DONALD DUCK
Will gled RAM
NEWS IS
KNOWLEDGE
QUESTION:
Whose
huney-
rauen trịp may lead to Important discoveries regarding prehistorie mun?
Blume,
Professor ANSWER: Italy's most fanous anthropolo- is, took his bride to a mountain- ous, district outside Rome. With her and, he discovered bones in a cave. Among them was a skuti which he identified Neanderthal man.
Q.; Who
man?
was
ONL
of
Neanderthal
A. He occupied Europe some- where between 40,000 BC. and 20,000 B.C. First
Was 16st thrown on him in 1857 when the bones of an extinct peeles of man were found in a cave near Dus- sadort.
Q: Why is Professor Blanc'a discovery important?
A: The skull fe so well pre- erved that it may be presible its means that to establish by Neanderthal man verspied Europe for a far longer period than is now thought.
Q: What other discoveries dict Professor Blane make?
A.
He found remains of ons and hippopotami that once lived in Italy
HOLLAND IS READY
(Continued from Page 6.) didn't ride her bicycle now, for she had grown too old.
་
PUT the Queen was like his mother in so many ways. She was a ponú mother good to all her subjects.
ove is the same for you in England with your fine King and Queen. vast That is why we both have
Our posses- possessions, my friend. stons belong to us with lies of love It cannot happen-the and trust.
trust other way."
-I-usked him about their princess, "She is a fine girl," he sak
#
Chief
Wednesday,
HONGKONG TELEGRAPH.
April 12, 1939.
By Walt Disney
USE
ARMORY
Justice Freedom In English Law
Discourses On
Sir Atholl MacGregor, Chief Justice of Hongkong, was the spenker on "Freedom in English Law" before a large gathering of University students at St. John's Hall last night.
Sir Atholl spoke on English law dating back to the Tweith Century, and also dwelt on the freedom of person and property, freedont of speech, discussion, meeting, and the Press,
The speaker was introduced by Mr. George She, who in a few appropriate words said that St. John's Hall counted it a great honour to have Sir Atholl to speak to them.
Among those present were Mr. D. J. Sloss, Vice-Chancellor of the University; Rev. R. O. Ilult, Bishop of Hongkong; Father 4. T. Byrne. Father G. Casey, Hon. Mr. and Mrs MK Lo, Professor W. Brown, and Professor Robertson.
The speaker said in purt:
years guide mid-control the destinies So may in after of the great Republic of China; many I you will certainly in the fields of medicine, selence and teaching, bring enlightenment, happiness and pro- perity to your fellow men, and so felt justilled in belleving, as I very enntidently believe, that it I could convince you Uut there is no greater hum blessing, whether for state or for subject, than Liberty, as that word is understood and safeguarded by English Law and the British nd ministration of Justice, I should have
discussion, meeting and the Press. J
am taking them together because they
WALT DISNEY
ONLY
"ANCHOR BRAND"
NEW ZEALAND'S FINEST
BUTTER
• The World's Best
SOLE AGENTS LANE, CRAWFORD, LTD., and from ALL LEADING STORES & COMPRADORES
-RADIO-
Vigour Restored, Glands Made Young
ZBW, 355 metres (845 k.c.) and 31.49 metres (9,520 kc.) In 24 Hours
"The Fol-De-Rols" And
Other London Relays BEETHOVEN SONATA
We Talk It Over (Washington and You're Gone That Young); Now (Kuhn and Fiorito)....Carroll Gib- lons ind His Boy Friends; There's A Ring Around The Moon (Grect); Nymph
(Cole Errant Selection
and Gibbons Porter),....Carroll
It in no longer necessary to suffer from Jus of vigour and manhood, wonk
netly
depronniot, nnd poor lead unds, nervousnean, impure let, because all American Docter lan discovered a quick, easy way to and theng troubles,"
are so clearly different aspects of the
This covery is in plonunt, en*7- Radio Programme Broadcast by SER same great liberty! After all, free-
to-lako tablot form, is absolutely harm dom for all practical purposes is the z. B. W. on a Frequency of 845 k.e's. John W. Green (Pianos) necump. by
en bringing new youth and vigOUT freedom of individual human beings and on Short Wave from 1-2.15 Their Boy Friends; Coronado-Select on away with land operations 9.52 m.c's. perou Thanks A
Million-Selection; to thousands. It works directly on the to express themselves by the spoken and 8-11 m. on
Love And Hisses-Film Selection; lands and nervos, and pute now, riel
bloud nud energy in your veinn, In or written word or by netion within second,
Manhattan Music Box-Film Select you can go and feel yoursel the frame work of laws freely mude
12.00-12.20 pan. Relay of Service ton....Carroll Gibbons and His Boy golling younger. Your eyes aparitie and accepted, and so long as that is
Intercession
so enforced silence is nothing but of Imprisonment of the mind.
Under British rule, we are, save
H. K. T.
Irene
Friends.
you feel ativa, and full of youthful
vigour and power,
from St. John's Cathedral.
1.30 Reuter and Rugby Press,
And this amazing, now gland and 12.36 Allee Faye (Vocal), and Roy Weather and Announcements.
vigour restorer, called Dr. Nizen's Vi- Tab, in guaranteed. It has been proved 1.40 New Variety Numbers.
thovande in America and lo how in time of war, rid of such restrictions Fox and His Orchestra. it was not
Dance Orchestra-Blue Skies Are afstributed by chemists here under ↳ You Do The Darndest Things, Baby und absurditles. But
or manoy always so, for, whenever any large (lm Harmony Parade')....Roy Fox
feel full of vigour and energy and proportion of a nation is disaffected and His Orchestra with Vocal Re-Round The Corner Slow Fox-Trot; guarantee of satisfac1104
Fox-Trot....Henry Hall and His from 10 to 20 years younger, or you dunger. The (im On the Avenue): Slumming Orchestra with Vocal
Chorus:
Vocal rely return the empty package and money back. A double- the rights of properly, the liberty of becomes a source of to "the laws and statutes of the realm, towards its Government, a free Press frain by Mary Lee; This Year's Kisses One Man Went To Blow-Novelty you Pr Nixon's VI-Taba must innico
Avenue (flin On the
Green (Traditional); Hot Collings Tabs cosig little, and the guarantee pro- the subjret and the petition of Right." censorship of the press continued in On Park King Charles thereupon hoisted his England ill 1095, and then its abell- Avenue')... Allee Faye (Vocal) with Pretty Polly Perkins Of Paddington strength bottle of 18 Dr. Nixon Vi
The
Nineties teen you. If your abomint is out, write Gay standard and there began the Civil tion was rather accidental than de- Cy Feuer Orchestra; Sweet As A (Traditional).
ene Singers with Orchestra: Organ to Muller & Phipps (China), Ltd., caustically Song-Fox-Trot (Allm Sally. War which ended in the battle of liberate, as Macaulay
(Austin, Shilkret, 20, Queen's Road, Hongkong. Preston in 1648 and the execution of points out in the 19th chapter of his and Mary'): I Could Use A Dream Lonesome Road
and Sally, Irene only Fox-Troi (film of England. The
arr. Waller); Water Boy (arr. Waller) History the Khung next year.
censorship which Mary)....Roy Fux and His Orches
"Fals" Waller; Vocal-Embrasse- vestiges of such still remain are the Lord Chamber-tra with Vocal Refrain by Denny Moi (Pills und A. and G. Tabet); Je lain's control over stage plays and the Dennis: It's Swell Of You (film Wake Aime (Pills and. A. and G. Tubet) Up and Live'); Never In A Million
....Lucienne Boyer with Orchestra; censorship of film pletures.
Years (film Wake Up and Live)....Dance Orchestra-Love Doesn't Crew In what does this vaunted and much Alice Faye (Vocal) with Cy Feuer On Trees-Fox-Troi (film' 'A Song is Bali-Fox-Trol; An Old Hawaiian Fox-Trot....Gene Krupt and His justified this Intrusion on your time against which Milton had pleaded in prized freedom of the spoken and the Orchestra; On The Beach At Ball Burn'); Tell Me With Your Kisses,
Guitar-Fox-Trot.....Roy Fox and Orchestra with
is Orchestra with Vocal Refrain by trene Daye.
2.15 Close Down. 1.00 Time and Weather, Denny Dennis.
6.00 Beethoven-Souata In B Flat 1.03 Carroll Gibbons (Piano) and Major, Op. 22.
Played
Schnabel by Arthur Bubbling Over (Corral! Gibbons) | (Piano). His Boy Friends.
..Carroll Gibbons (lano); Con't;
6.20 Haydn-Quartet In G Major, Op. 64, No. 4.
AVILN
The great rebellion had not been in vain, The Courts of Star Cham- her and High Commission were not revived, Feudal tenures were abolish ed. The restrictions which Henry VIII and Elizabeth had placed on the freedom of the press, restrictions
What. Freedom Consista.
every
vivilized
how it is
$0.
merely because they were Jews, is terrible proof that person and pro- perty are not zafe and that bar
but
Liberty of Press
ידיי
Lord
..
enacted in
the
Vocal Chorus by
PUT THIS NEW COLOUR-THRILL ON
YOUR LIPS!
beat,trangarent South Sew Calor...the me glamorous rows over put inta Npstick
Some Lipstick cooï ectually pela man; others he thinks I condos... but there aer fire contata reda chat resify make his heart beat fast wich dantra for possession ofthele wester. Then
are the Eye exciting South Sea reds found in TATTOO Hp- suck; purposely selected from ali colours because of their stunge power to enchant. Try it your
**Already she has given us an heir. liberty in the forefront of her re- barism again walks on the earth especially they scent a scoop. The an Impartial-public-tribunal--govern--The Composer; 1 Heard You Singing f... and seel You'll also dis
but if the next baby she is having should be a girl, too--and we would prefer a boy-well, we shall know even so, that one day another mother will rule over the Motherland. It
is fine to know that."
H
E showed me a dog race track as we flashed by. They allow dost
What then is the source from which in England flows this life blood of freedom? If one were considering almost any country but England the answer would be simple. France put
written constitution of Belgium. publican constitution und so does the July 4, 1776, use the declaration of American independence. Even the charters of post-war Germany and of Soviet Russin are at pains to declare freedom of
On
tested
or
Estate
coverthat TATTOO is the most Jastingly indelible lipstick you have ever used, and that it crually makes your lips sofier, smoother, chin much more luscious] Serthes five exciting colowe at your favourite store. There are various sizes ne pešcus to atsar pursa, CORALT, KRÓTIC.. NATULAL......PASTI..., HAWAJAN
TATTOO
and have given you a message of vin in the Areopagitles, were allow-written word consist? It is, I feel. real outstanding importance.
est to lapse in 1678, abolished in 1805. almost an anti-climax to pronounce On January 30, 1040. Charles IIn 1979 too the Habeas Corpus Act the law on the subject so I shall leave
executed 523 Wh!ichult. A was passed, In 168 came the re-it to much greater men thinn 1. spectator has told how when the volution and next year William and Liberty of the Press," sald blew fell "there was such a green Mary ascender the throne of England Mansfield, "consists in printing with
Lord Shaw by the thousands then present as I and the Bill of Rights and the nut any previous licence, subject to
the consequences of law." never heard before and desire I may Taleration Act became law,
in 1014 in Arnold v. The King; Emperor wrote: The freedom of the
Pro Arte Quartet (Onnou-Halleux- ever hear again." in these days when nations need above all authority
Journalist is an ordinary part of the which is not state worship, ·and: I pass now to consider what ourdom of the subject, ind to what partmental order "shall be final and Prevost-Muna).
6.45 London Relay-Up The Stairs What hot subject to appeal to any Court," liberty which Is not anarchy, the freedom consists in and
ever lengths the subject in general or "shall be final and conclusive" or Or April', "That is something," he said, "King's last speech has a deep im- safeguarded.
A Springtime Mosale devised by port. Having declared that he de- Dictators do not understand. They
It is natural that we should begin may go so also may the journalist, "shall have effect as it
his this act." from statute Inw, opart
Kathleen M. MacLeod; 'Up the stairs are like harsh school teachers, so that
sired the people's freedom, he con- with the most precious of liberties,
of April and of May; The hot sun the children are afraid. They are not inued: their liberty and freedom is freedom of person and property. privilege is no other and no higher.
Administrative Lawlessness
elimbeth to the summer's noon. consist tn having of government Eut surely, a critic might say, at The responsibilities which attach to
ofi mothers to their people. And when
In plain English the meaning and Production by Howard Nose. children are afraid they tell lies to
those laws by which their life and least red the abolition of slavery, his power in the dissemination
7.05 Closing Local Stock Quota- avold punishment and they do things their goods shall be most their own. one's
personal berly Is ngured printed matter may, und in the case It is not having a shore in governin
country? Un- of a conscientious fournalist do, make effect of such legislation is to outst through tear and not through love.
7.07 A Programine of Eric Coales Inent, Sirs, that is nothing pertaining fortunately that Is not
Ithim more careful; but the range of the jurisdiction of the Courts and to tions.
Including
"Springtime And we must love those who rule
to them. A subject and a sovereign is commonplace nowadays
to read his assertions, his criticisms or his place what is departmentally done! us.
ure clear different things."
being comments 1s as wide as and no wider and decided beyond the reach of the music of the fathers of the sins
law. There are legal remedies de- Sulte. the than that of any other subject."
Springtime Suite; 1. Fresh Morning the children, and visited on
are honourable; sigried to correct and prevent Source of Freedom
Our journalists treatment of the Jews in Germany, Austria and Italy, not because they they are, like us, citizens who have usurpation of Jurisuletion or to com- (Pastorale); 2. Noonday Song (Ro- erline, but at heart' the best interests of their pel a duly which has been omitted marce); 3. Dance In The Twilight Essie Ackland (Contralto): For had committed any
Light country, but they are apt to be in- to be duly performed. Nothing cun (Valse); The Fairy Tales Of Ireland satiable in their search for news and betler inspire confidence and safeguard at times almost unscrupulous in the liberty than the knowledge that in Your DelightSerenade melheds-by-which they obtain it, case of need recourse can be had to Symphony Orchestra conducted, by Alfred Piccaver (Tenor) with Let us contrast the position wher
ed by law and itself subject to re-
"London necompaniment; ever the British flug flies. There no great Barons of the Fourth
Oxford Street; 2. wield a power that few if any others view,
Again" Suite; 1. person whether British subject
The knowledge that the machinery Langham Place....The London Pal- resident alien may be arrested save can aspire to control and it would be on a charge of a breach of the low unnatural if in a country like Ens exists and can be employed tends to adium Orchestra cond. by Richard Every person who has been arrested and, where freedom is the breath of have the effect of rendering is em- Crean: A House Love Made For You: a court every man's nostrils they and their ployment unnecessary, save only in And We.. Hubert Elsdell (Tenor) guaranteed
person, of inust be brought before
cannot by journalists were not subject to critic the exceptional ease.
with 'Cello, Oboe and Plano. speech and of the Press, though few without delay and he
7.40 Dance Music. solemn declarations can have been imprisoned unless that court has sism and good-natured satire.
The function of the British Navy ordered. The propriety of arrest or In England we know that the Bri-
Fox-Trois-My Walking Stick (film more cyniently disregarded.
any time betish Press is incorruptible. We huvel is not conflict: it's function is to make Alexander's Ragtime Band"); Now It In the thirteenth century all in Imprisonment can at
Can Be Told-Fox-Trot (lm 'Alex- poceedings by way of
and promotes I urge you strongly to be on your? racing for one day a year in Holland, England were not free: the feudal abeas corpus. Every trial in a Brit cause to be proud of our press which, contiel undesirable..
consistently preaches system was in full force and the
and His Orchestra with Tony Martin but betting is forbidden.
I asked if people bet among them- Barons who negotiated, the Charter Court is held publicly in open the true ideals of democracy, which guard nga lust such per loud ander's Ragtime Band"). Ray Noble YOUR LIPS 80% 201
and pervasive curtailment of your Überly. Vacat: Fox-Trots-Noia; Parade For your complete beauty treatment, is not with King John, would, in view of court and every man against whom is great enough to withstand
brought Is intore those temporary serious charge Is
of liberty shocks and The prie selves. "No," he sald, "t
eternal The Tin Soldiers....Rawicz and their feudal rights, have been the
Landauer (Plano Ducltista); Tangos last to demand from their King any entitled to the verdict of a jury of taclysms which bring governments vigliance.
Vieja Amiga: La Maleva.....Ö. existing rights his peers. Furthermore, if arbitrary
questa Tipica Francisco Canaro. men were and unjustified arrests are nisde the from their high estate; and which well right to deserves the title of the Fourth Estate
8.00 The true end of democracy is to
Time, Weather and responsible, of the Realm, in a country
unile the best qualities of everynouncements. not free, but they gained publie person arrested has recognition of their freedom, low damages against those
8.03 Jack Xylion and His Orches citizen in a national fellowship of all though the process was, not by virtuel and Juries are not slow to marke by liberty will always be supreme. Threatening Development of any statutory declaration, but by the award of heavy damages, their
Indignation at the
is our liberty at last secure so long and everywhere to hold aloft the ban- tra
Drinking Songs (arr. Williams); the law of the land, a law that was sense of
invastan of personal
as our present form of democratic ner of liberty and justice. Democracy established and pronounced by the warranted
government rubriste? One's first in- cannot tolerate an exclusiveness of "Anything Goes" Selection (Cole No Distinction
elination is to say 'yes' with thank it own. For centuries in England the Porter): The Ficet's In Port Again That French is the language of the judges and in some cases, by the liberty.
action of juries of their fellow sub- Court,
English Law knows no distinction fulness and without reservation, but citizens who were outside the Con-Fox-Trot (O-Kay for Sound); Free How there is no early closing day | jects,
and second thoughts are apt to make one stitution were doing battle to make Fox-Trot (O-Kay for Sound); Yours Truly Is Truly Yours--Fox-Trot.... between rich and poor. Jew in Holland, except for barbers.
The artisan and the maid-servant with Vocal Refrains. Can we then say that with the Gentile, official and unofficial. In the doubtful in view of a very recent but their way inside.
none the less threatening development.
8.30 London Relay At The Black accession of James I universal free eyes of the law each is free and the of recent years there has been a have now full share of public respon dom in England was gladly and cause he is free he is a responsible subtle but still a determined attempt sibility, but it is well to remember Dog'
Mr. Wilkes at home in his own bar- SUCH Wings he told me until we
freely recognized? Unfortunately citiz
citizen and
as such answerable to the!
than by the parlour. the aw of cannot. The reigas reached our destination, his only we
for way infringement of the to enable officials to determine mat- that responsibility is shared not more
the artlat 9.00 London Itelay-Empire Ex- other observation on the political Stuart Kings
in our are unique
of any of his fellow citizens. ters which by statute come to them for by the maid-servant rights "It takes two to island's troubled history. situation being! make a quarrel, my friend.
The Stuarts set up the diving right of Not even the highest official in the oficial decision. For two and a half marchioness, not less by
son to believe that they were free mocracy takes the form of represen- Dutchman, will quarrel with no one. Kings, their judges were weak and land can set up Act of State as his centuries our fathers had every rea- than by the artisan, And where de-change
Justifiention for an illegal net.
desire to arrive at a It is not good for business."
tine-serving and the great pro- Under the English system the test within the law and that if their liberty tative Institutions common fairness the Dominions and Colonies. Wu parted outside
Amsterdam clamations of Magna Curta
be infringed there was a Court pre-true conclusion make it imperative Station he to see his good wife be deliberately and repeatedly flouted is a uniform and simple one. Every of legal action appeared to them to and the
Discontent at the recurrent invasions mon is answerable to the law but sided over by an independent judge that every good citizen should be of liberty of person and of property no man is answerable to any other grew rapidly till in 1020 Charles I was authority and the complete Indepen- whose duty it was to investigate and ready and willing to hear both sides Democracy means telf-government compelled to asent to the Petition dence of the Judiclury and the use of adjudicate on the rights of the par- of the question fully argued.
Lord Justice Farwell, in my own through debate. There is no virtue of Right which provided in the main the jury system are sufflelent for ever that there should be no taxation to preserve our personal freedom,
of freedom of conscience I need days at the Bar in Londen, said, as in a man's listening with complacen- dially agrees. Toleration. begins only without consent of Parliament and Brief Meeting of The no legal imprisonment, however say little. The Toleration Act of he was justided in saying, that "the Cy to oplaton with which he cor-
was determined to go down with his 1680 established the great principle, Courts are the only defence of when he listens with patience to The Washington Post; Semper Fide Urban Council flags flying. Next year, 1829, he dis- and its extension by the Acts of 1812 liberty of the subject against depart opinions from which he profoundly is; Hungarian March; Rodeo Parade; solved Parliament and with the help and 1856 means that throughout the mental aggression." Only a year a dissents. But we must remember alto London Scottish, hot Face application for a of his two ministers Strafford and British Commonwealth of Nations two nites that date began the in that free-government does not mean well; Popular Melodica, No. 3; Intro: allous process of legislating in government of each individual Pennies from Heaven; In the Chapel only one item, an agenda at the fud, he embarked on the fatal de- every person is free to hold the re-skeleton form including in the statute himself but government of each in- the foonlight, Another perfect meeting of the Urban Council, hell in cade of government by prerugsilve ligious belief that his conslecnce die-side rule mking powers to Minis-dividual by all the rest. Above all,
bad to Lates, to practice Building yesterday. alone. Things went from
sport to take money from a friend." He told me many things as down came and disclosed that fat country- side, rainswept and grey.
How there are 200,000 bicycles in Amsterdam alone, each taxed
three guider a year.
That you have to tip team co- ductors in Amsterdam, but not taxi- drivers.
fore going to his business, I to try to discover the pulse of the people.
LICENCE REFUSED
restriction of their over their villeins. Al
Troubled History
The
were
un-
Lics.
where
is
National Fellowship
+
An-
Points of view by travellers from 9.15 London Relay Tho News. 9.30 Piano Selections. Valse In E Major, Op. 34 (Mork- No. 3 In C Sharp Minor, Op. 38 kewski)...Arthur De Grect; Scherzo (Chopin)....Mischa Levilzki,
9.45 London Relay-Sports News 9.50 Harold Ramsay at the Organ. and Market Nates.
Famous Marches Medley; Intro:
The appileation was for a food pre- worse til they came to a head in the as he does not therehe so long for and then adding a wicked provision remember that the ideal of liberty night is ending.
refused.
Mr. I. I. Todd, Chm,man, presided at the meeting.
The following is a list of licences
occasion n
10.00 London Relay The Fol-De-
In
a Song-and Laugh Show Light-
the Post Office
and to express ousting the control of the Courts, not merely that men shall be free but Spring famous case of the King v. Hampden, breach of the peace, serving licence for No, 15
so long as his That provision takes as many forms also that they shall be willing and Garden Lane, third floor, and it was better known perhaps as the case of that belief publicly
Ship Money, in 1637. On the trial expression is not binsphemous. No as the devil can quote scripture for enter for others to be free.
In the words of a great American heartedly designed for all korts and We read for instance some of the Judges preferred their person under the Union Jack is sub-his own cade. duly to the law to their allegianco ject to any disabilities, nor can he that the Minister's approval of action statesman and lawyer "Not what alers of listene with a Smile and in purporting to be taken under certain nation does for itself but what a Song for the High Brow the Low Greatrex Newman. to the King, who secured judgment be made to suffer in person by a majority of only seven to live. granted by the Urban Council be-
that the requirements of this net have to honour and glory. In God's good presented by belief.
that "the world the way to scale the heights of Music by Wolseley tween March 28 and April 10, this That was the last stew on the back property, by reason of his religious rules shall be conclusive evidence nation does for humanity in its title Brow, and the No Brow, Written and
been complied with--0 Freedom of Speech
order has been made and lo within prosperity and happiness is not to B.B.C. Variety Orchestra conducted pull others down and climb up over by Charl's Shadwell; Produced by and! I come now to the most interesting the powers of this act." 1040 passed n statute vacating
de-as it is one of the most valuable of] Others, ever less politely, do not them but to help all up together to Harry S. Pepper. cancelling the judgment and cturing all the proceedings contrary Jour liberties-freedom of speech, mince words but provide that a de- united success." (Appliuse).
year!
Food factories (1); Food shops (1); Swine (2): Offensive Trodes (2): Eating houses (3); Restaurants (1) Total: 10.
of a long-suffering pubile. The great! and in Long Parliament assembled
or
11.00 Close Down.
Charles,
use Tattoo Powder, Rouge and Mascara (Cream with brush) Sole Distributor: Auw Plt Seng's Trading Co., Ltd., Hongkong.
One drop on
ACHING CORNS
reliovos pain in three seconds! Apply Gets It two or three times and the corn will peel right off. Millions, all over the world, use this faithful friend of corn-sufferers-
GETS-IT
METROPOLE
The
VALE
ROOM BATH
FROM
$6
CENTRAL) 21
CLEAN.
UP
COMFORTABLE
मे
No comments yet.
Private notes are available after approval.