SI
SECRETARY OF STATE
HONG KONG ASPECTS
CONFIDENTIAL
fo
a box fa si thin a lunchtime
Today fleare
plif
Asscussed with sofs
a Vero Vels, sent.
AMD
1. As a man's life is at stake I believe that every proper and
constitutional step should be followed to ensure that there is
صاری
no possibility of a mistake. I therefore feel that you would be
justified in asking for a psychiatric investigation at this stage
as suggested in paragraph 4 of Mr Stuart's submission.
2. The Governor clearly considers (Hong Kong telegram No 490)
that he can accept and indeed would wish to see a reprieve if a
political row is likely to take place as a result of an execution
in Hong Kong. I share the Governor's view that such a row would
be damaging to Hong Kong's image in other spheres.
THE WIDER POLITICAL ASPECT
3. In view of the Irish vote and the present composition of
the House of Commons, in my political judgement there would
inevitably be "significant controversy" and possibly a major
parliamentary row, if you decide not to recommend a reprieve.
4. As there have been no executions since 1966 it is possible to
continue the present practice of commutation. If Tsoi is hanged
what would be the position in say three months' time if a similar
case involving a European arose?
5.
Although this is outside my immediate responsibility I am
In my
of course deeply concerned to safeguard your position.
judgement I do not believe that we would avoid a motion of censure
1
CONFIDENTIAL
Ton
No comments yet.
Private notes are available after approval.