TNAG-0423-FCO40-469-Construction-of-an-underground-railway-system-in-Hong-Kong-1973 — Page 103

FCO40 Hong Kong Department Records 聯邦事務部香港部檔案 All

PRIORITY

CYPHER/CAT A

GPS WO

FM HONG KONG 080855Z

RESTRICTED

RESTRICTED

IN

128

-1

R

TOP LOPT

1~ICK 21/4

TO PRIORITY E.C.G.D. TELNO EXCED 30 OF 8 JUNE, 1973 AND TO DTI (FOR GLAVES-SMITH (OPG) AND FCO FOR STUART (HKIOD).

FOR COTTERILL FROM ASTON.

1. YOUR TRAVEL PLANS IN COGGIN'S EXCED 27 NOTED. YOU SHOULD HOWEVER

BE AWARE THAT CODD WHO IS HERE AT PRESENT AS CARRIER OF THE BRITISH

GROUPS PROPOSAL WILL ON RETURN EARLY NEXT WEEK RECOMMEND THAT BRITISH GROUP ASSEMBLE IN HONG KONG ON 25/26 JUNE IN TIME TO OVERCOME JET LAG AND BE ABLE TO DEVOTE WHOLE OF 27 JUNE TO GROUP

DISCUSSIONS.

2. REASONS FOR THIS RECOMMENDATION, AGREED BY LEVER, WEEDON AND MYSELF ARE :-

A)

3.

B)

BRITISH PROPOSAL WILL NEED MOST CAREFUL PRESENTATION IN VIEW

OF THE SHARP INCREASE IN COSTS COMPARED WITH THE CONSULTANTS

ESTIMATE

IT IS ALSO BEING RECOMMENDED THAT THERE SHOULD BE A LEADER OF

THE BRITISH GROUP TO CONDUCT THE DISCUSSIONS WITH SUPPORT FROM TECHNICIANS AS NECESSARY (CODD WILL ELABORATE ON LOGIC OF THIS

BUT FELL WILL BE AWARE OF THE NEED FROM PREVIOUSL EXPER- IENCE AND SUBSEQUENT CORRESPONDENCE). THE LEADER WILL NEED UP

DATED BRIEFING IN LIGHT OF LOCAL DEVELOPMENTS.

POINT ABOUT (A) IS THAT WE NEED TO TAKE ACCOUNT OF ALL WE CAN

DISCOVER UP TO LAST MINUTE ABOUT WHAT COMPETITIROS HAVE PROPOSED AND,

IF THIS SEEMS LESS THAN BRITISH PRICE, PREPARE ARGUMENTS TO SHOW

THAT THEIR BIDS ARE NOT REALISTIC OR NOT SUCH GOOD VALUE FOR

MONEY. IT IT SEEMS COMPETITORS ARE IN SAME BRACKET IT WILL BE

NECESSARY TO RUB HOME THE POINT THAT FRAGMENTED CONTRACT BIDS

WOULD ADD UP TO AS MUCH. THIS WONT BE EASY TO SELL SINCE, AS TALKS

WITH WILKINS TODAY INDICATED, THE INSTINCT IS STILL STRONG THAT

COMPETITIVE BIDDING WOULD PRODUCE LOWER PRICES EVEN FROM THE FIRMS

RESTRICTED

/MIO

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.