TNAG-0196-FCO40-232-Judiciary-appointments-1970 — Page 26

FCO40 Hong Kong Department Records 聯邦事務部香港部檔案 All

W(B)L 51-7406

Since a complete

Bench

J

Wide-le

appellate judges

местно пори вес

jennifeed.

were consistently very good. In Sir James

McPetrie's view, Mr. Blair-Kerr was undoubtedly

on merit the better choice; but he accepted

that other considerations of the public

interest had to be taken into account in

reaching a decision - as, for example, public

reaction in Hong Kong and the impact of the

appointment on the judiciary and the legal

profession.

4. Views expressed by Sir Hugh Norman-Walker

in a telegram (No. 881) received shortly before

the meeting were considered. It was decided

to ask Sir Hugh Norman-Walker to elaborate

his assessment that "disruption to the

Judiciary" would be caused by any appointment

other than Sir Ivo Rigby's.

5. There was also discussion about the

possible creation of the additional senior post

of Judge of Appeal. The Governor explained

that the present Chief Justice considered

there would be advantage in having one Judge of

Appeal (on the lines of the system adopted in

The Governor did

Zambia), rather than a Bench.

not wish to hasten consideration of this matter.

The new Chief Justice might not wish to be

saddled with an idea of his predecessor's.

NOTHING TO BE WRITTEN IN this MARGIN

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.