SECRET
18. An analysis of the Hong Kong Government's performance since the war and of its future plans for economic, social and political development as viewed from the FCO is given in Annex C. This section of the paper attempts on this basis to outline the prospects for further development over the next decade. The Hong Kong administration have made significant progress and have successfully overcome major obstacles eg the massive inflow of refugees from China. The proposals for further progress mentioned in Annex C are not new and many of them have in the past been rejected by the colonial Government in the light of their appreciation of local conditions. But in the discharge of our constitutional responsibilities for the welfare of the inhabitants of
Hong Kong, there does seem to be much scope for eg fiscal reform; the acceleration of existing social programmes; legislation to ameliorate working conditions; and the introduction of social security provisions at least up to the best that are provided by Hong Kong's Asian neighbours. It is common ground between Whitehall and the Colonial Government that social progress must continue; and it is appropriate to try to establish a detailed programme showing what progress can be made over the next decade bearing in mind the pressures on both sides. Annex C is, therefore, a first step in this process, but it follows that ultimate agreement on the rate of social progress will depend on agreement on fiscal policy, where at present there appears to be considerable divergence of view. From London there appears to be no prima facie reason why the ratio of public expenditure to GDP could not rise to at least 25% to be financed partly if not mainly by direct taxation associated with an expansion of the tax base, whatever conclusion the Hong Kong Government reach following the current
technical review of the Inland Revenue Ordinance. The Governor believes
that public expenditure can safely rise to 22% of GNP but the Financial Secretary in his recent budget speech, indicated that an average of 20% should continue to be the maximum for the foreseeable
future
19. The overall conclusion is that, if the present momentum of economic growth is to be maintained with the necessary underpinning of public expenditure to make Hong Kong an acceptable urban and industrial environment the Colonial Government will require the active and evident support of senior members of the Administration and of the Unofficial members of the Executive and Legislative Councils. There seems little practical possibility of employing HMG's constitutional powers (see
/paragraph
11
SECRET
Page 105Page 106
No comments yet.
Private notes are available after approval.