CONFIDENTIAL
HKD 24318
18243/8
273
124101
MDLOAN 1808
TOP COPY
DIST ?
CONFIDENTIAL
FM FCO
TO ROUTINE HONG KONG
TELNO 1502
OF 091545Z JUNE 88
INFO ROUTINE HANOI
CORRECTED VERSION
179
YOUR TELNO 1894 AND 2142: REPATRIATION TO VIETNAM:
1.
ISSUES WHICH ARISE
WE HAVE CAREFULLY CONSIDERED THE VARIOUS FROM THIS CASE. IN ESSENCE OUR CONCLUSIONS ARE: (A) WE SEE NO REASON IN PRINCIPLE WHY BOAT PEOPLE WHO ARRIVE IN
HONG KONG AGAINST THEIR WILL AND WHO FREELY WISH TO RETURN TO VIETNAM SHOULD NOT BE SENT BACK THROUGH DIPLOMATIC CHANNELS WITHOUT REFERENCE TO UNHCR
LIKE HANOI (THEIR TELNO 23) WE SEE SOME PRACTICAL ADVANTAGES IN INVOLVING UNHCR IN SUCH CASES, BUT NOT OVERRIDING ONES.
(B)
(C)
·
IN THE EVENT OF A CHANGE OF MIND BY THOSE CONCERNED DIFFERENT ISSUES WOULD ARISE. OUR OPINION IS THAT FROM THE STRICTLY LEGAL POINT OF VIEW IT WOULD PROBABLY BE ACCEPTABLE TO REPATRIATE SUCH CASES AGAINST THEIR WILL. GIVEN THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THE ARRIVAL OF SUCH CASES IN HONG KONG IT IS DIFFICULT TO SEE HOW THEY COULD MEET THE UNHCR CRITERIA FOR REFUGEES. IT IS ALSO CLEAR THAT THEY WOULD HAVE NO
RIGHTS UNDER HONG KONG LAW TO REMAIN IN HONG KONG. ACCORDING TO THE GENERALLY ACCEPTED RULES RELATING TO DEPORTATION, A FOREIGN NATIONAL MAY BE RETURNED TO HIS OWN COUNTRY PROVIDED (A) THAT HE HAS BEEN GIVEN A REASONABLE OPOPRTUNITY TO OBTAIN PERMISSION TO ENTER A THIRD COUNTRY IF HE WISHES AND (B) THAT THERE IS NO REASON TO BELIEVE THAT HE WOULD BE ILL TREATED ON HIS RETURN. HOWEVER, IN SUCH CASES OF INVOLUNTARY REPATRIATION WE DOUBT WHETHER UNHCR WOULD BE
WILLING TO CO-OPERATE.
QUITE APART FROM THE LEGAL TECHNICALITIES WE HAVE DOUBTS ON POLICY GROUNDS ABOUT THE WISDOM OF THE REPATRIATION OF INVOLUNTARY CASES, WHATEVER THE CIRCUMSTANCES OF THEIR ARRIVAL AND SUBSEQUENT CHANGE OF HEART. THE DISTINCTION BETWEEN SUCH CASES AND THE STANDARD ECONOMIC MIGRANT CASES IS NOT CLEAR CUT. GIVEN THE SENSITIVITIES ABOUT INVOLUNTARY REPATRIATION AND THE IMPORTANCE WE ATTACH TO GUARANTEES OF
PAGE
1
CONFIDENTIAL
THIS IS A COPY THE ORIGINAL HAS BEEN
CLOSED UNDER
FOI EXEMPTION NO..... 40 (2)
No comments yet.
Private notes are available after approval.