Sessional_Paper_1896 — Page 760

Sessional Papers 議政定例兩局文件 All

(6)

-How do the English prisoners bear the flogging? Suppose you gave a sturdy Englishman thirty-six strokes with the "cat," what effect would it leave in a case of that kind ?

A-I have known men receive thirty-six strokes and not speak, and I have known other men shout before receiving a stroke.

Q-I am speaking of the effects upon the body?

A-I have seen the effects; the flogging leaves marks on the body.

Q-What is the effect of the rattan?

A-In some cases it bruises and in others it cuts through.

Q-Have you ever seen a "cat" cut through the flesh?

A-Yes.

Q-And leave bruises?

A-After the flesh has healed it leaves scars.

Q-What is the difference between the effects of the "cat" and the effects of the

rattan?

A-In what way?

Q-As to the wounds or marks that are left.

A-One is broader, the rattan is much broader.

Q-And the flesh cut in both cases?

A-In some cases the rattan does not cut.

Q.-According to the severity of the punishment?

A-Yes.

Q-What is done in English prisons after prisoners have been flogged?

A-They are admitted to the hospital, sometimes.

Q-In the same way as is done here?

A-No; they are not taken to the hospital here.

Q-Not always ?

A-No.

Q-Is the practice at home to always admit them to the hospital even if they receive only six strokes ?

A--They never receive so little. They are sent to separate cells and kept there under treatment. It is equivalent to the hospital.

Q--If they have been severely mauled ?

A-Then they are admitted to the hospital.

Q-As the surgeon directs ?

A-Yes.

Q-Is a certificate necessary before the punishment is inflicted ?

A-He is certified as fit to be whipped before sentence is passed and again immediately before receiving the whipping.

Q-Then in your opinion the Chinaman stands the rattan a great deal worse than the Britisher stands the cat-o'-nine-tails? That is your opinion?

A-That is my opinion.

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.