TNAG-2219-FCO40-3187-Constitutional-development-in-Hong-Kong-Letters-Patent-and-R-1991 — Page 47

FCO40 Hong Kong Department Records 聯邦事務部香港部檔案 All

15-MAY-1991 16:23

DIRECTOR OF ADM.

852 877 0802

P.36

34

The Governor did not divest ni...selt

ΟΙ

his miticle

+

XIV powers at present regulated by s.(1) of the agistrates

Justice. Ordinance my delegating them to the Chier

de may

continue to exercise those powers as he thinks fit; and when the delegate exercises them they are, in terms of s.ċ3 (1) of Cap. 1, exercised on the Governor's Dendlí.

1

Service

to be noted that a

provision on almost

Identical lines to s.15 (ai appears as s.15 ci the Public

Commission urainence, Cap. 93. There is a Saving of

broadly similar kind in 5.29 of the Royal Hong Kong Muxiliary Police Force ordinance, Cap. 233. There is also

saving cr tuese lines 10 s.je of the Police Force Ordinance,

which allows, t s.14, persons to be appointed to certain

the Commissioner.

I think the Sare

leydi consequences follow from these differences. it 15

nelprul to recall what Loru Farmoor Selc in the ve Keyser

Koyal

ranks

The force

atter

there

At 376:

1 an further of opinion that nere â

nas Jeen directly regulated by statute > S a necessary implication that the statutory regulation must De opeyed, and that as far as such reyulation is inconsistent itn the claim of a Royal Prerogative riynt, such Sight can no longer be enforce)

There can De no "necessary implication:

Flynt 15 Expressly leserved.

..

..nen the prerojative

Speaking for myself, i see every advantaye in

continuing to use the machinery of the JSC when magistrates' appointments are under consideration, despite the fact that

the Chief Justice is the

the appointing authority while the Jelegation, remains

It may

rorce.

be thought that tne present situation is

untidy and could usefully we reviewed, out i am not persuaued that it renders the Governor's celegation to the Chief Justice of his power to appoint magistrates either

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.