Candidates would not have to be members of the EC, but would
have to come from the relevant sector. The election of
these three candidates in each sector would be by block
vote, using a simple majority system. All members of the
Election Committee would then elect 10 of the 12 to become
members of the Legislative Council by simple majority.
61. In the view of Her Majesty's Government and the Hong Kong Government the Chinese side's proposals do not meet the essential requirements and would not therefore provide a fair
and open method of election.
62.
Following precisely the composition for the fourth sector
set out in paragraph 2 of Annex 1 of the Basic Law raises two
problems. First, the Basic Law model includes members of the
present Legislative Council, not all of whom have been elected.
Second, it includes the Hong Kong Deputies to the National
People's Congress and representatives of Hong Kong members of
the Chinese People's Political Consultative Conference. These
people have not been elected openly and fairly in Hong Kong; to include them in the Election Committee simply by virtue of their
membership of these non-Hong Kong bodies would be a major breach
of the requirement that the Election Committee should be
composed of people who had themselves been elected openly and
fairly in Hong Kong. It would mean that part of the Election Committee was produced in an undemocratic way.
63.
The voting method proposed by the Chinese side is
self-evidently restrictive and cumbersome.
64. Following the Foreign Secretary's meeting with the Chinese
Foreign Minister in July 1993, the British side introduced in
Round Eight of the talks a revised proposal on the Election
Committee. In a major move towards the Chinese position, this accepted that the Election Committee should be composed of four
statememt.8/BRIEFS/NJH
33