TNAG-2694-FCO40-3900-Hong-Kong-Judiciary-and-judicial-appointments-1993 — Page 46

FCO40 Hong Kong Department Records 聯邦事務部香港部檔案 All

workings.

All its functions are governed by independence which must

therefore be fully taken into account in a discussion about the

structure of the judiciary and the distribution of functions.

15.

Plainly, a judge performing judicial work must not be under

or susceptible to pressure by the Executive, the Legislature or anyone

else. The more this principle is seen to apply the more the reality of

independence comes home. For that reason it is particularly important

to be meticulcus in classification and definition. If independence is

to be fully understood it must be seen to apply to every judicial

officer. I therefore recommend that in official lists of public

servants all judicial officers from Chief Justice to Special Magistrate

should be segregated from all other public servants and classified as

one homogeneous group.

For this purpose the varying terms and

conditions of appointment make no difference. A judge is a judge

whatever the period of his appointment.

16.

For the same reason I recommend that the pay and other terms

2nd conditions of service of judicial officers be looked at quite

separately from those of other public servants. The community should

be left in no doubt about this and should be made aware that a special

status of independence is accorded to all whose work is judicial

whether in the Supreme Court, the District Court, Tribunals,

Magistracies or the Coroner's Court.

17.

to

This attitude will enhance the Judiciary's corporate sense

and develop its tradition.

These are important

judicial

administration and thence to efficiency. The capacity to attract able

recruits from the legal profession is of such importance that it should

not be hampered by the preservation of relativity with pay scales in

the civil service. It would be salutary to demonstrate that all

judicial officers are in a special and distinct class which is looked

at in isolation for the purposes of pay as well as function.

- 25

!

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.