TNAG-1585-FCO40-2159-Hong-Kong-prisons-and-prisoners-1986 — Page 29

9787/82

:

10

}

INTRODUCTION (paras. 1-12)

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Page

PAN M

1

1

2

3

Substance of the application (paras. 2-7) Proceedings before the Commission (paras. 8-12) The present Report (paras. 13-17)

ESTABLISHMENT OF THE FACTS (paras. 18-36)

Relevant Domestic law and practice (paras. 19-22) The particular facts of the case (paras. 23-36)

SUBMISSIONS OF THE PARTIES (paras. 37-57)

The applicant (paras.37-47) Article 5(1)(a) (paras. 37-42) Article 5(4) (paras. 43-46) Periodic review (para. 47)

The Government (paras. 48-57) Article 5(1)(e) (paras. 48-50) Article 5(4) (paras. 51-56)

Periodic review (para. 57)

346

10

10

12

13

13

13

14

16

OPINION OF THE COMMISSION (paras. 58-107)

16

Points at Issue (para. 58)

16

As regards Article 5(1) (paras. 59-62)

16

Relevant principles in the present case (paras. 63-74)

17

Application of principles to the facts

of the case (paras. 75-79)

19

Conclusion (para. 80)

19

As regards Article 5(4) (paras. 81-93)

20

Application for Habeas Corpus (paras. 94-97)

24

Judicial review in respect of the Home Secretary and the Parole Board (paras. 98-105)

25

Conclusion (para. 106)

26

Summary of the Commission's conclusions (para. 107)

26

Partially Dissenting opinion of Mr. Danelius joined by MM. Nørgaard, Jörundsson and Kiernan

APPENDIX I: History of Proceedings

APPENDIX II: Decision of the Commission

28

30

32