TNAG-1157-FCO40-1437-Visits-by-FCO-Ministers-to-Hong-Kong-1982 — Page 89

CONFIDENTIAL

LORD BELSTEAD'S VISIT TO HONG KONG : 6 TO 10 DECEMBER 1982

BRIEF NO.6: VIETNAMESE REFUGEES

POINTS TO MAKE (Defensive)

1.

Impressed by standards Hong Kong maintains, especially in closed camps.

Aware of the dilemma of "humane deterrence" and

sympathise with the difficulties this causes.

2. Understand now some evidence that news of closed camps is spreading in Vietnam. Was lower figure for arrivals in

September/October a sign of this?

3. Anxious to do what we can for Hong Kong.

But difficult to

consider a further UK quota in present circumstances.

4. But we are looking with the Home Office to see if we can do

anything further, eg on ship rescues, unaccompanied minors, and

extended family reunion criteria.

CLOSED CAMPS

-

HUMAN RIGHTS IMPLICATIONS

[For use with officials]

5. We appreciate Hong Kong's position, and the reasons for introducing the policy, but we remain very concerned at the

human rights implications of the closed camps. Hope that you can make suitable amendments to your legislation. In the meantime we put great value in continued close cooperation with

UNHCR. Hope complaints such as Tai Tam will not be too

frequent.

6. [For use with Unofficials and Press if required. Defensive] We are studying, together with the Hong Kong Government, the human rights implications of the closed camp policy. [If

pressed] This relates to the various international conventions

on human rights that HMG have signed and that have been extended

to Hong Kong.

CONFIDENTIAL