TNAG-1439-FCO40-1923-Constitutional-development-in-Hong-Kong-1986 — Page 154

FCO40 Hong Kong Department Records 聯邦事務部香港部檔案 All

Whom?

WAY FOR THEM. THE MAIN ARGUMENT FOR THE DISTRICT BOARD-ELECTORAL COLLEGE MEMBERS WAS TO PRODUCE A REASONABLY BALANCED GEOGRAPHICAL DISTRIBUTION OF MEMBERS. THE MEDIA AND PUBLIC OPINION HAVE NOTED THAT THE MARCH 1986 URBAN COUNCIL AND REGIONAL COUNCIL ELECTIONS PRODUCED BROADLY SIMILAR MEMBERS TO THOSE PRODUCED BY THE ELECTORAL COLLEGES, THATS LARGELY SOCIAL WORKERS AND EDUCATIONALISTS. A BASIC DIMENSION OF THIS PROBLEM IS ARITHMETICAL: SHORT OF CONSIDERABLE ALTERATION OF THE DISTRICT BOARD ELECTORAL COLLEGE BOUNDARIES, THE CHOICE US TO HAVE THE PRESENT TEN SEATS, OR NONE AT ALL SEMICOLON AND THE LATTER CHOICE WOULD MEAN ABOLISHING A TYPE OF REPRESENTATION ONLY INTRODUCED N

1985 WHICH MAY SEEM DRAMATIC AND UNSETTLING.

20. THESE POSSIBLE OPTIONS APPEAR IN TABULAR FORM AS FOLLOWS:

COMPONENT

1985

PRESENT POSITION

(A)

1988

(B) (C) (D)

FUNCTIONAL

12

16

16

16

16

OFFICIAL

10

14

14

14

14

ELECTORAL COLLEGES

12

12

12

12

2

APPOINTED

22

22

22

12

22

DIRECTLY ELECTED

0

10

10

10

56

64

74

64

64

(A) NO DIRECTLY ELECTED MEMBERS ADDED SEMICOLON

(B) 10 DIRECTLY ELECTED MEMBERS ADDED SEMICOLON NO REDUCTIONS

SEMICOLON

(C) 10 DIRECTLY ELECTED MEMBERS ADDED SEMICOLON APPOINTED MEMBERS

REDUCED BY 10 SEMICOLON

(D) 10 DIRECTLY ELECTED MEMBERS ADDED SEMICOLON ELECTORAL COLLEGE

MEMBERS REDUCED BY 10 SEMICOLON

(IN ALL OPTIONS FOR 1988, FOUR FUNCTIONAL AND FOUR OFFICIAL MEMBERS

ARE ADDED BY WAY OF ILLUSTRATION.}

21. THERE WILL BE GREAT INTEREST IN THE DELINEATION OF CONSTITUENCIES

AND THE QUALIFICATIONS REQUIRED OF CANDIDATES, IF DIRECT ELECTIONS ARE INTRODUCED.

22. ON THE BASIS OF THE ABOVE ASSESSMENT OF OPINION AS IT STANDS

TODAY NO OPTIONS ARE LIKELY TO BE PUT FORWARD FOR CONSIDERATION

IN THE 1987 REVIEW IN REGARD TO:

(A) THE POSITION OF THE GOVERNOR, EXCEPT AS PRESIDENT OF THE

LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL SEMICOLON OR

(B) THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE EXECUTIVE AND LEGISLATIVE COUNCILS.

23. AMONG THE OPTIONS WHICH WILL BE FOR CONSIDERATION IN THE

REVIEW ARE:

(A) WHETHER THE 1988 ELECTIONS SHOULD BE CONDUCTED ON THE SAME

BASIS AS THE 1985 ELECTIONS WITH NO CHANGE SEMICOLON OR

Secret

(B)

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.