad
man and S obilaren ebild Me Chairman, ladics and gentlemen, in all circumstances the life and soul of the ad sentenced to even days' imprisonment covetablo-does not that tend to contemat a witness le, in the general law of England,
the case was taken on the 14th January virtue of my offies as Rectorof the College College and of the Hospitals. Thounds in respect of this offence. Notice of ap- of somebody 1
considered to be interferencs with justice,
the eridance of MeEwan swearing to all Mias Coa Ewan swearing to all Miss Ope of Medicine for Chinesa and as Chairman of sick have benefited by your patianos, peal was immediately given on the question attention, and professional skill, and have
The Chief Justice-This is an appeat both considered to be interferenes with justice, and, therefore, contempt of Court; bat
this, the evidence of the other constable who Mr W. S. Harrison Mr F. H. Slaghek of the Finance Committee of the Alice Megane to their homes praising pea and bless on fact and on law.
Mr and Mrs Findlay Mr Harvey this is a special section, and it does zut say
tere out the truth of it, and both witnesses morial and Nathersole Hospitals, the vary
Mr Justics Wise I have not received this is a special section, and it does zur say
waro anything about witnessca of Magistratus
w470 eros-xamined. And yet alikough Mr and Mrs Geo. Smith and family
Holmes
Miss Smith pissing duty has been entrusted to me of ing you. Every student in the College bas on fact and on law.
the Magistrate did not act hastily but ad- reqasating Dr Canilie to accept an address felt the influence of your enthesisatio love
Mr Justice Wiso-Bat that does not no- journed the case for further hearing, for two Me Andrew Johnson Rec. and Mrs (), W,
nato, the end of these two days, having The Chief Justico-Insulting expression
hing Mr F. C. McCallum Sprigza from the Court, Senate, Licentiates and for your profession, and hen buon aided and any copy of the appeal. On a question of anything stout witnessca of Magistratus from the Court, Senala, Licentiates and with copies.
encouraged to pursue
aye, at Students of the College of Medicine for oncouraged to pursue his studies and over. fant, both judges should have been furnish-It says oriy-
Me Francie Bath abould have been to the Magistrale concerning the Magistrate count for all these days. Chinese, and from the Clinical Btaff of the of the warm personal interest you too farnished.
Mr Francis-But he had actually com. had plenty of time to think it all over, Mr Hugh McCallam Mr A. G. Stokon Chinese, and from the Clinical Staff of the come the dificulties that beast bios, beesmased with copies.
or in the pretence of the Magistrats.
Rev. and Mr G. & Alice Memorial and Nethorsole Hospitals. in him and sour readiness to come la his
Mr Justice Wise What was he doing milted himself to this transaction at the instead of apologising to the Magistrats Mr. A. D. Mel. Miss Torner Mr Justice Wiss-All 1 have in the case
moment when he bad, in temper, brought and throwing himself upon the mercy of
E. Vellinge There are in this Colony members of the esxistance. Your fellow Lecturers in the stated by the Magistrate.
there at all
was this faise ohrafice-Bo charge and instructs his l
Mr David Wood mil admirari ghoul, who think that Collaro have been oncourged and incited Mr Francis When the case esme to be Mr Francis-His own explanation was this false charge against McEwan."
The Chief Justice-Ho did not consider got a lighter sentence, the appollant 16-1 W. Nicholson dresses in Hongkong to departing residents to further surts in the performance of considered later on, although it was a that the actual masters
The Chief Justice--He did not consider the Court, in which cure he might save Major and Mra G. E that the actual master of the shop was
whom are becoming too frequent, but I am car what st times has seemed a hopeless task by aired question of fact and law dificult to sway and the appellant
pallant had been requcated atro certo of
to raise the defence that it was an entirely
WINDSOR HOTEL. tain there is not a resident in this Colony,
uffence, with ecooooting the charge; nor tramped up thing, that it was invented by Jolony, pests this charge and instructs his solintor Jr whatever may be bis astionality sue what your energy and zeal in the outs of medi.mized question of fact and law dificult to away and the appellant had been requested the face of police contable Molwan who got a lighter sentenes, the appollant re- ever may be hie views on the subject of cal education and by your hopefulness of separate, it was found to be advisable, on 10 give a general look after the business he had charged with a most atrocious peats this charge and Instrusts his solicitor dr W. Nicholson
godown keeper received this summons for for the face of the constable whom he the police to shield themselves. This is a te
Mr Anderson
Mr O. Mouiler addrease, who will not agree that in the ultimate success, the Bensts and the behalf of the appellant, to appeal on during his friend's absence, and when the uffence, with ecnoosting the charge
Mr Justice Wise-Are you going on having false woights or sales, ho re-charges with conspiring but while he gross aggravation of the offence. 1 de note D. B. Adamson Mrs Matilaan
M. present instance it would have been Court have profited greatly in the menage question of law aler.
ported it to his master's friend and he goes to Inapsator Stanton and says that he think the sentence of seven days' impri- Mrs S. 11. Bradbury Me F. 8. Montieth present instance it would havement of the offsite of the College by your both
is perry he used the expression regreis
Miss Bradbury Oaps. N. Nielsen most Augrant example of base in
Mr Francia--I do not intend to press the appellant want up with him.
a raund and says heat all excessive. I therefore dismiss the Miss Bradbur
Miss L. Bradbury grationds if Dr Cantia had been al-experience and advice; and your efforts both?
So
He never used it and charges the police with appeal
Mr L. Bradbury loved although he himself might have stir up a wider interest among the mem,
Mr Justice Wise-1 concar. I think desired it to leave this colony without bers of the community and of the Governmotion for leave to appeal on the question The Chief Justice-He went as a friend having done so he turus called and textes sonment, ander these circumstances, was Mrs S. 11. Bradbury Me F. 8. Montieth
insult was a most gratuitous one. some recognition of the great services he has ment in the work undertaken by the Cal- of fast, because I am bound to say that on and supporter of the false scales man. He never used it and charges the
The Chief Justics thought the costs of rendered to the College and the Hospitals. lego, ond to obtain for the College public this weight of evidence the Magistrato could expressed his indignation against the Lo-conspiring, and where would have been the rendered to the College and the Hospitals. fast that the appellant had made tas of not t
the appeal must be paid within a week after In the base of the College of Medicine for recognition and support, have simply been net one to any other soudasion as to the specter proburing a conviction. He had fece of Tuspector Stanton, McEwen and there
for invaluable. That the College of Medicine Fact that the appellant had made use of not the excuse even of something having the other man al: to save his on The Chet. Bartos auto
hs: pened to himself to cause him to lose 'face.
Mr Fraucis-All that la trus; I cannot Chinese, it was in great measure dus to him
been ad- The Chisi Jastice.On the appeal on fact his romper,
Mr Francis wished to call the atraction that it was founded, and ever since it 20m the perind of struggle and difavaragement the only ques ion for us to decide is Mr Francia-Although o that it was founded, and ever since it com- for Chinens has parsed successfully through certain axpressions in the Court.
onced its work of training Chinese in
The Chief Justice (after conferring with medical science, there has been no more incident to all new institutions and now the only question for us to decide is Mr Francis-Although I was under the offord any justification. It has not taxation.
whether ense mitted and apologised for.
distinguish the prezent der
section Mr Justice Wine)-But I must say that I ardent supporter of it in every way, gives promise of great future usefulares la bather there no suficient evidence for impression when I first studied this
from the class of cases covered by section Mr Justice Wise)-But I must say that I As features in surgery and anatomy ho has mainly due to your untiring exertions on the Lingistrate to come to the conclusion he that I might distinguish the prezent As leotarer in surgery and anatomy he has its behalf during the leat nine years,
Mr Francis-I think there is also a quen-00 and might be able to persuade your do not think it is at all illegal, when devoted much time and attention to the We deeply regret that you are leaving
do you should award a man, to consider the tion of fact beyond that. There was Lordships not that the expression was not you are considering what punishment training of Chinese in these subjects, for the Colony in indifferent health and at an abundant evidence to justify the Magistrate offensive,
natura of the defends he sets up. Suppose his skill in which bo joelly enjoys eo great prob
repatation in his own profession. As earlier date than you had originally pro- abundant evidence to justify the Magistrate Elonaive, because I do not intend
The Chief Justice Do I understand that the defence be set up wan-be admitted he
THE ORIGIN OF THE JAPANESE. LOL, Le bas desa untiring in bla excond reach Europe you will he perfectly rated fact which the Magistrate in his capacity as the appellant admits to his conueni that he gretted the ass of the words and threw Da, La bas basa untiring in his ezeritons posed. We hope that long befors you in concluding that the appellant mide are such a thing, bat to advance the welfare of the College, and of the expressions, but there is another
Dr M. Chr., Kolahikawa, Kamilemisha, judge and jury has to consider, that is made one of the expression, and that he himself upon the mercy of the Court, that Irorsase the aphons of lis usefulness. It is and restored, and that you will be able to
@aphors of its het
whether he misbehaved himself towards vareservedly withdraws the charge made would are justised the Court in taking Tokio, writes as follows to the Japan Muit
have taking i
a chiefly due to hie efforts that Me Belline rooms the profive of your profession in judge and jury has to consider, that is the appellant admits to his canussi that he was a man of bad temper and that he re-
the Court or used threatening or Icsulting by him against the Police
very lenient view; bat the defence he sets on this interesting subject - has come forward with an offer which in England with every prospect of sucdem.
We thank you moes beartily for all your the Court or used threatening or Icsulting We thank you most beartily for a
Mr Francis-Certainly.
up, after two days consideration, was that
With the greatest interest I have perused quivalent to grant of 840,000 in aid Hospi-language to
Mr Justice Wise-It was in the pressuce
Mr Justice Wise-I should like to scrap after two days consideration, was that
the date was tramped up, and therefore al the contribution in your last istus on the of the College, the condition of the grant rvices to the Collego and to the Bospie language to the Court
himselt of sourse I know you leges that these constables have perjured as that truth finds at fast its way. It origin of the Japaness, and I am delighted of the Gouft. balog that the Cloverom similar amount and to help in belog that the Covetement will outstribute tals, and we hope that you will still conti
him say so ero la slect the point have your instructions. fnstructions to say what he sagala rrect, these dotem with fourney throud the book of John Campbell, Da Bombay Mr Francis-There
themselves. tones then lumceived. There is no middle course. It was even before I came to Japan, on my by way of endowisomest thego and to the Kospi langage by way of endowment & similar amount ue to take an interest in their progress
Me Francis-I bave databine com was re-and towards the College. It is much to be re- and to help in their advancement by every
that he admits baying made use of the ex-mitted perjury. He charges them with fourney through Canada, that I was happy gretted a Dr Cantlie is abou: to leave at means in your power. We bid you Fare whether it was in the presence of the
Chief Justice-The words of this pression and will spoleglas te Inspector that by his defence. It la gaite right and Professor in the Presbyterian College, Mon time when his persuasive hud Busnt elos vall, and we wish you and Mrs Cantile Court,
funt els
pression and will apologiaa te Inspector Bention applying to this one are If any Stanton and to the Court, and will express proper for the Magistrats to consider that The Hittites, their Inscriptions quouer, which has been not insptly coms very happiness and prosperity
We are, Dear Sir, Yours respectfully,
perroti tees any insulting expression in the Stanton and to the Court, and will express by his defence. It la gaite right and enough to find the book of John Campbell,
does his extreme regret
real The Hittites, their Inscriptions defence. He says it is an aggravation of and their History and ever since I have Un Calcutta pared to a Highland spate, carrying all bo
Dr. C. Thomson said he had pleasure in presence of a Magistrate, phee acting lu Dr J. G. Thomsa and the initutes of the the discharge of himarily nebtauce the occurred. I have right to anything in his mum punishaaenz
The Chief d'arico-Reading the depost the original offence and is considering the Lore it, would have been of great aselatange
fectly clear to my mouse that into consideratrate can inflict The Hittites migrated seat of 118m is stili ward, he says, I will gical proof, which is of the Japanese punishment I "I On Caleutia in the campaign which will hate to be reading an extract from the initiales of the the discharge of his Magisterial duly, ach tione it is perfectly clear to my mind what sunlament will award, he says, I will pisaded for the extremely striking stymatas
some
The man occur might give thirstin London Missionary Socials, which is the Magistrate may summarily nebtauce the occurred. I have rund them four times so punis
occurred. I have rund original offence and offender is Very good of these express the mat that having have been self uppes that in induce them to rote the sum required local governing body of the hospital-
Me Francis-Very good but we have favour as well as against him, and it is gear is two mouths.
vour as well as against him, and it is gearum punishanens the Magistrato can indict (F 18) for the Hittite origin of the Japanese. The Hittites migrated toward the north and That the District Committes placa cb Me Francis-Very good ; but we have that I might give weight to anything in his take that into consideration. The mazi.gical proof, which is given in this book to obtain the grant promised by Mr Basilios.
M: Fraccis-I do not think that I cast, and a miserable rest of them is still found in Siberia: among the Yenisalaas I feel certain his lost of reason would have record their high appreciation of Dr Can to stcertain the meaning of these espres to my mind that he did use the expression;
the Alice Max riones: They cannot, I submit, be disso that the moment that he used it li xe. on usefully occupy your Lordships' time
Ben fund went away all opposition, and that both slie's ungendging services to the Alice Motione They cannot, I submit, be disso that the moment that he used it he re polets and unofficials forgetful of the merial and Netherste Hospitals, and their diated from the other expressions in the gretted it, but that having mat Inspector
from the apparent object Butlin, who appears to have boen self upon the mercy of the Court wurde & Hitite. And in exactly the
have botany longer. The appellant threw him every mau ia, according to the various Bul Lent, 100 fine (por fasl)
merty of the Gourt dialects, kes, ka, hit, hitt, Ass, in other vereigns (Bank's buping rats). Bogey retrenchment would have found deep aanas of inss about to be sustained same section or from the apparent object Butlin, who appears to have been any longer.
Hilite, And, (per task). themselves in the somewhat unusual by the Medical Mission through his deand purport for which the action has been friend of bis-because he shook hands with d
that the passed, neither can they be dissociated him when he went out of the Doort-and subsart or of behaving contomp came manner, the Japanese hare proser
and that he had no intention towards it. And in exactly the Silver (per az Andidault the position of complete accord.
parate from the Colony and that the passed, neither can they be dissociated hi hough the College is about to loss the District Betretary be directed to convey from the general law which regulates pro- got an inkling that this was likely to batuously towards the Court. What hoved the remembrance of being origin. infinence of Dr Cantlis't powerful advos to Dr Candlie the Committee's most cor. ceedings for contumps of Court and what trought to the autice of the Magistrate and as swcy. I ak bol without hope that the dial thanks for the substantial aid he has constitutes contempt of Court, because that bo was to be charged, he turned ange
is en ound and wickedly espression to him ing how absolutely races of this description already implies, tatlarity between Tomato THERMOMETER College may be properly endowed. The rendered
the object for which the McEwan had used the ofpression te him ing how absolutely free we have been in Mexicans and Peruvians, and, as the name brought rendered to the Medical Work during the the object of the section toast by end is on that be war to be charged, he turned seld was not intended to be heard by ally Hittites, for each of them calls himself object for which the round and wickedly seested that Inapot as Mr
doubt, BADOUR Blazas
ing how absolutely free we have bear is Campbell bas proved beyond deals, the epidemic of 1894
broth whole period of his resideves in Hongkong. tirely the same as to himself a Camp home to us how neembare it is in whole period of his resideves in Hongkong. tirely the same as the object for which the round and wickedly chessted that Inspector anyone it was merely an akprosive to to which is apparently identical with He most heartily occurred in every ward to prevent any interference with legal pro-tables upon his accusers. Es has never inalt of the Court or interferer.co with
word general law for contempt of Couri existe and called him that, thereby thening the this Colony from offices of this description exists and Peravians, and, as the patte He most heartily coccurred in every ward general law for contempt of Couri exists McEwan het Used the ofpression te hins himself as a vent for his fastinge. Consider Hellite. To the same stock balous
Dr -insult of the Court or interference with already implies, the Catbayans. the interests of the public health of die Stewart Lockhart had said. It had been tours or with the operations of the Court: had the courage to bring the charge against the officers in the cxevation of their daty,
The striking of this Colony that there should be amongete to prevent any interference with legal pro-ent
interference with the the Chiness trained in Western Medical gunual report daring his lifetime so consult Courts of Justice is the sole object for this expression. Okiness trained in Westera Mediosi raived to place Dr Cantils's nams in each vedurs or with the operations of the Court;ables upon his accus.rs. He has never his Cology from off tices of this description Mexicans and Peravians, and, as the name Bano &
the p-blicity and diegrzes and discredit and Homath, the old capital of the Hittites, THERMOMETER-- A..... Methods, and I think every one who cuting surge of the Hospital, shongaldo that of which the law with reference to contempt Methods, and I think every one who ungal report daring his lifetime as consult to prevent any interference with the bus doblega
attacking to the appellant in ennmention is exhibited by Mr Campbell (p. 18), and he Brots on the important matter spoos but og g
but gurgaon of the Hospitel, shongaldo that of Courts of Justice in the sole object for the unstabled charging them with ming the officers in the sxevation of their daty,
Me Francis-Within an hour he was with this matter would be almost sufficient adds the comparison, which struck me at: puntalsment, for the office and will does ones, with Himayed, the old nates for the agree that an Institution which can train De Mensets at tonaditing physiolar. They which the law with reference to contempt this expression. Chinese in such methode should zeosiva did this out so much an at honour to Dr of Court exista,
The Chief Justice And to maintain the brought before the agistrate. the lastitaliane, so
The Oufof Justiceer, but he reall athere from being guilty of similar Bimalayan, and with the Amants, the
Peruvian moribes (p. 24). every encouragement and support. Suck Oxetlie as so honour to the institutions,
in order to show the extremely suggestive Mr Francis-That is implied. If the winkel enough to think that instead of ad- offences. an institution oxista in the Chinese College that long years hance when their children dignity of the Dour
After conferring with Me Justica Wire, obaracter of Mr Campbell's etymologios, of Medicine with which the name of De taquired who it was they would tell them
the Court would not be so able to administer ay the policeman used it, and then he the Chief Justice sald-I do not think d-I do not think
ink which are, to say the least, equal to those of Cantlis will always be associated; for he it was the name that they already knew so dignity of the Clonet is not maintained then hitting, the use of the expression tre should
instructed--not the same day, but two date we need call upon yoo. Mr Pollock. This ir Edkins, whom contributions sometimes as been the life and soul of it, and had it well-the name of Dr Cantlie, the grest the Court would not be so able to admistery the policeman used it, and then he
justice,
is an appeal from the decision of the The Chief Justice-The use of these ex afterwards, he instructed his apliciter to knon not been fer his keen enthusiasm, his love London surgeon (applause)
Br Wong-Tek said Mr Chairman, I praesions may be to the Magistrate, aon that effect, brosuse I can only assume his Magistrate, who intcred a sentence of people to study that book, which throws a of his profassion, his untiring real, and bis
alicitor acted upon the appellante insitut of light da Asiatic and American bls. tors, I quote a few of the most striking Indmaitatis energy, it is certain that the bave been asked by the other Lioentietes seven days' imprisonment upon the appell
Temperature College would never have been so sucessful and the students of the College of Medicine sauss of the Magistrate. If a judge were tions when he raised this defence before the lant for having used insalting szpressions College would never have been so successful and the students of the College of Medicine orning the Magistrate or in the pre-avlicitor acted upon the appellant's instruc- Magistrate, who ta fitored a sentence of appear in your paper, and in order to invite dest, a man in Court could not be Magistrate-this charge that it was
in the presence of disobarge of comparess family name Masakado is Bidits as it has been. In addition to the excellent for Chingue to express to their name our dest,
when work in connection with the College, Dr Oan deep regret that the College in lesing him as allowed to keep
The Muntado Humidity.... 76. because the ing MoEwas that was the defouse Magisterial duty. The Ordinanesit is undoubtedly of the same origin as Mas. Diration of
atro Magisterial, in the need hardly point out that is is an atra-sotion 90 I am bea been
Wind... this has also bran one of the main pillars of its Dean; and as its Lecturer on Anatomy allowed to keep up a running commentary trumped up esas for the purpose of shield. in the presence of the Magistrate torf, I quote a few of the most striking Barometer
thank judge could not hear him. the Alien Memorial and Neshersola Hospitals, and Burgery, Destor Cantlio, we than ridiculing the Court simply because the ing McEwan-that was the defcase. when
Mr Frands-Was this an insult to the clously wicked thing-liaving done an-an-open.os neding-deals with three ssgssas (p. 2); Yedo corresponds to the
offen.68: If any person behaves in an Mexican tribe deter, the medials, represent For ******* an Mexican tribe detec which, as you all know, are bospitals main you for all your kizdues to us, your patience Air Francis--Was this an insult to the clously wicked thing-having done an as-offet.nsf
or troffen.es: in
insulting, manner or dees any threatening ing an original breathing (31); the Chinese Weather Mized by voluntary contributione and with as, and your willingness to help us in Magistrate, to the Court at to the admini- mannerly thing, to turn round and try to insulting, manter or ding
rain the charater of the constable by asy-saulting manner or dees any threatening
Raiz......... insulting expression to ut conseru- tablissed for the purpose of treating Chic all airenmateners. We ak you to apcops stration of justice! Is it contended
stration of justice! Te conto de expreting the constable used the expression to grin the presencia of a Magistrate, aben die Ford (da) Hachiman, the Highest open air temperature on the fo
Mr Justios WiseIf he used the ing prophetapi geus of Japan, Tupen, is apparently the Ralz Mr Justies Wine-If he used the acting in the discharge of any Magisterial god of war, is doubtlessly the same name nass spedzling to Western methods. But from as this cup; masompaated by a small Base aptording Dute ing the years from 1887 to 1885 no fower gift for Mrs Cantile, that you may have aion, I think it is an insult to the Court hitt. He now admits however to you that in the presence of a Magistrate, when Indien Fussed (2, 181; Hachiman, the Highest open air sepers ing the years for magnts and 79,000 not before you standing romloder to you of and tends to interiste with
in sma (18),
that was falss, and that the instructions duty, the magistrate may summarily design the Mexican historians maks Hioman standing reminder to you of and tends to interfere with the administra that was falss, and that the fostructions acting in the discharge of any Magisterial thas about 0,000 fo-pationts
ho gave to his solicitor that it was a cost be gree to his solicitor that it was a Co-with Impri-and stants have been an idea of the in that we shall do auffering among our were
treator and patients have been treated in these hospitals. our gratitude for the many favours we hate tion of Justice.
piracy to shield bicEwan were fate and comment not exceeding two months among the extinct Guinches of the Canary The Chief Justice--The words I am piracy to abled bicEwan were fates and with the maiter, either by fine or impel- and the Peravias Huaman; it also appeared Three Bigures will give in ides of the ex-received at our hands. We promize you
This is A social power which has been Islands sa the apunym of the dehimencey, cellent work that is being performed in that we shall do our best, by diligent efforts sorry to repeat them which sets used be unreservedly withdraws that defence.
Mr Francia-Certainly, your Lordship, in force in the Colony for over twenty and its oldest form is preserved in Joshua valent work that in bo has work Dr Centrallers the sick and suffering among our were: Godein son of a band that these Toxiitutions, and to that inferent
of silwere: Godan son of a band that He has lent the valuable aid of his medicul own people, to prove ourselves worthy of sil applies to some person it is not like Baving arrived at that point I would ask years, beosten I see this section was taken. XV. La, where ahiman appears as an of sines the hospitale the labour you have to generously hestowed Bather it' or 'Dama it, which would be you to consider the general order in which from Ordinanca 10 of 1870. I cannot help Enak. I express the hope that historien! and surgical skill ever 16 bare grated. For the part nine years, Ee upon us. We wish you a good poyage, rude sud improper, but which do aut sp. the proceedings are conducted at the Police thinking that it is partly on socuant of the researchen based on the saild reok of such
to remember that at the Police Magnity of his Court, nele, Es besu one of the regular visiting surgeons spiedy restoration to health and strength, ply to some person. It is suggested that Court, and asking you to remember that existence of that Ordines in this Colony
disained question of the origin of the Japa to these hospitals, and during that time and all prosperity in your future life, he by these hospitales
his expression applied to Inspector Stan however offensive the language was he had that the Police Magarate has been able sound etymology, may soon settle the long ton, who had just been giving evidence in no intention of imesiting the Court as a to maintain the proper dignity of his Court, many have been the tick and suffering to (Applanes),
the dane. I do not know if you intend to Court, and that the appellant had no know which is often crowded with Chineas and whom he has brought relief and samfort
ledge that the use of the expression would others, some of whom ocossionally may and healing then with that skill, cheer
say that it applies to soups eine!
Mr Francis From the evidence, I be constitute an insult to the Court; and how ing them with that geniality which
lieve it was intended for Inspector Stautou. pror wild the contempt of Court might have many residents in this Colony will so long
The Chief Justion-it ping an expression been, whether the punishment inflictou by
Messrs. Kelly & Walsh's List rememba Bat not only has he been of
as
includes the following Works by Da EITEL:- statante to these hospitals es dostoc
The speeches of Air Franolk and Dr Cantiered towards a winess in the presents of the Magistrats might not have been too
the Magistrata. Is that not using ineuiting severe.
EUROPE IN CHINA: The History of Lin has always taken a keen interest in their
language in the presence of the Magistrate! The Chief Jasion-Yon Mlet, baar in and measures. The appsilant 10 this Base PRESIDE Cleveland's action in the Vane- Smancial welfare. Na mpyement has ever will be published to-morrow.
Hongkong, from the beginning to the Als Francis Endoubtedly it in faulting mind that the Magistrate had evidently had apparently nothing to do with that suele matter bas had far-reaching son- taken place to raise fanda without his exer
langonge, but is it in the protanes of the
yout 1882, Hopskong, 1898, $6.50. slag immolt in the good of zine finspitals + want a fountats per veel and the As Oblot Jostlemil the Magistrate in the defence he set up. Ho eat up the understand from the lusaed counsel vers beloft theas of the previous month by TED LECTORIES BUDDHISM
taken the view that the conduct of the one. Le seems to have gone up to the suvis matter bas had far-reseding po member theted both bacon weekly and 1 hour a member when she låre in wald the of wark pen, sold Magistrate P
bangkelt-Durbete Diuionary Besond wis given in the Fuble Gardeor the mentiems with the bresting brows and the The Oblet Joltell the Yaghirata in was greatly aggravated by the nature of Court at a sort of friend and supporter of the sequences not only in America, but all arst HAND300K OF BUDDHISMA
up. He sat up the men who was thus charged, and who wat, as the world. In Japan is to reponitble for Versus Destor rehabited booth with the siting out Yes, air all right, sir, present. It does not my in the hearing defense that he never used the expression 1 Understand from the lusted counsel, decrease in the exporte last month, which Edlloy, Boogkong 1886 99.50.
booch with the siting out we have the very of the MagistralIt was in the praainst the police had wickedly dates was in au moy nevestars of Keeping explained ever since the fascial damy men as compralom en whom baahid the tapman.We have the very of the Magistrato,
Mr Justice Wis-It was in the precincts that the police used it against hit and that fined for having these false weights and were below thens of the previous month by Fallon, Boogkong 1866 €2.50
yen and his preaande in the Cours van 517,676,69, be importe slowed: Au trumped up this mo Flormed weed Bardly any most ance thing you wealtke paglist's favorite.
Operation wood Bardiganen whom has biting the brating held the angonge but is indonbtedly it is strate ful oporations wonderful la res balore Jet A
Jou all it up occasionally and it never will of the Court
Eaves PENGSEULER,
Natural Selsace, Hongkong, 1873. Browded Audience from whot, however, he dry app
The Chief Justice-Thers are certain base against him. This to the Masticieste's was in no way nomentary. He was thote appareren 1,454,493.60. The decrease Third Edition. Hongkong, 1888. $1.50. of Box trumped up by the polide to sield countenance his friend who can market, which ever slace the fluencial OR BOK OF CLARKE'S 8.41 Praiswamated deeds which it done in a Royal Palace record Me Filia submite the cite is partitip for the purpose of keeping explained by the condition of the wik
ne man turp-weak, | the Hopital
to mate all disuniges from the Uridars Ongous bring serious results to the door. It dues MoEwan. That le a very gross aggenvallon who had false wind mesures trouble in New York has seed Try weak, ORINESE DICTIONARY IN THE CAN-
the person
kouw, Tarpestor Stanton many orders from Amarion having beenTON DIALECT. Four Volumes, with told trumped up by the polida to bield tootenance his friend who Turning to De Canelle, Mr Lockhart wald in the wax (asquled of constitational); Gravel not matter if the King is present. Thats the one
Appendix. Hongkong, 1877-110,00. une giren his evidence and proved the patermanded, Acte Chronicle, et Dr Cantle it with feelings of gentina and Pains in tBid Garated free from are certalu provinote; and it-in the same
Bound, $11,000 gic, ne he was bound to do in the discharge regret that we have to say goodbye to you. Werdery, Bold in Bozen in. Ud. saab, by a thing with church. The general idos in Etteid taste wave of forgetfulness soon Cheminis and Patent Medising Vendar through that à perace should bahays in a certain
of his duty--not always a pleasant duty- Away obliterates the memory of tabas who go from at the World.opriest Ta Lingan way la sburgh. But when you come to Pava Company, Lingalay Diagistrates Court whatever you say the thidah and this to parkaga ansta voidableary COVA
tale nagy dologlard
Weged against the powers that be in order
ful
But!
is
་
De Gentile replied in a long speech.
De Hd Kal proposed a vote of thanks to the Chairman, he made a few olusing ro-
quite as valuable sa the appellan
Mr Jostico Wis-McEwan's character The Chief Unatige Th
の引
be ladlined to be discrderly. As regards,
the Incis of the case there appears in BANFORS, Guitare, Mandolines, Antoharps,
no dispute at all. Inspector anton had Violine, also Strings and fittings for sale a been given evidence in Care Hose W. Robinson and Co. man was okarged with having falas wjghts
polst you make as leaving the box and then the appel W RONSON and Co. maha a special is when
that we did afterwards was put partent who seems to Have learned Baglish feature of Balling Places and Organdon 3- and original offengej
-
And had the advantage of Bring in Bongs | the Easy-Pagtact prstom
4 months sight,
Drudite,
Oa Parle-
4
2/2
2.70
Dommentary, mau ta'sight,
On demand Ccodite months' sight, - m in he a new York. On Be-Demandinï ̧
Ou demand, Credits, 40 doyo' rig} %,
Wire
FIL HEN AN AT
་་་
1831
Og founud,
Shanghat Wirs, On demand, Shanghai
441
FIR rh
145
On demand,
30 days' sight, private paper
DOL
$49.00
Temperature.
(Taken at Mours Falconer & Co.'s Premises, Queen's Road.)
PAK
,80.21 Horogoro, February 6, 1890,
1 AM
& P. Most
30.12 30.10
Ka
18
Do.
I FAM
68
Do.
4 F · QU
Do. (Wet Bulb) D.10. Do.
Do,
Do. 1 P.M. 58 Do Do. Maximum
82
וגן
Do. Minimats overaläht 61
HONGKONG REGISTER.
Previous OD anta atrón datza. jdaystóp.m.). 10 8.1.
*p,
80.10
$0.18
30.20
58
56
57
67
76
2.
od.
0.19
Lowest open air temperature on the fiduino-bi
F. G. Fice, First Assistant, Hongkong Observatory, Feb. 5, 1896.
Quotations. BONGZONO, February 5, 1896. OPTUM-New Patns, ommh.... 7873
Old Mouth,797 Now Benares, cash, 765 cath, 795
1.
#
50
Old
FOR SALE.
PENGSHUI Rudiments of Chloere
3200.
CELTERS BOKOOLBOOKS Translated.
1. The rimairidal Disesto. - Ika (The Thousand Words Foom. 69.50 per set-