GRS 450
CONFIDENTIAL
FM HONG KONG
TO IMMEDIATE FCO
TELNO 2116
CONFIDENTIAL
ник ош
RECEIVED IN REG
10 OCT 1935
ESKO
OF 090925Z OCTOBER 85
1
INFO IMMEDIATE PEKING'
PEKING!
INDEX
HONG KONG TELNO 2097: DEBATE ON BASIC LAW IN LEGCO.
196
Asheets. PA 011/1 ра
TUR REPORTED THE CALL BY ELECTED LEGCO MEMBER AND BASIC LAW DRAFTING COMMITTEE MEMBER, MR MARTIN LEE, QC, FOR THE BASIC LAW TO BE DEBATED IN LEGCO. THIS HAS BECOME THE SUBJECT OF
CONSIDERABLE MEDIA ATTENTION FOLLOWING REMARKS BY THE CHIEF SECRETARY TO THE EFFECT THAT IT WOULD NOT BE DESIRABLE AND PERHAPS EVEN CONSTITUTIONALLY IMPROPER FOR THE BASIC LAW TO BE DEBATED IN
LEGCO AS SUGGESTED BY MR LEE AND THE SUBSEQUENT ASSERTION AS
SUGGESTED BY MR LEE THAT THERE WAS NOTHING THE CHIEF
SECRETARY COULD DO TO PREVENT HIM BRINGING THE SUBJECT UP IN THE
COUNCIL. MISS DOROTHY LIU IS ON RECORD AS SAYING THAT THE BASIC
LAW IS BEING DRAFTED UNDER THE AUTHORITY OF THE NATIONAL PEOPLE'S
CONGRESS WHICH IS A SUPERIOR BODY: IT WOULD NOT BE APPROPRIATE FOR
LEGCO AS A LOCAL LEGISLATURE TO DEBATE IT.
2. STANDING ORDER 9(5) OF LEGCO PRECLUDES AN UNOFFICIAL FROM
RAISING IN AN (NEXT WORD UNDERLINED) ADJOURNMENT DEBATE ANY
SUBJECT FOR WHICH THE GOVERNMENT IS NOT RESPONSIBLE AND SO 15(1).
IMPOSES SIMILAR RESTRICTIONS ON QUESTIONS. BUT THERE IS NOTHING IN
PART G OF STANDING ORDERS TO PREVENT MR LEE FROM MOVING A MOTION
IN THE NORMAL COURSE OF LEGCO BUSINESS AND ROYAL INSTRUCTION XXIV
PERMITS ANY MEMBER TO PROPOSE ANY QUESTION FOR DEBATE. (IT WAS
UNDER THIS BROAD REMIT THAT THE LOBO MOTION WAS MOVED DURING THE
NEGOTIATIONS.) THE ONLY WAY IN WHICH MR LEE COULD BE FRUSTRATED
IS BY USE OF SO 22 WHICH PERMITS THE PRESIDENT TO AMEND A
MOTION OR RULE IT OUT OF ORDER.
3. HOWEVER APART FROM SO 31 THERE IS LITTLE OR NO GUIDANCE AS TO THE PRINCIPLES TO BE APPLIED IN DETERMINING WHETHER A MOTION IS OUT OF ORDER. WE PROPOSE TO EXPLORE THIS ASPECT IN GREATER DETAIL IMMEDIATELY WITH A VIEW TO PROVIDING AN OPINION AND GUIDELINES ON THE SCOPE OF SO 22. WE ARE PRESENTLY CONSIDERING WHETHER THE SCOPE FOR DEBATE, BEING ANCILLARY TO THE DEVOLUTION OF LEGISLATIVE CLAUSE UNDER THE LETTERS PATENT, SHOULD NOT SIMILARLY BE CIRCUMSCRIBED BY REFERENCE TO THE PEACE ORDER AND GOOD GOVERNMENT OF THE COLONY. OUR LEGAL ADVISERS WILL PROBABLY WISH TO CONSULT YOUR LEGAL ADVISERS. BUT WE SHALL HAVE TO BE ALIVE TO THE POLITICAL ASPECTS TOO.
CONFIDENTIAL
/4