TNAG-0931-FCO40-1149-Capital-punishment-in-the-Dependent-Territories-1980 — Page 132

C

CONFIDENTIAL

-2-

<d

STAFF IN CONFIDENCE

5. Mr Davidson, the Governor of the British Virgin Islands, is

concerned over his responsibility in deciding on the death penalty.

Mr Davidson himself is opposed to capital punishment and would like

to commute. He also points out that there is an anomaly between the

non-use of capital punishment by the metropolitan power and its

retention in a number of very small dependencies; he regards it as

unreasonable that Governors should be required to take decisions

previously exercised in the United Kingdom by a Cabinet Minister.

At the same time he recognises that the British Virgin Islanders

generally favour the death penalty. There were strong protests in

1978 when Mr Davidson's predecessor commuted a sentence.

Moreover,

one of the current British Virgin Islands cases concerns two men

from outside the Islands against whom the locals are likely to feel

particularly strongly.

6. Mr Davidson called on Mr Ridley on 8 September. The discussion

was not recorded in detail but Mr Deare's minute of 10 September

reports Mr Ridley's direction that the subject should be aired among

FCO Ministers and that Cabinet colleagues should be made aware of the

problems likely to arise over individual cases.

Argument

7. The points raised by Mr Davidson do not alter the basis on which

Ministers took their decision earlier this year. There is some force

in the argument that territories with populations as small as an

English provincial town should not retain a say on so fundamental

a question. But this comes up against the main argument that the

relationship between the centre and dependencies is based on their

CONFIDENTIAL

STAFF IN CONFIDENCE

/internal