TNAG-2387-FCO40-3469-Extradition-from-the-UK-to-Hong-Kong-case-of-Lorrain-Esme-Os-1991 — Page 11

NADAN 4075

COLE

DOF COLLY

до киким

FN HOKON TO FCOLN

2010JOZ DEC

GPS 750

7 1

SEXT

1325

CONFIDENTIAL

FM HONG KONG

TO IMMEDIATE FCO

TELNO 2874 10,00am

OF 2010OOZ DECEMBER 85

FAF 102

INFO IMMEDIATE KUALA LUMPUR

· 6 JAN 1986

PA

38

SEE(6

ADVANCE CO

горый

HD

serti)

HD/ SEAT7)

HD/HKD)

Ma Wilso

IMMEDIATE

مضان

fokan

759

KUALA LUMPUR TELNO 597 AND YOUP TELNG 521

1. THE CONVERSATION BETWEEN ABU TALIE AND PEID OF THE HONG KONG TEAM REFERRED TO IN PARAGRAPH 3 OF THE FIRST TUP ORIGINATED IN A SUGGESTION BY ABU TALIB THAT IT WOULD ASSIST HONG KONG IF OSMAN AND SHAMSUDDIN COULD BE DEPORTED TO MALAYSIA BECAUSE IT WOULD BE EASIER FOR THE HONG KONG GOVERNMENT TO OBTAIN ORDER FOR EXTRADITION FROM THE MALAYSIAN COURTS THAN IT WOULD BE FOR THEM TO OBTAIN ORDERS FOR EXTRADITION FROM THE UK COURT. REID SAID THAT WE WOULD REFLECT ON THIS IDEA AND REVERT.

?

2. ON REFLECTION, WE PROPOSE TO TURN DOWN THE SUGGESTION PARTLY BECAUSE WE BELIEVE IT IS NOT A FEASI LE COUPSE HI LAW AND PARTLY SECAUSE WE JUDGE THAT ONCE RETURNED TO "ALAYSIA IT IS NOT LIKELY THAT OSMAN AND SHANSUET IN MOULT TE RETURNED TO HONG KONG FOR TRIAL. SO FAR AS FEASIBILITY IS CONCERNED, HE HAVE CONSULTED LONDON COUNSEL AND WITHOUT ANY DETAILED RESE/SCH, IT APPEARS THAT:

(A) THERE WAY DE NO CPOUNDS FOR DEPORTATION OF SHANSUDDIN EVEN IF THE "ALAYSIANS WERE TO PEVOKE HIS PASSPORT:

(B) EVEN IF OSMAN HERE LIABLE TO DEPCETATION, THEPE MUST DE STEPS HE COULD TAKE BY WAY OF WADCAS CORPUS OF APPEAL TO PREVENT HIS REPORTATION:

(C) THERE MY WELL OF POACTICAL DIFFICULTIES IN ENSURING THAT OSMANAND SHAM SUDDIN RETURN TO KUALA LUMPUR IF EXPELLED FROM THE UK:

EXHIBIT I

+Ne

J