1886-08-25 — Page 6

giual better to the Mining Journal that, was re- forced to. There was a statement mads the pro- vions day that in was tot original oarrespondenes.ing It had never been published in Hongkong.

Tho difendant called attention to the fact that the publication referred to was a loading article, Heal pat in a report of My. Candor's from which he said the information used for that an-

abot of our conversation was that no further pabligation from Mr. Bowlor's peu about the mines should be received.

Frautor, commencing his cross-examination. said-You have a great many letters after your It a fact that if yon failed to pay an anaa Anbscription you would still have the right to put these luiters after your name?

In reply to his Lordship the prosecutor anid-tlele was taken. That was the original report. They are not degrees. It is a matter of mera- His Lordship-That is scarcely the point; it harship. I happen to krow something about is whether he made these statements without it. I have a letter from one of the bading sathority, knowing them to be false. seipatista of Loudon giving full details of all these societies. Also I know all about Mr. Candler from home,

The complainant produced another paper con- taining this same statement.

The defendant said it was upon the raport he

Preacuta was then proceeding to question produced that he had framed the article referred the witao on certain gealogical specimens to. It soumed to him that a mistaka of teu dad which produced.

somehow domered there, what should have beon Trdship-I don't think the jury wikia soren having been made an eight. Tant was take the leash notice of this, I don't like to in the only raport he had ever son. The roport terfore, but I really cannot sun what this has to was giver lim, he believed, not to publish, but do with the spatter.

to look at, and lo colient information from. Ho did not orastiy rozober now, but he thought mail litely thaprus what it was,

Prosse tor-It has been so strongly insisted n that my desertptjou is wrong and Mr. Cand lor's is correat.

Hi Lordship. Well, 1 shuli tell the jury it is a matter of opiuintet between scientists, Witness, in reply to further questions, said he had not said there were calcaronna rocks at Tai Ya Shan, bat that the lode itself was eal-

2arcous

His skip aid that this appeared to go to the whole foundation of the thing that the publication was not made without authority. at ret, fabricated. It was very likely the de Yondant had it in manuscript before.

The defendant--I think it is very likely I saw it, though I cannot reall it: it is so long age. Prosecutor put other questions to the witness The complaiquztrequested that the jury should as to the rice, and on his Lordship again inter read an extract produced of the agreement posing, sail bat ak this hal bong brought out byder which Mr. Phillips was engaged, asha attotapt the often silo he had a right to prove that what had been evade on the part of the defondout to fe had written was oorrect and that wint Mexit a shr upon the credibility of the statements Caller had said was us be contended absurd 4 made by Mr. Phillips, and upon his capacity, gentleman at hom engaged on the Government: The extret set out the various kinds of work goalonzical survey had charrised Mr. Candier's Me. Phillips was to do for the Mining Company, report es bed. The prozonator then repeated amongst the thinga stated baing geological and his question about the letters after the withat's other arrays, managing and reporting upon the rines. Could hử havebeen engaged in sucti a position he hul known nothing ebent geology? Mr. Phillips had explaiend to him that he had not been in court beform, and words were put into his maith in the cross-examination.

Wit-I am a life member. Of BP-01 ka

Of the Instine?—No. ·

Then if yoh failed to pay your sub-eristion would you still be entitled to put those letters after your uses?-Treese to answer.

Then with gard to the Institute of Meta -liferous Mining --I am a te moraber of that.

Was it by purchase or oxamination ---Exi amination.

Prostratur- is the first time I have heard of an ayumination it correction it i

Craigamination coat.al-Did en calle the China Meredalein refentice to a letter grey the face of Me. Philliper -Yes,

Dil you all the editor so knew nothing about it - illy forgot what I tell him. I helioso I told him I wished he would inquire into the truth of it.

di mot.

it himself. It was quite a coluntary thing,

I say that on gathe

His Lorship interrupted and said Mr. Dowler could not go into this; if Me. Phillips wanted to giyo further evidanes upon this polat he must get into the box agnia.

Mr. Bowler-But this is documentary stid. ence; it is a foot positive na to his status.

His Lordship--Hare you any further evidenco that pou desire to gita ?

His Loodship –Never mind that, ft. Bowler,

|

|

|

MAIL SUFFLEMENT TO THE “ HONGKONG DAILY FRESS,” AUGUST 2011, 1886)

Complainant-That is faba.

choy mues, not to the Tai Yu Shan wines?

Complainant It is mizod; I was writing a good deal at the time,

And thou words about an intrusive dÿke abstrusting works?—This was a mistako; it did not refer to the mines

If

plainant's in which he and he had visited the he wrote that article to the Daily Press. Fid did Compliant sail if babal mads such su ap- | The detoutout, said Mr. Borlar's objnet, wia to His Lordship--I must insist upon your answer-mines with one of the most amiant geologists not know whers the minsa war cufli bo tuntication it would have been in writing, but depreciate those rains breann he had liam ra.

thegnestions.

of the dag. Defendant asked who the aiment passed on the givet, property of this company, there was no ench application produced sexinst fusada sitation on the at $1 month, Defendant-I am saking him the question. gouloglat was.

and found the minos work not at mchow. Ila bini. Mr. Candler had also sword that the and test he had threatened to raake them aller Complainont—I say that what the lefondant Complainant-Which do you refer to I went statement as to that was about as true as his works he saw at Tomehow were merely two if he were not suga ai and on the athorside it mid to me just now is falso.

with soverl

statement about tho ore from the mine, whlah shaftsuta levul for surill holes from which was all danid. is Lordin forret briefly to Defendant-You say you spoke from portonal. You refer to and here There wore béporal. was nu attempt to show that Mr. Chudler was a few tons of oneth hal baon Laker out. Ha nil the actantillo questions which had been raised, observation F-J did.

There was one poztleman who is now in charge attorapting to swindle and mislead the shur-seomad to have forgotten his afterward, for be and he attached, no important to the difference You mention the name of Mr. Phillips in con of very large mining operations in China; I do holders of the Company; and this was the gamblil in denying that the work; hai boonshanden of opinion which had been slaan woon thom has nection with them. Mr. Phillips has never been not intend to give up his name to gon, but, the man who as to them with a criminal prassoned on the recommmêntions of Mr. Phillips, that two the ovmplainant and Me. Candler. One to those mines, and never saw them of my was ons gestlounu who was with me whose name tien for libel. Then they fund he had wals they hat bon worked for three months after all soientific questions it zoemad thore own knowledge he was at Tai Ya Shan for II will give you because I do not think you can another assertion about an intrading dyke of then. Both statements could not be trap, and the were coutlisting opininga, perdonlarly no with have seen him there, and I can call a witness who injure him,

porphyrite rock which turned out ta ha qually fiets that Mr. Daudler had not come theronines, as to which many parsons had been ruined

· bay seen him there also,

His Lordsbipagain called Mr. Howlar to order. | false, Firet ho said it was at Tamshow, then ho to swear to what was true, he had exas there by trusting to the report of any scientific man Dofendant-This letter rafers to the Tam- Complainant Wall it. ms Mr.. Haughton, Rall that was a mistake, and it was at Tai Yu to soar to what was convenient. He was on and others puriched by speculation in the face of nining ongineer, surveyor . His report du Stau o monal, and lastly he tell them thera Insuring to throte discredit upon Mr. Cand another's adverso opinion.**Him Leged skip said ho the place as a mining locality is—“ I don't think no dyke at all. He must have krown in the trailer's ordonge because he had periured himself must leave it to the jury to decide whether tis the place is worth a second glanci

instance there. was no dyles, and conse-rough thick and thin, Mr. Caudler's expert-matter complained of way liboflens ae net. Defendant-Ia hu a goolgist F

grantly he (dofandant) was justified in say one as a mining meiner was gathered at a they found in was so they mestconsider whether Complainant--I am not quite sure; I think tong, that the simplingnt had written what coal pit in the north of England.

it was true and it was published for the public was false and what he kar to be false, Tis Lordship-Wa hada no evidäöse of that. benefit, and whether it was fair and honest That was a question of fact. There was notana Complainant, refarrod te. Mr. Candler's old foriticism under all the siren mei21008, article which the prosecutor had published which ones about his connection with the School of was not infamously suggestive of foul impets Arts at Nawesstle-on-Tyne, tions, and infamous in the highest depro, Ho dated the prosecutor in show one article against him which has beeu, ilictated by malica or spite. He had not abused Mr. Bowler, what ho had written of him could not be considered as abusive. He would not condemand to abas Mr. Bowlur. The defondant then went on to refer to the specimens of oño afe. Bowler said he had obtain- from the Tamolow mines, and be contended tant that stalaragut also had boon provod in aross-examination to be a falsehooil, that Mr. Bewlor torer had this" half a ton of spintons, aud the whole thing was an invention. The proseentor had fonced with the questions en corning it in just the same way as the other statements

Complainant-The is nothing about half a

When did you find this out ?----The day aftor it was published when it was too late to siber it. And you did not correct it --- No, it was never intended as a scientifs description; it was a mero joculus latter, I must orpinia this matter. The copy for the printera is written ou saull slips, I was writing a great deal at the time, and one of the slips referring to another matter got mixed with thaus by mistnics. I detected it toc lata.

Dofondant And hodid not correct it the act

day because it was merely a joke. Will you take a note of that, my Lord?

Hi Lordship-It is unnecessary to take a note, the jury have beard it.

Defendant (to complainant)—So there is an intrusive dyke? Well I cannot exactly say that dyke will correctly describe it. It is a mass of rock, but it has not got boon opened aufficiently to show what its exact form may be.

You say in this letter one of the most niinent geologists That is not the person I referred to. The defendant then produced a letter in mannscript dated the 18th Jane, 1890. He said You swore yesterday you landed this letter to mo?

Complainant-Yeg,

And you still swear it-Yes, I swor you my it. You say you never saw it, and that you nevar would have inserted it If you had.

That you brought it into my offins and gave it to me -This is not the one I referred to them, it is that lotter (producing the letter in print).

The defendant here dashed down the paper upon the table with a highly theatrical gesture.

Complainsut-This was the one I referred in. As you know perfectly well, thust ono was aver published, so that I could get bare referred to it. Tho one I referred to you say you had never men, or it would not have a pblished; thornton anywhore, my Lord. fore this cannot be it, as it has never been pub.

Defendant. It is in evidence that he was en gazed in gold mines in India,

Į

The jury rotired to consider their verdict. and after an abroncs from the cart 38. 30 minta, the 'forman said they found a verdict of not guilty by six to one,

The sessious wore then adjourned.

THE TYPHOON ON THE CHINA COAST,

...

Complaint said he was coming to that; tha whole thing, was in the Mining Journ d. - Mr. Caudler went there as second to unabber person, and reained till the company had no more money and then they weat away. He trusted it would not be the same thing with regard to tasse mines, Me. Her went on ta peak of the ancisty Mr. Caudler studied in as a mutual beneft society resembling that Portugueso society lately con nected with the old Roman Catholic Cathedral

The Shanghai Mercury of the 16th inst, says: and ho prosseded to discount the value of the -For some days past there have been indications modal which Me. Candor deposed he had re of an approaching typhoon. All day yesterday neived in a silke way, though repeatedly called thore was a stiff gale blowing, and though the to order by his Lorship. Complainant sald that joning these societies of suisalists diaphore was silent, it was apparent by the fall Defendant-You hear what he says now, my

nike M. Candler a geologistany more than of the barometer that a typhoon was raging at no Lord, there is no dyke.

Complainant-T muy uo! Is thutect shape,lished.

The defendant further referred to this point is going intoa stable would make him a horse. grant distance from Shanghai, Though the nt some length. Ho said this was another quos (Laughter.) The lofondhat had alluded to these vessel which arrived here yesterday reported not it is impossible to toll what-form it may assume. His Lordship-All this is of no importanon tion of plain fant, notaf professional opinion, and mines as being those of public companies. They hoay weather, yet the deputies of mista

The examination then wont into scientific whatever. matters relating to the results of assays of oron, Complainant-It is an attempt to throw dust in the face of theen fucts and how his oradibility wore act so. They were privato affairs, the pro-stomers which were to have to-day was post-

had been shaken, he thought the jury would not prety of private individuals. They were not ra. and a letter published on the 17th November, in the eyes of the jury, 1885, wa areferred to in which the complainant

bo ineliood to place much reliance upon the origistered as public enmpanies. As to this on ponod. The gule increased during last night, His Lorship There has been a lot of dust deace of Mr. Bowler, I went into the box that frotorzy it was not commenced by complainant's and blow furiously today. The Frouch mail kad given the probable yield of the ore sa notown Tu the eyes of the jury.

day to do his came as much good as he could; it geological articles. The defendant had persist- | steamer Melbouras faft bor racorings in the river Imore than ton ources to a ton, when Professor Defendant-This is an attempt on your part was for the jury to consider hothor ke had dogs atly sttanket him for yours past-siace a bailiff about soon, with her top-galtat mast struck,

Milne, a short time aftor, found it yielded 143 | to defeat justies P

his one pum. Dafer thou reformed hud turut kan out of a house of which he was and the US man-of-war Varios and Puforstrick ounces.

Complainan-1 have come here to panish you to some remarks on criminal prostations for less by the seruit of the neck. The complainant-That ten ounces is a mis-for what I think is a ordel and malignant attack. litol made by the late Sie John Smale who he

His Lordship og da called the complaionat to their fog-unsts also. The semiphora showed, print: £ have another article which says 14) ounces.

And after I had been committed for trial at described as of the must night judys who orlor, observing that there was no vidlanes of Eng 57-lyphoon between Niugpo and Foo- the Police Court, did you not go to the Palioever sat upotea bak, Sir John Smal auf that whatorer, Court and make this remark reported here the functions of a julgo in a easy of crifinal

chow." There worn only fien arrival staring the The complainant proceded to deal with the The mere existence of such a scurrilous print bet ware vary mael arrowed dowa. In paragraph containing the alleged hel upony, and zone of them from the Sith. is a reproach to the colony?"-I cannot scar fact the jury were the julges of the merits which this action was brought. This paragraph | Kington and Susi arrived from the Liver Porta to the exact words, but it was something to that of the case thomsalvor. His ship badh referees to a lotter he wrote handed" "An the steamvara Paulah and Et. D›ráže from Taku, - effect.

only to lay before them the evitone: Hey Exolution" in which he sarcend Mr. Candler and the Yordomo More from Japan. The River That had reference to a man committed en were not bound to popept his opinion. It was of havier gone to the Co Hospital nejled boats raport strong WF, winds and rain: the criminal chargo P-Yes, I was bringing scotler also his Lordship's daty to lay down to them the Mr. Phillips's tetier attacking him from a man charge against you.

I junșt stop you; I really cannot allow you to go into them exteuremis mafter about what yena did in Government House. Have you anything

Mr. Bawber Yes, I have a book here writton

by my former tutor, Professor Cook.

Complainant-1-am in my 99th year. Hos long larga de Hooghong Sison

1. James Ball, engineer in charge of the 1870? zachinery at the Tan Chow minos, was called

to speak to a naversations had with Mr. Bow-thenshire? ter about Me. Candier.

The prosecutor ejected to the evidence on the grond that in the alleged libel there was

ten reference made to what he had sail bat caly

to what he had written mul published.

His Lordship allowed the olgction, Mr. G. Laws sail-I am a miner in charge

of No. 3 shufs at Tam Chow. 1 bara sem the prosecutor at the m'e

He had no pormisdan

to visit the mines. It was at the agil of F+bru

What steamer did you come by the Carnin

Complainant-Am I bunmi to saver thesa nestions, your, Lardship they are quite irrele vant.

His Boriship said Mr. Bowler could do as he pleased about auswering them.

action.

My Bowker-Then I refuse to answer the

Were you a chemist before you came out?-I War in metallurgisul chemist.

De yon bold any diploma - bars no er

His Lordship-You say ten ounces to the tos in that letter most distinctly.

Complainant-I cannot exactly account for that.

His Lordship-Have you published anything in aug of the other papers simultanovasly with this that it was 140 oumicos be the ton?

Buroses-over-been-employed in mining

have never worked as a miner.

That is not the question. Have you ever had przètical working employment in mines ?—No, bat in connection with mines I have.

Where wore those mines? I deslineroanswer. His Lordship What is your objection!

ney beginning of March last. Ha trent downticate here, but I may tell you I had matrien-esired minerals from. No. 1 haft i did not down mine, or ask lated with bonours in the London University

I wis comert d with in France to drass gelenn up to 7ta 78 per cent of had. I don't know what

is usual in the lend minas of Devon or Cornwall,

hi personally. He bad intended to call his after their name, sad aqyer passed an examint sab editor to give evidente on that point, but he tien.

was not resent.

His Lordship It does not matter. It may bove-been a mistake.

Just answer my question.

His Lordshop-You have your answer. Complainanti de unt see why he should go inte all these matters. I did not ask his witness. Candler all these things (Innghter).

and their sense of date,

D

|tion of the wird Was N.E

The

P.M.,

The bammeter was then 29.70 and the weather

Mr. Bowler-Yes, I kave. An attempt las i been made to show that I commenced my studies ¦of geology and chemistry sincs I came out here. It will be for me to show that is not so. I swear that commed the study of geology and chemistry at the age of 14, uzder

my nucle, as late Dr. Thomas Martin. the Did you indits that letter for Mr. Phillips P-founder of St. Thomas's Hospital, he is now duet, and I am not afraid, consequently, By his Lordship-This is my handwriting. Ito bring forward his name How Those Complainant tafter staming the letter)-I soo had to come down to Horgking in connection anding I hate continued up to the present time-- now my Lord; it is perfectly correct; ten ounces

law relating to the cuso, but even with regard to prestated and weakened by sickness. This was two Northern stars experienced a strong with a very insubordinate letter I had revived a muster of 20 years. I have still in my posses-to the tan is correct. I do not go upon the sary I can prove what I say shant this letter.

Defendant-If your Lordship thinks it noaos-tant the jury old ase their own good sanssa fact as Mr. Padlips had told them. Who westerly gals and coulceed a The ElDor do from Mr. Phillips Mr. Ho Amei scrised me to sivu spetimens of minerals and rocks which I cleaned org as Professor Milner does; I go upan

Mr. Phillips had regained some of his strength was rather bidly krockel shemt. Shohad some Hi Lordship-It is of us importance en op to the Hospitol are discharge him at once callected when I was between the age of 14 and the rough ore us they get it out of the mine.

His ship What is that you say?

he voluntarily fold prostaster that he felt he had The complainant, after a fow more questions, on account of the writing of that lattes. I went 39. when I was very young indeed. Mr. Fowler The contention is that ore which is picked out in which concluden bis crows.examination I wish duty to lay quen the in relating to the mitted that using to the threats of his superior Sus reports as follows:-" From Talin to Chalon Defondant said though it was his debin's acted meanly tarda hin. and he candidly afifty or sixty gritas pa bol, from Tientais. up to the Civil Hospital. "Bufere I saw him I went on to say that he had had a therung du small quantities and cleaned does not represent to produce the evidence of a gentleman who went use to the jury, they are not band is he had written lies. Complainants oxalanation one wasther; at Chetan much rain. Froma ir quired if as wasvoneniessent and they told nation in glory before coming here, and he the work of getting it out. What they get out with me when I got those specimens of rocks neapt his definition if it did not fall in with had been proved true in every sense and in every N.E. Promontay to S.E thick fog. 12th. hould be discharged the next day. I spoke proceeded to describe the recaption is met at is this staff forhibiting specimen). Everything Mr. Candler swore they did not come from the what they considered the justice of this or any detail. The paragraph went on to say that Mr. moderate S.S.E. wind and heavy goll rising. to him in referee to this insubordinate letter of Gatrenosat Hane when he called there soon

have written is surrept. his und ababrat same very insubordiante words after his arrival in the colony,

place be ww working at. I have evidence to ease. The precedor al instituted these - Candor was animated by a perfectly laudablo de he hat spalon to Mr. Homci, and told him!

Defendant-And what you said just now was prove they did come from there, and that will rastlings us to avaved, to punish him id fon- sira ta sesers Mr. Thomas Ide Bowler's urist List Amy wind and sou tcreasing. incorrect ? bal'instructions to discharge him.

discredit his evidenoo by showing he has told dantia mort noble motive for any man bo como non. Did the nines of Kr. Oandler's personal wind ingrossed to a moderate gale and easterly. He told me

His Lordship-You said just now the 10 was falsehood. I call faspector Stanton. he was rey sorry for what he had fans,

misprint for 140.

into noriminal court with. He world repeat attacks upon him bear sat each a statement? with a very hurl sex from E.SE. and continuer William Stanton, Inspector of the Hong-what, he had sai bofore, that this was a case The defendant had failed to show that his latter blowing hard until arrival" The steamship Yori- and be offered to nam down to the offen

Complainant-It cleans up to 140. It is not kong Police, esid in auster to Mr. Bowler, which ought never to have come into this const. of explanation contained anything that was not amo Maru reports as follows:-Loft Kachinotza and apologise to Mr. Io Amei, which to any to the jury by way of rebuttal?

!a raistako. de that same day about three o'okek This

Previously to joining the police I was and is balised in noother place thann Haacking perfectly in order and perfectly fras. All the was the third I had condoned offences

His Lor labin-Then you were wrong in saying miner is Coruwuk About two years ago I would criminal proceedings have bewa institutol paragraphs as hat rand to the jore of which he on the 11th iust, with strong easterly winds. it was a taistaka? by the same man. After this conversation had His Lordship You are a geologist, and not!

accompanied you to the Tai Yu Shan mine; in sneh a case. He again quote from the tiemplead were libellous, and calarinted to de. Angest 12th, wind iœrawing to a wondacata gain Complainant-es. I have refreshed my mo- there was no mine there then. There were tnm of the late Sir John Smate to the effect that price him of credit and repalation. It was a with a brary S.E. arall nad a falling baromster. ended I told him I had received by the last mail a bad one either. I dare say you think, but I mory by reading the previons remarks and sea-everal boles, the marks where blasting had been crimizni prosentions for libel ought not to harry serious thing for a man to be deprived of August 13th, met steamship Inge, bound East: my enpy of the dining Journzi and Lad hal want to know if you have any farther evidence ing what it referred to. What it referred to was going on, and we ourselves fired several blasts taken except by porous of high states with his daily bread sme convorsting with the other stuff at the to give

any man who started rough urs.

that day. I have since tales visited the pines Oct

už 5,40 pan, arrived at Taugeha with a strong Set of mins which led me to believe he was giving in

great interved at stake, or Mr. Bowler-Yox. I have never asked Mr. Ho

newspaper. To

A starting if envl it Defendant-The statement is a perfectly plain with Mr. Caudler. It is the exact spot I visited whore

public questions formation about cerr miass to Mr. Bowl in Amei for employment in these mines, and I have on it in that it will be perfectly impossible to with you. I have seen plenty of rook like that wers concerned.

ef imoustanee noweraper "dił

3. та hot constitita

agate from E.N.E. nad troamʻlonde high sa was trying in an anderhand way to do ayself a never asked Mr. Caudler for employment inclosa up this ore to anything like 75 per cent of produced by yon before; I have seen plenty of it libals criminal proscations worn out of pleit hat been the marimot public writers to avoid Lith, sirailar waathor.

For ordinary defomatory public pranentor. Since the time of Juvonal Lowest reading of barometer 2948, Atgut little harm. He got very excited and ran into them. I had never on him. I have nothing load or more than about ten ences of silver to at Tai Ya Shan. I have ever seen ang like it Criminal sacation was not vindictive. That personalities.and this was a motto which had been his room and brought ort paper and punci, anda to say: the defendant can cross-examine ma. the con. That is perfectly plain. offered to contradict the stents als in the Oh, I wish to wear that these pieces of rock,

Anywhere else before, I can masily tell this kind of was thedictum of Sir John Sala, and it was focally approved, "parere purvain dicere de

With the exemption of the sinking, off the

Mining Joel, shich I showed hio, and produced) which Mr. Candler has sworn are impossible.

Complainant-Yes. I consider it would be quite lead. We brought away thre or four hundred the jury to say, after what the presentor and tifs, or pre perious while writing of Quaida Franca, of an old junk which a couple of imited later will refeomna to it to the Miner never been got from the mine where be in work-

weights of that kind of rook that day. This said in the box, whotline this prosecution was vice." Complainant went on to alune to the torms months ago was picked up by a tng, wa kare Tern which was very mark the same as thising, at Tai Yu Sith, were taken from there by sible.

Thut is your answer Yos, absolutely impos.granite I cannot say is different from what cannot the result of ignorance and vindictiveness applietto bin in the paragraph complained of bourd of no casualties afford or ashore. It is

be had anywhore alse. He sated me to write it out grammatically for myself, and quite recently.. Thim; Fist wreto it bite. I then wrote

Have you ever been employed in mining I

The dierum referred to was made in tongs in and to his interview with Mr. Ho mi when he Cross-examined by defendant-I have never which a banker was prosentor, a much higher explained to that zont man that Mr. Chudlar ertainly focinate that there are Low-nap tides, this letter from his notes. I loral to write are you. Mr. Bowler?

Cross-xuniard by the defeolant-How old have been very nonsiderably employed in Resay heen at any other ages in China, but I har prom in social position thum. Vr. Thomas Lile had described as prphite meat boniferous else part of our salement, Jongkow ospecially,

ing: I have taken sample oros from the mouths specimens from all mines that have been opened Bowler. A to instifistinn, he thought bis site. Ang geologist would recognise it with might have banu sahnurgad, (of mnay mines.

from the 15i Ya Shou mines. I hare aflosting a public company, and au importat defendant had Inscribed him as an objectionable the Daily News- in China. That produced is a time specimen. Lordskin would adgát flakonoke 1 Die ont jan seực. Haguarowed that was alig the The follozinc caparte, of pawwala nan pisanje

ance since the first I saw. aven some sincs, and it has improved in appear. industry coactol with Hongkong, has busybody. The defendant wil be hal published

The Fushun raporta :---Laft Hongkong at 6:40 justified in publishing what was taxe in respont fals and gratuitous statements which he know This concluded the evidence.

to attanks muuta mpán it, It was for the jury to to be false and gratuitons. In all his corresp.m. an the 9th, with the wind 3.W, and hauling said he was quite sure that what had passed had regard to Mr. Bowler's sttanks mon it. If what he heliavad to be true.

The defendant than addressed thus jury. He consider whether he had said what was tras with prudence he had published nothing but was the North. Breaker Foint was passed He could at 5.25 am, the 10th, with light brakes and quite opened their eyes as to whether it was the the jury thought Mr. Bowler published a single not say that he had madə mistake: Complaint-Because I do not want, by dia- complainant or himself who was trying to throw statement which was natron in tasse articine, The ww not infallible-buatmur est errare," fine weather; 3.46 pm sans day, passed the ribald jokes and joers, so I decline to give, if I confidence leave the case in the hands of the jury a verdict of not goûte. Ha did not thinks he less vituperation. Had he mer personally abused rain, the barometer being study. At 14 pm. closing Ravens's names bera to subject them to dust into their eyes. He felt sure he might with and which he kaaw was true, they would End The defendunt asee him of weak and purpose. Brothers with N.B. winds and heavy squalls of can do so, any Dube.

as it stood, but he thought, perhaps, it would be oneil trouble bis Lordship with many reunieks sither the defendunt or Mr. Dandler? Thoo Defendant I am not using names. What as well that ho should makes fow remarks before on the legal aspect of the e. La libd eso had pared a great deal of personal abuse over

on the 11th, passed Tunzging with strong N.E. mines liave you assisted at?

Complainant-Hundreds of them. I have rete criticise the indialment, which he described as Ro raferred again to the case ho had cited in powder and shok, implying that he say Hisshans, with same weather, but the swall bis Lordship summed up to then. Ho provaded the same anth wities were host alwave quoted him. Then the defendant said he was not worth wind, aloar weather and strong Easterly swoll elling in. At 3.28 um, on the 12th, pasaod

Name somo - decline to answer his ques-oriminal conct. It was the ordinary thing in Gembach as the latest of the kind, casually him of his character. The editor of a newspaper hau Chanus, the wil increasing to a strong the funniest thing he had ever seen put into his opening speech, also to the case of Had y worthless person indend. "All this was depriving was increasing: 7.50 p.m. passed through Tai for porevizione. I uno drasat. I have dressed The defendant called the complainant's attention, ny Lord. Lend a high as 26 to 78 par cent.

tion to the law which provided penultiós against

libel cases for the alleged libel to be set out and alluded to the mans of Hanwood v. Harrison and was in uxory responsible position, and the state- Byt prosecutor-1 was usual in the mine persons who hold themselves out as chaimata, evor made to the Tamacho Mining Cougary there

Defendant-You say the only application you the innuendous explained. In this indiciment Wison v. Walter. He was auro he 'migit leave) monts be made in his gaper had very crent gale, the swell getting heavier, with the baro- and were not certified to act as such.

no ianuando set out the jury had the law in his Lordship's hands to lay before the waight, and it was in his power to crash a mha Lightship at 2.20 m. on the 13th, and

motor slightly falling." Anchored off the Tang was for some piaces of rock ---1 have tried to do simply to take the paragraph as it stood, and jury fairly and lucid. The jury at as the without giving any opportcity of defang afterwards ptonded, arriving at Shanghai at Complainant-Thut refers to druggists and basines with them. gothecaries, to pharmaventists. I am not a

could not go in the least beyond anything that whole thing liofors them, and would be able to hims If was tika ant ran attacking 10 30 the same day. In the river, the dire The defendat tten banded in a copy of the and were druggit (mughter):

That is your only application P-The only sprea atatod thore. They sure bound hand and judge whether he had hon started by Ewlings another who was quite defenceless with a. Habang Flegraph of the 19th Jane, tain

plication Lever made to Mr. He Amai or to Mr. foct. This controversy commeal by Brof-maller towards Mr. Bowler or not, whether with an sam other ways. The defocatuut Ocpata Extwards, of the P. 20. Le's steamer Is not that u facetist a man las to right to Candlur." ga pararraph which he said would show he held himself forth as a chemist who has no cer-

Howlar sanding

him on article criticising this this prossention was a bona fide one on the had shown units to give his fair play, for Bokhart, has favoured us with the following as was in Aney when the prosecntor sent in istifiente as snch P-It is not a fast

You never applied for permission to visit their mining company and it had gore on inthe columus part of Mr. Bortor. He had to do they the one or two of his letters which he had pab count of his trip op tus eosst-Tha Bokhara Some of the private property at Tamolos I went to Mr. of the Hongkong Telegraph until he stopped it. world come to rational conclusion, and he asked fished he had hurile ballasted with footuales. letter, and which prosector said he hundead to leading scientists of this world have no letters Ho Ama's office to ask permission, but that That article had been read to the jury, and he them with confidence to return a verdict of not Complainant contended that all this talk about weather to Oaksen, which was reached on the inft Hongkong on "the 11th instant with fine gentleman was away somewhere in the country, did not hesitate to say that it contained maliciens guilty.

winwa was hasida the question. The casa had 12th, when priced N.. swell; prepared en as I was going in that locality, I went there falsehoods and which the prosecutor, if Le without bis permission.

The prontar, in reply. hagged the jury mat nothing to do with cines, but these attacks wars Trespassing on private property-There, is to have, mast have known to be so. Whon ho feulant had mixed up his stately, or by his being a contributor to the Daily Press. Dine. On 18th August at I am, the ship passossed the geological knowledge he pretended to ba fad away be the manner in which the dome on him from sims which are through he ship for bad weather and furled all awnings. a public road leading to it, I believe.

(defondant) grated from Professor Milne, the a sloquegon which ha, prato anfortunato- tealat hal dosenbod bin is a contemptible of Fangying and the wind set in from Where did you get your torothundredweights of ore Pal got it in 1975 or 1876, trom the pafant admitted that te was wrongly did not possess, for by his strong positive as antites what pull the ten clams of stuf NW st 4 s. stron NW. wind and

These statements of his were not quarry working in these quarries. It was ore expressions of professional opinion; they word for great strass upon the feel that cuainal - showed the aninius.

mero sertions, which were falso. The delantalon Gologies Notes. To submaltind that swell turning into breaking seas; eased the which had been cleaned quarter of a ton of absolute statomaats of fast. He had admitted stead of civil proceedings had haan taken against

I raade nothing by the transaction.

His Fordship summed an rather brieft. Hengines to dead slow and sat reefed fore trysail And you have kept it all this time -No, I said he bad soon specimsus of the ore which himself that he should make some explanation.said about this criminal prosenation, if the com

that Professor Wilco's assay was correct, and he him, and he (evapligant) thought it was due to said, with reference to what the defendant but the ship entering on S.W. guadrant of oyelono, barometer 29.22, wind N. W with ferde squalls and heary min 0.16 p.m. tarood ship's hand to letters-I thought you said you had it on your box, they had seen the way in which he gavo his for those mires were ever thought of, he haften would never be hafers the court as it was. The N. and kept engines-jast turning over, the Defendant (referring to one of the published jury had won Mt. Bowler's demeanour in the sistunt attacks upon him for years past, long bo- tion, against defendant in this matter it/8. W. and ran for two hours in heavy confus would zaawer that gentleman's description. Th-Owing, in great messure to blus defendant's pre-plainant kad nos a right to a criminal prosecn-

seu the barometer rising slightly, turned to verandal still-That has reference to Tai Yu evidence. and they had seen that whenever he reduced in circumstances for nextent that it magistenta had fouil a urina facie caso, and tha opolens travelling slowly. At 2 am. at the Shen,

defendant) put him in a sormer he lied, and was allogether impossible for it to find the Attorney-General had filed an information and 11th, the eyelone moving westward, barometer The defendant neized complainant to explain a this he should prove to them. passage in his Geological Notos pablished in the

means to institute civil prestlings and carry allowed the prometer to prossunto Thongh, dewa to 29.74, the lowest reading, stoppai the Daily Preas to the effect that through the to uso in this court

His Lordship-That is very strong language them on. He had conducted the present cashotaver, it was within the complainant's right sugides, the ship ising very quietly, and ship- courtesy of Chinese gentlemen who had the DefendantIt is my Lord

from no desire to act as his own lawyer, but be to bring a criminal prosscation, it might be plug un water. mangement of the mixes he obtained numIATOOS

The wind veered W., S.W., cana be bad not the means to promira legal is gestionable whether it would not have been thon 9, when the russel proceeded full spend on His Lordatip It would be better that yan stanes. He asked the jury to all to mind the fire to the defaint lol los brought civil prober course at 6.50 s.. on the sun day, the specimens of the ore obtained from that locality should express yourself in a different manner. nature of the correspondence which he had put ending for n ertaina! rocution sad bis wind and sea rapidly going down

Complainant I shall have to send to my Say he ocntradicted himself. house for the cards of these Chinees goutdomen;

lished in the Daily Press at various times. It month, and he was nuable to vivo evidence on I have the all there.

Defendant-Contradiotsd himself would not was not upon those minos. bat upon the geologi-f his own behalf. There could be very little at 200g the 15th mat the Melbourne at an- chor At daylight she agaalled What weather His Tardship-Answer the question. Ton

cal features of 11 country, and those mines only done that Che faires course would have been outside to which the Bles replied "The know perfectly well what it is.

cropped up incidentally. On the other hand the civil pre-dure, so as to give the defendant Complainant-I do ust ahoratani, it is more is went on to say lust Mr. Bowler had publish in thismattor simply for the purpose of attacking was nothing to have prevented the defendant

The defendant adopted the latter expression. nons of Ms. Candler and defondant had been used every opportunity of disfeeding himsel. There typhoon has passed to the westward." of an eration than a question.

el statements which he could not hotp knowing him. Their articles had been more personalabas from taking proceedings in a civil court any His Lordship explained the nature of the ques were untrue, and in his writings throughout be firstod at hire, and in vo way controversial. The mere than in a criminal, for he senlä kars tion, and asked the witness if the specimena re, had slawn animus sgainst the Tomchow Mining defendant had said he had compensad the con I did not. aw & quarry in which cortenferred to in the article quoted from wore the Company because he had imported Mr. Ho trovary. It was not po

fill his own petitiou, and though he would small metalliforous lodes were shown on the site quarter of a ton te had been speaking of.

It had really bean probally not have done it so well as a lawyer, is nothing calcaraons Abont ft. There are nu of the present win godementary rocksia bat vicinity, and the person

Complainuut-No, is not It refers to the company on the strength ofhismizing experience,

Amoi and Mr. Candler for smployment in the commencathy Mr. Candler's publishing euerficle there was a doubt, he would have got substantial You saw the site of the prosent mine?I did day I visited the mines last year.

in the Hongkong Telegraph in which ha sta izstice. His Lemship threw out these observe-

The Mercury says:-News resolist Shanghai who would my there are must be ignorant of thes

Mr. Bortar, did you not write in un article

&c. and they refused to give it to him bemuse statements which complainant thought wer of a tiros as what had been anti might otherwise be the 19th Dist. of u seose segnator which took first principles of geology. If he can produce u gan contributed to the Daily Press, that you to there ?-Tho specimens 1 obtained when 1 position. Ha (defendant had nothing whatever mind sets of way he kad routared, conscientiously then the proscator non the pront of the the tire pointed peasly, the Chinese Defendant-What are the specitous referred they did ant think he was a capable potsen for the rory congius character. In a cery make and misleading. The defondeat was entitled to place between Chinese mom-of-war's chen and single cubic foot of calouroous rock, from that had not been to those wines before March visited the mines last year. locality I will give him a thousand dollars for this year 2-1 did not, I wrote that I bad- Any rofrono to that quarter of a ton -No was in no way ecnosened in the success of their had written was perfectly trae. The defolaatoriticisma.

bo do with either of those two gentlemen, and he as he thought, to set the right, and all that he publication, and to show that it was not fair There are, as rapted previously, four Chinasa it will give him all I hare gut. I wish to not visited the locality since mining operations reference whatever. If there is any doubt about rantüre, but they had both came forward and had positively told them that bo (complainant); ad done, the 1bel couplained of was true in danked; and, it appears, according to the version He was also titled to plaid, as hem-of-war at Nagasaki, for the purpose of being yay I had no malicious intent other towards, Mr. were commenced there. Candler or the Company or any ette accorned.

In this article of the Sad Deamhor in the it in company with--

By having visited the plaes I may say I visited sworn that Mr. Bowter had importuned them se had committed deliberata perjury, unt to make substanes and in fast, and that it was published of the affair which we got from a omsting vos I intended morely to criticize bis geologicat Daily Press, on the geology of South Kwang.

bu had stated, and Mr. Gealar further said Mr. this art he had mixed up a quarter of & tou off for the public benefit. It was for the jury to that overal of the crew went ou share tv remarks and I wrote what I thought tras tung in which you say the ore is good, but simply.

Hi Lordship-fast answer the question Bowler forced himself into his office and asked ore he got years ago at Tanchow with the consider whather the defendant had shown buy sine Japonowo swords. For some unknown I saw what I thought was very orrcneous, and scattered in such email threads as to be unprot i was put in pria: test by Mr. Candler, and 1 able for working. At what time previously had cances and 140 ounces of ever to the ton, which make thinge unpleasant for the equpany if he told them abous it in his aridence.

Defendant roverted back to the question of 10 salary of 2400 por month, and threatened to in company with Mr. Stanton, who End and whatherarnot they ware of a libellous unto in a house of ill-fame, and scop it came from for an engagement for five years at the modest snocimens be recully took from Tai Yu Shan that the allegations he had made ware free rosson a quarrel casaud - it originates, we hear, thought I was justified in contradicting it.

you been to son fasse minos, wete ferm my he said he wished to make as clear to the jury were not employed, and that he has to tell the bitta kunder his be Mr. Candler aftur His Lordship thought he might way at once trying to pacify the won, who seemed to be blin The and also if they were unde for the public benefit. words to blows. The Polina were called, and in At this stage the case was adjourned anti hatt knowledge acquired when I visited the locally and bis Lordship as possible. He said Profes 1080 employés to put him out of the office. Would he had written what he above referral to was upon that print that he thought this was past ten o'cloak next morning to allow of the previously. I visited them in company with a Laor Mine is one of the most eminent Geologists the jury believe those gentismen or Mr. Bowler very sarrilous and porconal one told him matter for pablo dicesion.

worse for liquor, one of the "bobbies" was stubbed bedation of a copy of the Hongkong Telegraph Fontkoman who was a partner in quo of our lead of the day, I suppose you are aware?

Mr. Bow With a Japanese sword by one of the marinea eataining sa assay of Mr. Candior's to which using firm in Chi

when the latter denied having ever applied for ha had not finished his schoolboy studies, called ler had regarded it a finiently s

The affray was reported to the Central Police publie peussenter had referred in nue of his articles. A Never mind that, I want to know at what

anything more than some samples? He might him various things, and wound my by anging matter to write articles upon it to the Press. Station, and a detachment of Police was des apy of the paper of the data given was set for time - cannot Wenetly fix the time I went at it did not contaju the assay, und tre case was

way st case be baltered bis Lordship would mush for Mr. Bowler."as if to finally completely. As to the question of pricilera, there were our patched to the scous of the disturbance, but by Complainant I deny it. Ife went on, in an tell them the chief sting in the parasquach him after haring deprived bin us all fain bin indications with were privileged, this time the number of Chinese man-of-war s adjourned to allow prosecutor to produce it.

wwer to further questione to give the same expla graph complained of antion of the differmos botwoan

was the statement character (Laughter. Had he written anything and his Lordship proceeded to specify them had increased considerably, and a free hand. Mr. Dowlait may have been in 1876 or those of Professor Mine as befogares and that the oorplainsus had written what was falss approaching that? Had his writing ever been. This, however, was not, on absolutely privile.to-hand fight ensued, as soon as any arrest was 24th August

1875, I cannot any exactly. Somewhere about Dafnadant-Yuussy herayon have seen a speci- pressinus such as "medillesono busybody", ko, plainant agaid gave his explanation. as to the and the editor of a newspaper had no mere right armed with long awords, usad them freely, and the and what he knew to be falsThe other extingad by such sourvilone personalities? Com- ged publiection. This was newspaper criticism. attemptod to be made. The Police sergents, The boring of th

han yours ago.

mon of the ore which would answer Professor were not libellous. Prizia facie to state that a difference between the result of his assay of the than any other person to express opinions upon had just boughtinta aso. The result wasthat seven cris. was resumed this Then how could yoo tell ail that you have Milne's descriptioa: Whore have you soon it.

Chinoss brought the Japanese swords which they rittou re if you had not seen the place

man had pulled what be kaow to be false was ora of the mino and that of Professor Milne other poopla. He could, however, criticise fairly. Beforehnything further is done for ten years, and you kml

Complainant-I refuse to answer the question distinctly libellous; but it was not libelivna in a pointed out passages in the correspondence, and bonestly and atats what he believed to Chinese were killed, and some twenty more or less dek gone fordship to allow it opened?--The place was well opened my gaarrel. (After a panss)--I amend my state sud if the jury believed the evidence he had clearly drawn there between rough and olonned Imep tho palio right, and expose any the Japavoss had four Police constables killed,..

Deed but I do not wish to mix other people up in this case under the jastillation he had shown, and be submitted that the distinction was very he right. His duty as a public writer was to injured; of which nambor oight have died since dr with to what appare by a quarry 100 feet dop, and that quarryment, I will tell it. I saw it in the possession of called us to that, they would retorn a verdict of are: After soms Enrther reference to the artistes aniso presentations that might be made ou

and about fifteen wounded. Among the Chinese Pelas nutter, the fall ernilicances hen worked perbapa ¿0') or 500 years The Mr. Chin, at his place; I am willing to put you I not guity. The complainant had made three he had pablished, Mr. Bowier proceeded to refer matters of public interest. This was what the killed are two offlers, who worò attacked when of wines far to fee yesterday. Gul the wh le place was thoroughly harrowed and under- in communication with Ein if you like. It is positive assertinus with regard to the mining to the evidence which Mr, Candler land given and defendant id he did, it was for the jury to non- detendat made the etatement that I lave been ained I bays written an account of if guilty of Cheiniraus audindeuat action of writ The defendant propended to address some ro place in Canton. It way through him the ming monatopinion, but as funts (Defendant read some contradicted him as to the samples of rook pro-

Str. Chin Po Ting. I think. I saw it in his company, not merely a statements of profes-to-the w Mr. Stanton and himmelf had Hetly sider whether it was ao, or whether be bad Those of the Japaness who wore hors de comat ing plate letter to thejunge after the defend marks to the jury about the complainant having was sold to Mr. He Amei.

"been aetunted' by malice. As to the onse were removed to the Government Hospital, and had been conuitied for trial. I think the written these remarks abeat the mine when be What sort of play was it ?I refuse to tell and lead per ton of his sony, and the sassy of He thought the jury wunld beltare such a'wit- have applies to the present, as if the two foreigu doctors residing on shore and the

extracts from his article se to the result in silver duood having come from the Tsi Ya Shae mine. defendant should be made to ons to the Italian cruisen Rapide. the defendant hd first rsterred to it might whilst the Chinese were attended to by the called him to order, and told him to confine him get paas map of Canton if you like, and point thing at all about what he was writing he must such as ran the defendant wall not venture to in his correspondence. The had not done pestive ships. The affray, of course, left the His Lortkip-There is unreason to say any self to questions for the present; ho was not out its position to you.

They wore afterwards sent aboard their res thing about that now. I said yesterday there then addressing the jury; We foundation whatever for the statement,

His Lordship--There must be some, limit to and if he did not know what he was writing about that rock never came from Tai Yu Shan, and he directed szolusively against Mr. Candler. His foreign a well as the active population in con-

have known he was writing what was false cast aspersions upon. Mr. Candler had sworn however, for what attacks he had made had beer al there is no reason to refer to the matter defendunt the complainant explained that the

In answer to some further questions frons the this; will gau confine yourself to simple answers, he was equally guilty as if he know it was false. The had also sworn that complainant had importuned Lordship had no hesitation in saying that the derable consternation for a day or two, hot c now Just got into the box, Mr Bowler Have fam Chow mixes were not ally at Tam Chow,

nuredweight in tay you saw three or four jury had mean what the prosector and wid about him for employment. He but sworn that he oftack the complainant had usato spor M-Cand the 16th inet everything soomed-gaist, and you got the paper you spoke of yesterday? but at a small village called Tal Kong. The

Complainant (walking) to the boxIt is a town of Tam Chow was at one side of a hill, and I took samples from them, and gave several saw he was stultifying himself. He went on and the Canton steamboat. It was for the jury to Mr. Phillips. The whale of the latter had reference being stopped. Even the stewards of the war- Complainant--I did not merely look at them, rented what he said about a misprint because be until recently he. happened, to meet him onto Mr. Cruder's visit to the Ciril Hospita! to see by eli leave of the Chinese [taen-of-war'u Toon his ten ounces and his 120 peness. How ke oor dil zot, and that he mayor saw Mr, Candler eritfalse, analibelous. The whole latter applied repetition of the encounter has boga prevouted falsabond, an orgnated falsehood.

Complainant then produced a copy of the called Tam Chow, taking its name from the bill, was before this mins and been began to be into the mire, where he might tonimy. (Laughter). Ia peator Stanton's whether they blered him had heard the evidenon which had been given on

the mines at another, but the wasje dietrist was appoiaens to gentlower in this colony. That stultified bimself again, gettingdeeper and despor way in the face of bis evidenes end that of to Mr. Chudlər, not the defendant The jaryships are not permitted to go on shore, and pre- Henghong Telegraph dated 14th April, 1885, The ming wern six or even miles from the town work, before Mr. Candler had been engaged,

visions are brought aboard An enquiry was to mail supplement in which the writer referred to a of Tam Chow, letter of complainant published on the 25th No.

As to what the prosenator hit sald about the Mr. Gandler. He had never appled for an aither side, and it was for the Jary to consider mice on the 17th last. The Chinese Defendant-You never discovered that till you say by Professor Milne and after some querur been there until last Fabrway, and that he Viceroy.

Defendant again referred to the result of the Tomehow Mines, defendant did not helface he had playmont to Me Cazalon, but he had to the whether Ms. Candler bed, does what Mr. Towlessandron was exported to loare Nagasaki for vember. The prosocator also said it was a cri went there a short time ago,

tions of that point to another article of the dom, nuper Ahograzed where there mine were qui!!! His Liqiship-That is of no importance.

alleged by bin jetter. His Lordshth road same Fort Hamilton, es route to Chatoo, by the end patraste from a copied authority spoke of the rock.

Presenter-No mistake, I saw him: strike Tout sévéra! bzes. Uve of us is telling a lie.

Defentant-Aud I am going to prove which. His Lordship-It door not affect publier Defendant-But if I was in Amoy I could not

be here.

Prosentor-Heid just come back from

Amor.

The defendant was proceeding with further questions in this direction when the complainant refused to answer thom.

it.

His Lordship-You have power to refuse to answer, hat the jury will draw their own infersmelted it at once.

eure from it.

Prosentor then got in the box to give rebut Mr. Bowler said he had told the jury all about tingevidnes. Haid-Mr.Candler stated I had this a little while ago. frequently importane him to give me employ

Defendant-Have you boon employed by any nukt I saw but witness for toe first time on body bere as a guologist daring the time you the Canton atomer a few months ago; I had bingo been here?—Yes, five or six times I basa nycor seno bim boloro.

In 1870, is statement was a lionde repris and boun paid for them. a black lie.

in the month of November, I received two fees His Lordship said it would be sufficient to say for asys; that I can prove by a leading fra it. was incorrect.

Evidence continund-is statement about wy

I shall act ask you to prove it, it is not worth asking for a munib is falsa a far days after while When did you first go to Tamaher his arrival I heard that a Frofessor Caudler was In 1872 or 1873, Think 1874, somewhere there. staying at the Sharosa Clab. I did not know abouts. I am not exactly certain. I was taken he was acneered with mining. I called an him.there by two Chiesa stone-cutane

but was told he was out.

hare.

I was informed after- His Lordship toll the complsivant simply wards who he was. I swear on my onth Mr. Answer the questions.

Castor's description of Tai Yu Shan was ridical- ous nonsense. I are on the table there in

of granite which is the counter rock of that lod

I have there is nomo quarte porphyry. There

in form

.44

some way.

And you saw the mines now being worked by the Tamelow Mining Company then?

there.

►

His Lordship About

not

i

A

Complainsut I am not aware of it. Defendaat-Then you ocght to be.

hundredweights in Inge

describe it, my Lord.

His Lordship Or say he swore falsely..

Of Bouham

FATAU AFPRAY AT NAĞARAKI.

in the act of trying to quoll the disturbance,