SECRET

ID

NEGOTIATION ABOUT THE FUTURE OF THE COLONY WHICH WE WISH TO

AS LONG AS POSSIBLE. ON THE OTHER HAND IF WE ACT NOW WE CAN THE

OUR ACTION TO THE QUESTION OF THE LEASES WHICH OBVIOUSLY NEEDS TO

BE TACKLED RELATIVELY SOON.

5. INCIDENTALLY THE SITUATION RESULTING FROM THE COMBINATION OF CLAUSES 2 AND 3 DESCRIBED ABOVE WOULD BE MUCH EASIER TO DEFEND TO

CRITICS WHO COMPLAINED THAT WE HAD NOT MATERIALLY CHANGED THE

SITUATION AND THERE WILL BE PLENTY OF SUCH CRITICS HERE.

-

6. YOUR PARA.4. TO FIND WORDING FOR CLAUSE 3 WHICH AVOIDS

REFERRING DIRECTLY TO CONTINUING BRITISH ADMINISTRATION IS A PROBLEM. WE COULD STICK TO THE EXISTING WORDING ON THE GROUNDS THAT SELF-EVIDENTLY THE GOVERNOR MUST HAVE POWER TO EXERCISE AUTHORITY SO LONG AS BRITAIN ADMINISTERS THE NEW TERRITORIES, AND THE CHINESE MIGHT FIND THIS EASIER TO ACCEPT THAN THE SAME PHRASE APPLIED TO THE LEASES SINCE THE FORMER WOULD NOT CONTRADICT DENG'S

SCENARIO WHEREAS THE LATTER WOULD. HOWEVER SINCE THERE IS AN CEVIOUS RISK THAT IT COULD PROVOKE DISCUSSION OR SUSPICION WE ARE NOW WORKING ON A FORM OF WORDS WHICH WOULD PUT TOGETHER THE

ESSENTIAL ITEMS IN CLAUSES 3 AND 4 BUT AVOID WORDS WHICH MIGHT -OFFEND, WE WILL TELEGRAPH OUR SUGGESTIONS SOON.

7. IT IS BY NO MEANS CERTAIN THAT THE CHINESE BELIEVE THE INITIATIVE

LIES WITH THEM. WE DELIBERATELY MADE IT CLEAR THAT WE WERE

INFORMING THEM ABOUT WHAT WE PROPOSED TO DO RATHER THAN INVITING

A DISCUSSION. I ALSO TOLD HUANG HUA THAT WE WOULD BE INT TOUCH

AGAIN BEFORE TAKING ACTION. UNLESS THEY HAVE SUCH SERIOUS

OBJECTIONS TO OUR WHOLE APPROACH THAT THEY WISH TO HEAD US OFF

FROM EVEN EXPLAINING IN DETAIL WHAT THEY ARE - IN WHICH CASE WE

CAN EXPECT A REACTION FAIRLY SOON THEY MAY WELL BE RESERVING

JUDGEMENT UNTIL WE HAVE EXPLAINED OUR PROPOSAL IN DETAIL.

8. M.I.F.T.

MACLEHOSE

FILES

ARGO

LEGAL ADVISERS

FRO

کنم

AS/LORD GORONWY ROBERTS

Ps/pus

SIE A DUFF

تمام اسام

CORTAZZI

MR MURRAY

وو

SECRET

Share This Page