1923-08-02 — Page 9

Daily Press 孖剌西報 All

TRAVEL TALK.

CANADIAN

NATIONAL

HAILWAYS

How long have you been out from Home?

and

When do you go on leave ? «

Every day you hear these questions in Hongkong. The later is always an interes ing topic of conversation." Have

will you thought about which way you go next time? The ROUTE via CANADA offers un imited attractions 1 with its wonderful scenery, busy cities and holiday resorts.

We will glad'y supply you with fares, illustrated booklets and first hand information.

CANADIAN NATIONAL RAILWAYS

(Separate and Distinct from C.P.R.)

WRITE, CALL OR TELEPHONS

·GENERAL TRAFFIC OFFICES:

Phone C. 2004:

THE RONGKONG DAILY PRESS,

Queen's Buildings, 8. Chäter Rd.

HUGO STINNES

STINNES LINIEN

Regular Monthly Freight and Passenger Service between Japan, China, Hoogkong,

Manila and Straits and Hamburg and other North Continental Porta.

OUTWARD from Hamburg via Porta of Call

Skantiers

•Albert Vöglor

Carl Legion

adolf von Baeyer

*Emil Kirdorf

+Scheer...

+Scheer

Zorange, 4,w,

2,000 tons

9,000 t

9,000 t 9,000 tons 19,3:0 tons

Astival

11th August..

First half of Sept First half of October First half of November. First half of December.

HOMEWARD for Antwerp, Rotterdam and Hamburg

Stermere

#Albert Vögler"

*Carl Legion

*Adolf von Baeyor

*amil Kirdorf

Tontage, d.w.

12,300 tons 9,000 tons 9,000 ton

2,000, tous

1,000 tons

Departure

18th: Ang. Calling at Manila

These steamers are fitted with all comfort for the convenience of, about 50

first class Passengers.

† Cargo boat.

AGENTS

REUTER, BROCKELMANN & CO.

26. Des Vaux Boad Central

ASAHI BEER

SPECIALLY BREWED FOR EXPORT

DAI NIPPON BREWERY CO.

LIMITED

TOKYO, JAPAN.

MITSUI

BOLE AGENTS

Phone CentralKo, 478.

BUSSAN KAISHA, LTD.

INSURE WITH THE

HONGKONG.

OCEAN

ACCIDENT A GUARANTEL CORPORATION LIMITED

ACCIDENT & ILLNESS MOTOP CARS, MOTOR CYCLES FIDELITY GUARANTEES BAGGAGE BURGLARY--

EMPLOYEES'INSURANCE K10

SHANGHAI OFFICE:-

No. 89, PEKING ROAD, SHANGHAL

AGENTS for Hongkong and South China

DODWELL & CO. LTD. Tazar. C. 1080.

Shining eyes

and glossy curls

-of your little boy or girl,

that will not forever stay captare in pictures TU-DAY ·

We bare the

2. QUEEN'S BLDG,

of an outfit you TACK

want. . Ent & Co.

show it to you

6. Des Vœux Road. Central.

AMERICA' AND BRITISH SHIPPING.

THURSDAY, AUGUST 2ND, 1988.

In the same way, several years ago, Can- gresy passed a law, forbilding the laboure of children in factories. Within a year,

THE SUPREME COURT'S DECISION.the Supreme Court bad interpreted this

SOME MISUNDEESTANDINGS.

The Washington. Currespondent of the Toulon Observer, in an article published on June 24th said-

An American who is temporarily in Tondon, reading the comments of some of the British papers on recent events arising out of our prohibition law, and bearing the comments of English friends on those events, is dismayed by several fundamental misunderstandings. Some of these misunderstandings arise out of difference between the legal systems of the two countries, a difference go intricate that it is going to be dificult to clear it up. And yet the effort is worth while.

I suspect that a good many Englishmen think that we in America passed a law specifically calling for the prohibition of liquor on foreign ships in New York barbour. In fact we did nothing of the kind. We never thought of doing any thing of the kind. I don't think wa, ever will do anything of the kind. And, har ing found that a law we passed for a quite different purpose is now interpreted to include this purpose, I think our people will amend the law-although as to this last I am compelled to be a little less positive, because the unhappy nerimony that has arisen over the incident, and the preciso condition it is now in, may be attended by the unfortunate results that sometime come when an otherwise simple situation is beclouded by acrimony.

The reason for the British misunder, standing of what has happened is that Britain has no exact, or even very close, analogy to our Supreme Court of the United States. And, lacking, that analogy, Britain naturally fails to understand its operations.

-THE WRITTEN CONSTITUTION.

statute as inconsistent with the cou stitution; and we are now busy with tion of child labour in terms consistent devising means of achieving the probibi- with the interpretation of the Suproute

Cour1.

UNIMPEACHABLE MOTIVES.

INDO-CHINA

STEAM NAVIGATION COMPANY, LIMITED.

SAILINGS SUBJECT TO ALTERATION.

MANILA KOBE vis MON TSINGTAU via SWATOW

& CHANGRAI BANGKOK và HOTHOW BANGKOK via SWATOW SHANGHAI via SWATOW TIENTSIN

KUBE TE MOJI --. HAIPHONG HOLHOW STRAFTS & CALCUTTA SANDAKAN CALOUTTA LISE

In short, the American people have frequently been put to much more is. convenience by our Supreme Court than Britain has in the present.caso. Nuver- theless, our people value the Supreme Court above almost any other one of our institutions. thoughtful Englishmen have frequently (I think that many wished for an

analogous institution.) Some Americans sometimes talk seriously of limiting the Cort's powers somewhat, BHANGMAI but practically no American ever fails to appreciate its value in the management of our democracy."

MANILA

HAIPHUJO

BORNEO

Another phase of the British comment on this receat incident, which is acutely painful to Americans, is the assumption, occasionally found in important British sources, that the Supreme Court of the United States handed down this decision with the intention and for the purpose of putting British ships on an equality with American ships.. Such an as 71BSTEIN sumption includes the innuendo that the Supreme Court, would take into considera- BANGKOR tion a motive of commercial self-interest.

This is so remote from Lo faintest element of possibility that the utterance of it is seriously depressing to American realers. There is no institution in the work more rigidly oblivious to all motives what. ever, except the simple interpretation of legal words, than the Supreme Court of the United States. There is no institution in the world more secure in its sanctity and in ita reputation for an integrity so great that no American ever harbours the idea of even discussing it.

WEATHER REPORT.

July 31st at 18.30-Warning to Hong kong, Connd Ports, &:-Depression cr typhoon of unknown intensity ithin 120 miles of Lat. 14 deg. N. Long 197 deg. E moving West,

Anguat lat at 11.45Warning to Hong- ong Coast Ports. &c.-Depression or of Lat. 14 deg. N. Long. 128 deg. E., may- typhoon of

unknown intensity within 60 miles ing West

August 1st at 12.12.-Prossuro has des and slightly from Shanghai to Formosa creamed moderately and Manila and Legaspi It is nearly stationary from Hongkong to Haiphong.

The most important function of our Supreme Court is to interpret our written constitution. (Oar written constitution is another one of our institutions for which Britain bas no analogy.) In effect, by interpreting our constitution is meant this: Whenever Congress passes a law, the Supreme Court, upon appeal from any litigant affected by the law, determines whether the law is cotaistent with the constitution; and, speaking generally, has the final word in interpreting the meaning of the language in which the law is framed, To illustrate by the presort case: Con- gress some years ago passed, and the States confirmed, an amendment to the constitn. tion calling for the prohibition of the manufacture and sale of intoxicating liquor in all territory where the laws of the United The typhoon continues to move westward. Statea ordinarily have effect. In addition | At 6 xm, this mroning it was about 310 to passing the Constitutional amendment, miles Fast of Manila. Congress passed the requisite and more detailed statutes fecessary for carrying the amendment iato effect. The law. being passed, the appropriate department of the The forecast for the 24 hours ending s Government put it into effect, and framed noon, 2nd Aug., is sa follows; various regulations for that purpose.

Distrios Formosa Channel

The depresion over SW, China is un- changed.

Total

Hongkong rainfall for the 24 hours ending at 10 am, 1st Angust, 014 inch. since January 1st, 45.3 inches, against an average of 5204 inches:

*MINGBANG **LAINANGTM

"YATSHING"

"CHUNNANG"

KWAISANG *

**ESANG *

Friday,

3rd Aug., p.m. Saturday, 4th Aug. Noon. Sunday, 5th Aug., 9am. Tuesday 7th Aug, @am, Tusaday, 7th Aug. 4 p.m.

Wednesday, 8th Aug, 10 am.

"CHEONG 3HING...Wednesday, 5th Aug-2pm.

*FOOKBANU” ...Friday,

LEESANG

"HUSANG

"HINSANG

10th Aug?

Friday 10th Ang, 8 a.m. Saturday, 11th Aug. 3pm. Friday, $4th Aug, 4p.2.

Thin Ling afforda regular sailings to Caloniss, Fedaag sas Singapore į returning from Unicoots staanera prossed via Birwis as Hongkong to Japan, occasionally calling at Shanghai, au steamers have stoolicos passenger actinimodation, hused with Wiriom and carry a fully-quallied surgeon. LINE-Sallings approximately every three daya Dowson Unston as Shanghal, sometimes calling at „Swatow. Through trokute enh be obtained and through Bu of Lading are NEMOCÍ M Wertherm and Yangitus Purði via Shanghai,

LINEllings approximately wonky for panschere ge LINE :—A woskly service in mainaisod with Manila by vouch with good

Passenger acccxemodation, sailings from both porm every Friday. Balling at Hoihow when in is jomases batera, LIND – Fortnightly sailings to man from Banusia by two 5,000 mos *- HINNANG:”and sa "MAUNANO" both steamers atcellent passenger setommogatiua, Cargo taken through Hills of Ledina fox adat Juston Labuan, Tawee

#DELIDOTU 3.8.

A

and Lanas Dare LINE—a regulae soryjon is run from March to Movember between

Hongkong and Tien win, usinag at Wetha, wit and Uketos,""

LINE ➡A wookly service is provided between Hongkong and Bangkok wa Besson. ty Bra Marmora prise with sp-10 date passing S

commodation.

CALCUTTA

3.5.

1i

LINE

'HOSANG" will be despatched on or about Saturday, 11th Aug., at 3 p.m., for SINGAPORE, PENANG

& CALCUTTA.

Through Bills of Lading issued to RANGOON, MADRAS, PORT SWETTENHAM and DUTCH EAST INDIES.

For Freight or Faszaga apply toda

Jardine, Matheson & Co. Ltd.

Tatarsons Cantial No, 2:5

GLEN

AND

GENERAL MANAGER -

SHIRE

JOINT SERVICE OF STRÅKKKA,

\_D.K.-STRAITS, CHINA & JAPAN SERVICE

FORTOLST

N. winds

moderate.

OUTWARDS.

Yeuol.

This statute and the regulations under it immediately became effective as the law of the land. But in this instance, as in most instances, specific arose in which litigants (including the Hongkong to Gap Book E. winds, moderate; Government itself) contested the statuts and

Cases

+

fuc.

the regulations under it. The issues thus South coast of Chins between joined were carried up to the Supreme

do Court of the United States.

Hongkong and Lamocks f And the

S.E. winds, Supreme Court, in the present instance, South coat of China between moderate handed down an interpretation of the law, Hongkong and Baion which among other things, is to the effect that the statute and the regulations in the precise language in which Congress passed it, forbid the carrying of liquor by foreign sbips within the three-mile limit..

This is an unanticipated and unintended. ihterpretation put upon a minor and "col- lateral aspect of our prohibition law.

"ARY-BLOW OF PROHIBITION.

The British, having no knowledge of these facts, and no familiarity with any institu-

tion wholly analogous, to our Supreme

THE NEW VERNON KEMEDT.

THERAPION No.:1 THERAPION NO.2 THERAPION NË 3

IN FOREMANT DULUTH.Tech für stolTM1⁄2

JOLASTERANSKOEKAKITA. FADES DE SKOLÁKS,RA BUS TAARE WALKED WIND FREESPION U A

GLENSHANE' "PEMBROKESHIR "GLENLUCE" GLENOGLE"

Due Hongkong.

13th Aug. ... 30th Ang.

10th Sept. ... 20th Sept.

BOMEWARDS.

J

Vemel Leaves Ekong, Dienkarges *GLENIFFER

7th Aug, Genoa London, Rotterdam and Hambary. "CARNARVONSHIRE" 14th Aug

London, Rotterdam & Hamburg, s "GLENBEG

... 29th Au London, Botterdam and Hamburg,

Movements are subjec to change without notice. For freight or farther particular please apply to

Jardine, Matheson & Co., Ltd., The Glen Line, Ltd, aceste.

Telephoné. Central No. 215 rubax. 18 and Central 2595.

Court; thinks that the prohibition of liquor The HONGKONG & WHAMPOA DOCK Co., Ltd.

on their ships, is the direct and intended

result of an act of Congress passed for that specific purpose.

In truth this is far from the cause. It would never have occured to any member of Congress to pass a statute deliberately aimed to prohibit liquor on British ships. The present interpretation, which has given rise to this embarrassment, while it must be respected, because it has been found by the Supreme Court to be inherent in the language of the statute, was wholly unan- ticipated, and was not at all in the minds of the Congress that pussed it.

By the same token it would be cothpara- | tively simple. for Congress to pass, an amendment to the law designed to get rid of the present interpretation. This is what is always done when the Supreme Court rules that the original language of it statute han an interpretation contrary to, or going beyond, the true intent of Congress.

I say it would be comparatively simple i to get Congress to amend the Act so as to relieve the present situation. IL may readily be possible that all the coinmotion that has arisen sad all the scrimony that has been uttered about this incident may have created a state of mind which will make it less easy to pass such an amend. ment.

The interpretation of statutes by our Supreme Court has frequently embarrassed and impeded the will of a majority of American people in cases more important and more charged with feeling than the present one. In 1896 Congress passed the first law providing for a national income taz. The Supreme Court, acting wholly within the obligation of its duty, ruled that the statute, as passed, was contrary to the constitution. Thereupon the statute be cameroid; and it was seventeen years until we were able, in 1913, finally to get an in- come tax law in terma consistent with the Supreme Court's interpretation.

TELEGRAPHIC ADDRESS: "MANIFESTO," HONGKONG.

CODES USED AI, A.B.C. Fifth Edition; Engineering: First and Second Edition; Western Union and Watkins.

Dock Owners, Ship Builders, Marine and Land Engineers, Boiler Makers,

Iron and Brass Founders, Forge Masters, Electricians.

Steel Twin-Screw Ocean-going Tug and Salvage Steamer

Henry Keswick

"

Built, engined and equipped complete by The Hongling & Whampa Dock Co., Ltd., Hongkong for their owa hervice, 1921. Length 165 B.P., Breadth 34′ (m) Depth 17, (m) LH.P. 2009. Fitted with electrically driven, submersible and centrifugal pumps, air compressor, wireless, searchlight and all modern appliances for Balrage Work.

Please address enquiries to the Chief Manager :

R. M. DYER. 8.80, M.IN.A KOWLOON DOOK, HONGKONO.

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.