CONFIDENTIAL
MR GILLMORE'S MEETING WITH MR DAVID HOWELL:
FOREIGN AFFAIRS COMMITTEE
Points to Make
Speaking very frankly, grave misgivings about idea that Committee should undertake enquiry into Hong Kong. Believe
Secretary of State has explained why.
We are having some success in arranging for Hong Kong's future. Doing much to shape Chinese perceptions. But this depends on
continuing and delicate confidential negotiation with China, which
has another eight years to run. Must not put it at risk.
Therefore little we could say publicly. Expect vast bulk of
our briefing would have to be under confidentiality rule. On some
subjects could say nothing at all. Wonder what basis this would
offer to the Committee for publication of a report.
At same time, Committee would come under intense pressure from media and lobbies in Hong Kong. Hard to distinguish between public support and mere volume. This publicity would do nothing to
assist continuing discussions with China and in Hong Kong.
Framework of Hong Kong's future already determined by Joint
Declaration. Being given legal shape in Basic Law. Under-pinned
by confidential understandings between British and Chinese Governments. Most unhelpful if enquiry or its recommendations cut
across these established lines.
See particular sensitivity if you focused on development of representative government. Progress here too is bounded by Joint Declaration, Basic Law and our confidential dealings with Chinese. Has already been subject of intense consultation by ourselves and
Chinese with Hong Kong people. Believe outcome can be reached
CONFIDENTIAL