CONFIDENTIAL
would involve heavy financial and political costs for HMG.
HONG KONG ASPECTS
5.
Although persons joining HKG since March 1985 have not
been able to become HMOCS officers, two key areas of the
Civil Service in Hong Kong still contain substantial numbers
of HMOCS officers. In the police force, some 60% of
superintendents and above are expatriates, and the majority
of these officers are also HMOCS members. In all there are
363 police HMOCS members and a further 260 police officers
who still have the option to become HMOCS members. In the administrative service, about one quarter (99) of all officers who occupy the middle and senior ranks of the Hong
Kong Government are HMOCS members. There are also some 40
judicial HMOCS members and some 280 others, mostly professionals. If large numbers of police officers were to
leave, the command structure of the Police Force would
collapse, and the Force would not be able to maintain law
and order. If there was a large scale departure of senior
civil servants, our ability to administer Hong Kong
effectively could be undermined.
It could also encourage
others to leave and have a wider effect on confidence in the
Joint Declaration.
6. It is not possible to predict how many HMOCS officers might decide to leave if acceptable arrangements were not made, or when they might do so. But the Governor considers
that there is a real risk that several hundred senior and
middle-ranking officers will leave unless adequate
arrangements for HMOCS are announced soon.
7. The Joint Declaration (like the constitutions of territories attaining independence) contains good assurances about pay and pensions (repeated in the Basic Law). The
details are at Annex B. These guarantee pay and conditions of service "no less favourable than before" and payment of pensions "on terms no less favourable than before". But the
NC3AAV/2
CONFIDENTIAL