Annex 4-2 to XCCI ??
Letter from the Honourable Nicholas Ridley, MP
to Mr. K. Marks, MP
"Thank you for your letter of 8 December to Peter Carrington about capital punishment in the Dependent Territories.
I have been asked to reply.
It may be helpful if I amplify the information contained in Peter Blaker's reply to your question on 29 October, and in
Norman St John Stevas's reply on 11 December.
First, the power to exercise the prerogative of mercy in
capital cases is constitutionally delegated to Governors by the
Crown: it has always formed part of their duties and is not a new
departure. The Governor is also under oath to uphold the laws of
As you know, the seven territories which retain
the terrotory.
capital punishment have voted to do so.
Second, the fact that the death penalty for murder has
been abolished in the UK is irrelevant in terms of the Dependent Territories who make laws to cover their own special circumstances.
As the Leader of the House explained on 11 December, Her Majesty's
residual prerogative of mercy is exercised very rarely in special circumstances: to exercise it automatically in every case where the
local decision is to let the law take its course, because of the
decision of the UK Parliament, would be unconstitutional.
Abolition of capital punishment for murder in the territories concerned can be brought about only by a change in the law of those territories and their Government and legislatures are not willing at present to make such a change.
There are currently two appeals against sentence pending in the British Virgin Islands and Belize respectively the accused in the Turks and Caicos Islands pleaded guilty to manslaughter and was sentenced to 10 years imprisonment."
No comments yet.
Private notes are available after approval.