TNAG-1418-FCO40-1901-Hong-Kong-Parliamentary-Sub-Committee-on-Race-Relations-and--1985 — Page 170

FCO40 Hong Kong Department Records 聯邦事務部香港部檔案 All

RADIO: THE PAPERS TODAY FOLLOWED UP YESTERDAY'S RTHK'S 'THIS WEEK''

COVERAGE OF THE SCORRI REPORT WITH INTERVIEWS WITH LEGCO UNOFFICIAL

ALLEN LEE WHO SAID HE WAS CONCERNED THAT HK MIGHT BE LEFT WITH

SEVERAL THOUSAND VR ''REJECTS' AND THAT HK WOULD HAVE TO FACE THE

REALITY OF ACCEPTING THEM. (MR LEE'S INTERVIEW AFTER THE POLYTECHNIC

CEREMONY WAS ALSO CARRIED BY ALL ELECTRONIC MEDIA). KARL STUMPF

CRITICISED THE MPS WHO COMPILED THE REPORT BY SAYING THAT THEY DIDN'T

REALLY HAVE ADEQUATE AND DETAILED KNOWLEDGE ABOUT THE PARTICULAR

SITUATION IN HK AND THEY SHOULD NOT HAVE GIVEN ANY ADVICE BEFORE

THEY WERE MUCH MORE ACQUAINTED (WITH THE SITUATION). HE SAID THE

UK WAS IN A BETTER POSITION TO HAVE A PROCESSING CAMP FOR VRS THAN

OVERCROWDED HK. MEMBER OF THE PARLIAMENTARY COMMITTEE WHICH COMPILED

THE REPORT JEREMY HANLEY SAID THE COMMITTEE HOPED THAT THE UK, B

RELAXING ITS FAMILY REUNION CRITERIA, COULD TAKE IN ABOUT 500

ADDITIONAL REFUGEES FROM HK. AND THE CHAIRMAN OF THE ASIAN COMMITTEE

OF THE BRITISH REFUGEE COUNCIL, LORD ENNALS SAID THE REPORT SHOWED

THAT WE REALLY HAVE A LEVER IN OUR HAND TO PRESS THE GOVERNMENT

TO TAKE ACTION, '' ADDING THAT THE BRITISH GOVERNMENT HAD BEEN DELIGHTED TO DELAY A DECISION UNTIL THE REPORT, WHICH HAD CHALLENGED

MANY OF THE POSITIONS OF THE HOME OFFICE, WAS PUBLISHED.

PRESS COMMENTARIS

SING PAO, ON APRIL 21, SAID IT WAS GLAD THAT LEGCO UNOFFICIALS HAD

COURAGEOUSLY REFUTED THE REPORT'S RECOMMENDATIONS TO ABOLISH

CLOSED CAMPS HERE AND TO ASK THE HK GOVERNMENT TO OFFER SETTLEMENT

TO VRS OF CHINESE ORIGIN. THE FACT THAT THE UNOFFICIALS WERE BOLD

ENOUGH TO SPEAK AGAINST THE REPORT AT A TIME WHEN HK WAS STILL

UNDER BRITISH RULE SHOWED THAT HK ENJOYED A HIGH DEGREE OF FREEDOM

OF SPEECH. IT MAINTAINED THAT THE CLOSED CAMP POLICY FOR REFUGEES

WAS THE MOST HUMANE TREATMENT WE COULD OFFER. IT ASKED IF THE HK

GOVERNMENT SHOULD BE CRITICISED FOR IGNORING HUMANITARIANISM WHEN

IT HAD BEEN TRYING ITS BEST TO ARRANGE OVERSEAS RESETTLEMENT FOR

REFUGEES IN CLOSED CAMPS WHILE, AT THE SAME TIME, ILLEGAL IMMIGRANTS

FROM CHINA WERE ARRESTED AND IMMEDIATELY REPATRIATED EVEN THOUGH

THEIR NEXT OF KIN WERE LONG-TIME HK RESIDENTS? MOREOVER, IN VIEW

OF HK'S SMALL AREA AND HIGH POPULATION, SHOULD IT KEEP ITS DOORS

WIDE OPEN TO ALL THOSE WHO FLED THEIR COUNTRIES?

YIK CHUN OF THE PRO-CHINA TIN TIN DAILY NEWS, ON APRIL 22, WAS ALSO

CRITICAL OF THE RECOMMENDATIONS AND SAID BRITAIN HAD BEEN PAYING

ONLY LIP SERVICE TO THE PLIGHT OF THE REFUGEES, BUT HAD FAILED TO

TAKE CONCRETE ACTION IN ACCEPTING MORE REFUGEES FROM HK. IF BRITAIN

WAS REALLY SERIOUS ABOUT HUMANITARIANISM, IT SHOULD ACCEPT ALL THE

VRS NOW STAYING IN CLOSED CAMPS IN HK.

-3-RESTRICTED

/ THE

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.