84.
24
We have divided the executive grade into two, with a promotion bar between $9,600, per annum and $10,080 per annum. Similarly we have provided for two grades of senior executive officer. The nature and responsi- bilities of these senior posts will naturally vary with the development of social services within the Colony and we would not suggest that the list of scheduled posts we have put forward is exhaustive. We tentatively recommend that the holders of the posts of Chief Clerk, Colonial Secretariat, General Secretary of the Public Works Department, Treasury Accountant and Treasury Inspector should be graded as senior executive officers grade I and the Treasury Cashier, the Accountants in the Railway, Public Works Department and the Waterworks, and the Secretaries in the Medical Department and the Urban Council might be graded as senior executive officers, grade II.
85. Women clerks have been engaged since the reoccupation and their work has proved satisfactory. We have therefore provided salary scales for women clerical officers at 80% of the scales for male clerical officers. Grade III runs from $1,440 per annum to $2,040 per annum, grade II from $2,160 to $3,360 and grade I from $3,600 to $4,800. We recommend that entry should be by competitive examination for which the possession of the Hong Kong School Leaving Certificate should be the minimum qualification. We have made separate provision for stenographers, who should possess a Hong Kong School Leaving Certificate or its equivalent and be able to pass a prsecribed typing and shorthand test before appointment as stenographers grade II on the scale $2,880 to $4,800. Promotion to stenographer grade I should depend upon vacancies in this grade and ability to pass a more advanced shorthand and typing test. In addition we recommend the creation of a small grade of senior stenographers and secretaries for promotion to which the same technical qualifications will be required together with secretarial ability of a high order.
86. We have considered representations from various Heads of Depart- ments that the nature of the work in their particular departments was so specialised that there was a loss of efficiency in drawing their clerical staff from a general clerical service and through losing men through transfer to other departments. Complaints were also received regarding the slowness of promotion for clerical officers and the apparent unfairness of the system of making promotions. Certain Heads of Departments have suggested that their departments should be made closed departments and that their clerks should receive promotion within their own departments. Although we appreciate the difficulties which such Heads of Departments may have experienced and can readily understand their reluctance to part with officers who have, through experience and specialisation, made their services particularly valuable in a certain direction, we consider that it would be neither in the interests of the officers themselves nor of the public service as a whole to extend the system of closed departments. Instead we recommend that all clerical staff not excluding the present postal clerks should be in a single unified service. We are of the opinion that by the creation of the executive grade we have opened up an avenue of promotion to the outstanding officer at any stage of his career in the Clerical Service and that adequate provision should be made by the setting up of the proposed Public Services Commission to which reference is made in Chapter IX to ensure that promotions are made fairly and according to merit.
87. Another proposal which we have considered was that there should be a separate Clerical and a separate Accounting Service. It was argued that the present system could produce good bookkeepers but not good accountants and that increased specialisation was necessary. It was also contended that a trained accountant should receive a higher salary than his opposite number on the clerical side. We do not find ourselves able to accept these arguments. We have already recommended that an elementary knowledge of the Government clerical and accounting systems should be required before probationer clerical officers are confirmed in their appointments and we consider that while a clerical officer is in grade III he should not be allowed to specialise but should have an opportunity of doing both clerical and accounting duties. After promotion to clerical grade II officers might be allowed to specialise in either direction.
88. Another possibility which has been discussed is the creation of a separate grade of shroffs i.e. assistant cashiers. We understand that in the past shroffs whose educational qualifications have been lower than those normally required for the Junior Clérical Service, have been engaged on the Junior Clerical Service scale at points varying with the amount of security they were required to provide. We are not in favour of the establishment of a separate grade of shroffs or assistant cashiers, but consider that the duties of an assistant cashier should be performed by members of the General Clerical Service as part of their normal career. We do not favour any relaxation of
Page 30Page 31