TNAG-0500-FCO40-565-Appointments-of-puisne-judges-in-Hong-Kong-1974 — Page 41

FCO40 Hong Kong Department Records 聯邦事務部香港部檔案 All

Reference.....

CONFIDENTIAL

10. Then I think we should telegraph to the Governor saying that, while we accept his assessment that Mr Pickering is a suitable person to be Senior Puisne Judge, we should be glad to know if there is anything as respects Mr Huggins that would make the latter a less suitable person. We might also refer to the letter about the post of Senior Puisne Judge mentioned in my paragraph 4 above and ask if any thought has been given to the abolition of the post e.g. on the creation of posts of Justices of Appeal.

11.

J

Turning now to the other vacancy, my impression of Mr Baber is that he is one of the duller members of the District Court I think we had better look at his confidential reports, and those of Mr Yang (if available), Mr W S Collier, Mr R O'Connor and Mr F Addison.

12.

I am sending this file first to Mr Ensor at the ODA for paragraph 9 above. Perhaps he would then pass it to Mr Greenwood before it goes to Mr Stuart.

A.R.R.

A R Rushford

Deputy Legal Adviser

18 January 1974

See and Ensors minute on RC 204/77/02 attached.

orer

I also feal don't about passing The Huggins. Though Mr Pickerings reports Mr Huggins are

much longer period.

are good

Lund over

mittuskind

is

much better

Mr Pickering is 58.1 15 32 and has been on the bruch for 9 years.

As between The Pickering + Mr McMullin I think there is Cattle in it. Mr. McMullin

is

a

Senior

year

asports

lix E

batter!

But Mr Pickering's Perhaps mus Pickering

my

Just has it over Mr McMullin

more suitable

Y

I do not understand why the Gormir Considers Thy Pickering than Mr Huggins. Age is the only

CONFIDENTIAL

вер

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.