Page
February 9, 1907.]
Major and Mrs T. P. Jones, Captain W. C. Jones, R.M.L.I., Staff Surgeon and Mrs R. H. Jouer, Assistant Paymaster E. P. Jones, Dr E. Evan Jones, Dr and Mrs K. Jasti, Miss Jacobs, Mr and Mrs H. Jessen, Mr. and Mrs Edward Jones, Mr. F. J, Messrs B. James, C. H. Neill James, R.N.. H. T. Jackman, D. Jaffe, J. J.Judah, J. C. Jonghin, R.C.N.C., P. Jacks, . A. M. Johnstou, Patrick Jones, Dr and Mrs G. P. Jordan, Miss Lee Jones, Mr. A. Jabrand,
CHINA OVERLAND TRADE REPORT.
Spedding, Rev. G. Searle, Major G. W. R. Stephenson, Mesars. H. A. Siebs, R. H. Scovell, P. O'Sullivan, G. M. Smith, J. R. M. Smith, E. G. Smith, F. Smyth, R. A. J. Savage, A. W. Schellhas, H. W. Sayer, H. Percy Smith, J. H. Seth, A. Sheffield, J. C. Steen, T. Seggie, J. M. P. da Silva, M. W. Slade, C. R. Satter- thwaite, T. H. Stainlow, N. G. S. Simson, R. T. B. Sayle,
Major and Miss C. T Terrott, Dr and Mrs J. C. Thomson, Captain, Mrs and Miss Thompson, Lieat. Commander and Miss Lloyd-Thomas, Mrs H. P. Tooker, Mr and Mrs W. Tutcher, Captain K. Tonami, Lieut. T. Tosu, Mr and Mrs T. Takamichi, Captain A. Thompson, Captain G. B. Thornhill, Captain J. A. Tuke. Messrs. T. G. Turnhall, A. Tillett, T. H. Tennent, 8. M. Thorne, T. Toledano, J. M. G. Taylor. H. Tiffenbacher, W. Taylor, C. Thiel, W. C. D. Turner,
Mesars W. Von Uffel and S. Usher, 129th Baluchis,
Dr and Mrs Kruger, Mrs L. C. Kerr, Colonel and Mrs. Kent, Dr and Mre F. H. Kew, Lieutenant. K. Kogs, Lieut. J. Kiddle, Dr Koob, Captain R. E. E. Krickenbeck, Major H. J. Kelsall, Messrs F. C. Kendall, T. Kawada, H.W. Kent, J. C. Kit»mantil, P. H. Klimanck, J. H. Kemp, H. M. Kendall, F. V. B. Kirwan, Lieutenant T. C. Lethbridge, Captain and Mrs F. W. Lyons, Captain and Mrs C. F. G. Iow, Rev. Mr and Mrs Longridge, Mr and Mrs B. Layton and Miss Layton, Mr and Mra H. E. Stanger Leathes, Mr and Mrs E. (.
Captain and Mrs C. G. Vereker, Mr and Mrs Lane, Mr and Mrs G. Liebert, Mr and Mrs J., C. Varnou, Mrs F. W. Woodley-Valpy, and J. Leiria, Mr and Mrs H, W. Looker, Miss Mr L. Vegner, M. D. Lee, Miss Loureiro, Miss M. Loureiro, Mesara A. F. D. Livesey, H. Lehmann, W. L. Leask, I. C. Lowe, A. R. Lowe, L. V. Langstein, P. Loureiro, L. C. Larmour, J. C. Lecky, L. K. Leeson, C. E. Libeaud, E. P. H. Lang, E. C. Lewis, C. J. La Frentz, E. H. Look, R. Lenzmann, P. Lehrs,
Lieutenant B.
t.
་
Mr and Mrs W. B. Walker, Mr and Mrs E.
SUPREME COURT.
Monday, February 4th.
IN APPELLATE JURISDIOTION.
MAIN AND
BEFORE THE FULL COURT.
LEAVE TO APPEAL
89
Sir Henry Berkeley, K.C., instructed by Mr. C. D. Wilkinsɔu of Messrs. Wilkinson and Frisk mide a formal application on behalf of Messrs. J. Ullmann and Company for leave to appeal to the Privy Council against the judgment of the Full Court in the case of Ullmann, appellants, and Leabs, respondents, and for a stay of proceedings under the judgment,
Mr. M.W. Slade, instructed by Mr. J. Hastings appeared for the respondents, and took exc’P. tion to the application to stay all proceedings under the judgment.
The Chief Justice pointed out that if the exeontion was stayed the injunction was stopped. Sir Henry agreed, but went on to explaia that the appellants were suffering considerable C. Wilke, Mr and Mrs M. Watson, Mr and loss in consequence of the injunction. Should Mrs Wendt. Mr and Mrs Van der Woude, they succeed altimately they would have bad Captain and Mrs G. R. Wait, Mr and Mrs A.
extremely heavy loss by not having rold those Wilson, Mr and Mrs GA. Woodcock, Miss particular watches for a couple of years. The Williams, Miss Wingate, Miss Wilkinson, Miss respondents ought to give an undertaking I. Whiteley, Mrs T. Wakefield Consul General that they would recoup that serious loss which Mr and Mrs A C. More, Dr and Mrs W. B. A.A. P. Wilder, Major W. A Williamson, Cap. the appellants were suffering by not selling. Moore, Mr and Mrs A. S. Mihara, Mrs J.ain H. T. Walker, Captain G. G. Wood, Justice required that they he not restrained from Macdonald, Mr. and Mis G. C. Moxon, Eug. Engineer Commander Watkins, Messrs J. R. selling but that they give security to abide by McQueen, Captain D. Wood, A. G. Wood, F. Walker, Dr Newell any decision of the Privy Council. The order Macdonald, Rev. P. M. de Maria, Messrs Wilson, Mesura A. T. Walker, C. D.
was that appellants give an account of all T. H. Martin, A. G. de Mediros FWillingon, J. W. White, H. P. White, J. sales Macdonald, W D. T. Morri-b, G. H. B. Wisehart, W. L. Waaser, P. Wodehouse,
After discussion, Sir Henry Berkeley Medhurst, H. A. Meyer, C. D. Melbourne, F. H. V. Wilkinson, A
that the W. Watt, P R. Wolff, asked
-xecution be stayed on Matsuyama, R. Maten, G. P. de Martin, E. AR de W. Waller, C. M. T. Western, W. appellants undertaking__not to selí until G. May, Lieut. Colonel and Mrs Scott Moncrieff, H. Wickham, A. E. Wright, A. J. Williams the order of the Privy Council Commander J. P. de Montmorency, Lieutenant and G. H Wakeman, M. A. Marshall, Dr and Mrs J. E. Mitchell, Captain C. L. Mayhew, Dr O. Marriott, Eng. Messrs Chu Sik Yue, Chau Yue Ting, Chan Lieutenant McGregor, Commander H. L. Poy Kai, Choa Teep Chee, Choy Siu Wan, K. Mawbry, Assistant Paymaster P. D. E. Marks, A. Chek, Chan Pun Po, Chan Chuck Hing, Mrs G. C. Master, Miss Master, Miss J. Chan Tez Wan, Chan King Wao, Fung Ws Marchant, Mrs Sud Miss P. Macdonald, Chap, Goh Lea Kheng, Ku Shan Chuen, Ho Measra H. G. Moore, L. M. Murphy, Kom Tong, Ho Fook, Jay Yun Chee, Ka Fai K. Matada, F. Macdonald, G. Muller, F. A. Shan, Lee Pine Shek, Leung Ting Nam, Lo Maclean, V. F. F. de Marney, F: Matsuki, W. Kit Ting, Li Yan Tour. Leung Shin Kong, A Moore, P. Marty, A. M. Marshall, J. Ti Po Lung, Lo Koon Ting, Li Man Leans, Muller, J. E. V. Morton, C. W. May, G. E.La Yum Chnen, Li To Kwai, Li Kin Tong, Morrell, A. Moreno,
Mr and Mrs M. S. Northcote, Mr and Mrs R. Leung Kin On, Li San Hin, i Tez Hi, Lan Li A Pak, Lau Chin Ting, Leung Ngan Pum, Newborn, Father Noval, Surgeon Chn Pak, Mni King Shek, Pow Tak Hang. Nakajima, Eng. Lieutenant Y. Natts, Captain Quan Cho Ching, Quan Kai, Sin Ynen Fai, J. D'Ugly, Dr J. W. Noble, Messrs Negner, P. H. Nye,
ཧ་
Mr and Mrs E. Ormiston, Mr A. H. Gugh. Major H. P. Parker, Lieutenant Colonel Price, Major H. de F. Phillips, Major L. H. Parry, Captain B. S. Phillpotts, Major J. W. Petery, Rev. and Mrs T. W. Pearce, Miss C. H. Pearce, Miss Picard, M's J. A. Plummer, Mr and Mrs T. Petrie, Mr and Mrs T. L. Perkins, Mr and Mrs W. Parlane and Miss Parlane, Captain and Mr O. L. Prios, Mrs C. H. U. Price Messrs T. E. Pearce, C. Pemberton, A. C. Putley, L., Plummer, H. R. Phelips, B. Percival, E. V. D. Parr, J. D., Macpherson, J. J. Plummer, A. N. Paxton, J. B. Picton, L. D. Philpot, J. Pirnitzer,
Captain W. A. Quenne),
Mr, Mra and Miss A. Rodger, Mrs C. V. Shaw Rice, Consul Komane, Mrs and Misses S. B. Howe, Mrs and Miss F. Robinson. Mr and Mrs Ralphs, Mr and Mrs H. Rissland, Mr and Mrs W. Ramsay, Mrs Richards, Mr and Mrs E. A. Ram, Mr and Mrx N. H. Rutherford, Lieut. F. A. H. Russel, Mossre 0. 8. D. Rowe, P. Rrque, L. Robert. A. G. Roberts, C. H. Rowe, A. G. Raymond, A R. F. Raven, Lieut. Colonel J. M. Reid,
Mr N. Yamada,
W. Tse, Ting Lan Kok, Tang Chi Ngon, Toi Kwai Ng, Tan Taz Kong. Tang Lap San Kaw, Wa Wing Hong, Yin Oi Shan Ting, Tong Lai Chuen, U Hoi Chan, Wong Yune Hin Pong. Pum Yan Chuen, Yang Shio Po, You Ping Yee.
HYGIENE EXAMINATION.
H.E. the Governor having again kindly offered prizes for the encouragement of the study of hygiene examinations were held on the 3rd Docòmhar last, at which all the principal government and sided schools of the Colony
compated.
His Excellancy presented the prizes to the successful candidates at Government Honse yesterday at noon. They were as follows :---
First
Second
ADVANCED COUR"M.
(Lau Iuchung # Carlos Sequeira (Wan Khukching ¿Chan Chiu an
}
Elli Kadoorie School. St. Joseph's College.
Belilios School
$1. Diocesan Boys' School. & TI #LEMENTARY COURSE.
The successful team of ten competitors osma from the D'ocean Boys' School" which thus becomer the holder of the «hield for nga year. Major and Mrs Stevenson, Mr and Mrs Prizes were also given for the best papers in Grant Smith, Mr and Mrs M. J. D. Stephens, the winning and the two next teams, and were Dr and Mrs F. O. St. dman, Mr and Mrs F. | awardal to the following :
Mantel Letlað. Alice Brandt Mora Rozario.
Diocesan Boys' Schoot. Italian Consent.
Bellion Public School,
#1
Southey, Captaiu and Mrs T. ekinner, Captatu and Mrs F. H. argent, Miss Spedding, Miss Smith, Mr and Mrs B, de Szentirmay. Miss K. L. Stewart, Dr Alice Sibres, Miss Skipton, Miss Sands, Miss RStacey, Lieut. Colonel and Ou Feb. 4th afternoon the sea gare up the Mrs E. H. Seymour, Miss M. Sanders, Capt. hodies of two more Chinese who were drowned J. B. 8. Shinkwin, Eng. Lieut. A. G. F. alter, in the recent squall Oue was discovered by Dr J. H. Sanders, Lieut. P. A. Shepherd, the police off Bank wharf while the other was Commander K. Seushiu, Lieut. Y. Sakakura, found off the Yaumati wharf. Both were Staff Surgeon E. C. Sawdy Captain C. Gr. removed to the mortuary.
¦
received. It was the question of costs that he was concerned with at present. Why should the appellants be called upon to pay several thousand dollars' costs now, when they might ultimately succeed? There was no sounity for the repayment of those costs.
The Chief Justion said the question wIE whether they should allow the injunction to continue.
Mr. Slade argued that the authorities were emphatic that security for the costs must be given. There was no reason why they should the costs which they might ultimately pay
recover.
The Chief Justice-The rule is that the costs are pud.
Sir Henry-It is very important booanas Mr. Leuba is out of jurisdiction. There is no
against business in Hongkong that can be proceeded If Mr. Hastings gives his personal guarantes to refund the onsts in the event of our succeeding that will get us out of the difficulty.
Mr. Slade—That is the practice. We are willing to do it.
Sir Henry Berkeley-I would ask your Lord. ships in view of the circumstances of a highly debatable point not to make us pay.
We may very well succeed in the Privy Council on the points raised in this Court, having regard to the fact that the Court was divided in opinion. If we pay the costs and succeed we shall be out of pocket in any rent.
The Chief Justice-It cuts both ways,
Sir Henry Berkeley-Both_parties are pre- cisely in the same position, If their costs aro $5,000, probably ours are the same. Why penalise us by making us pay?
The Chief Justice-The other side have got the judgment
The order of the Court was that leave to
appel be granted subject to the payment of security, that no accounts he taken or watches hauded over, and that the injunction stand,
BUILDING ORDINANCE LITIGATION.
An appeal and a cross appeal arising out of Magisterial decisions under the Public Health and Buildings Ordinance were heard. In the first case the appellant was Fung Chun Yuan and the respondents were the Building Authority Mr. M. W. Slude, jastracted by Mr. D. V. Stevenson from the office of Messrs. Denoon Looker, and Denson, appeared for the appellants and the Attorney-General (Mr. H. H. J. Gomperts), instructed by Mr. F. B. L. Bowley, acted for the respondents.
No comments yet.
Private notes are available after approval.